Currently reading: Buy them before we do: second-hand picks for 28 February
Quirky cars that won't break the bank is the theme for this week's picks. First on the list? A £3000 Audi A2

Our selection of affordable mould-breakers kicks off with the chic A2. Launched in 2000, it was not only the first European production car to average 94mpg but also the first mass-market vehicle to feature weight-saving concepts in its construction, with aluminium the principal material.

The UK got very few of the economy-busting 1.2-litre diesel versions. Instead, buyers could choose from 1.4 and 1.6-litre petrols, and a 1.4-litre diesel in two outputs. Today, it’s the 1.4 petrol and lower-powered 1.4 diesel (they each produce 74bhp) that appear to have weathered best. The direct-injection system in the 1.6 petrol can be troublesome, ditto the dual-mass flywheel in the 89bhp 1.4 diesel. This engine’s turbo suffers carbon build-up, too.

At this age, provenance, condition and history should be uppermost in your mind. Find a good one and you could be sitting on a future classic.

9 Audi a2 stationary side

We think we have, although the 2002-reg car is a little pricey and its mileage – 28,000 – is a concern. It doesn’t bode well for the condition of the cylinder bores and anything else that has had to work in the cold with insufficient oil. Fortunately it has a full service history, although we’d like to know if that means a fettle each year or every 10,000 miles.

This engine can suffer coil pack issues (we found an example claiming all packs had been replaced). We wouldn’t expect our car’s cabin to be much worn, but the satin finish on controls can wear away. Checking the oil is a simple job of opening the front flap. To raise the bonnet you release a couple of catches and away it comes.

8 Mercedes a190 elegance stationary side

Advertisement

Read our review

Car review

It promises unrivalled off-road performance with on-road niceties. But does it deliver?

Back to top

Mercedes A190 Elegance, £1495: The Mercedes-Benz A-Class of 1997 was a mould-breaker for its Mercedes-Benz C-Class-size accommodation in a small footprint with an engine designed to slip safely away under the car in a crash. We spied an immaculate 2002-reg with 39,000 miles and full service history.

7 Bmw 745i se auto stationary side

BMW 745i SE auto, £5950: “Only people who say ‘I’ve got to not like something’ have a problem with it,” said Chris Bangle in defence of his E65 7 Series of 2001. This 2004- reg 745i SE has all the gizmos, a full BMW history and one owner, proving Bangle hit the bullseye.

6 Mazda rx 8 stationary side

Back to top

Mazda RX-8, £3995: The RX-8 wasn’t the first car with a rotary engine but it’s the only one with rear ‘suicide’ doors. Motors can last 100,000 miles or so, so we plumped for this 2008-reg, one-owner example with 47,000 miles and a recent compression test.

5 Volvo 850 t5r stationary front

Volvo 850 T-5R estate, £7989: The 850 T-5R of 1995 changed people’s perception of Volvo, although in subsequent years the car maker did little to build on it. But it was fun while it lasted. Our find, a right-hand-drive import from Japan, has just 69,000 miles and is rust-free.

Auction watch

4 Land rover defender works v8 stationary side

Back to top

Land Rover Defender Works V8: Production of the old Defender ceased in 2016 but as minds turned to its replacement, Land Rover celebrated the model’s 70th anniversary in 2018 with the launch of the Works V8. Powered by a 5.0-litre Jaguar engine producing 399bhp and 380lb ft and with an eight-speed automatic gearbox, the new edition was built around specially selected examples of nearly new Defender 90s and 110s. Land Rover’s Classic division assembled 150 of them. Prices started at £150,000 and within a month they’d sold out. A 90 Works with 57 miles was sold at auction recently for £129,000. No investment, then.

Future classic

3 Toyota celica gt stationary front

Toyota Celica 1.8 VVTL-I GT, £5490: Not an obvious future classic, but the seventh-generation Toyota Celica GT of 2006 has many of the qualities necessary to qualify. For one thing, it’s a dedicated coupé and not a hatchback with the rear doors filled in. It looks the part, too, with its reduced ride height compared with the standard model, its oversized, Supra-like rear spoiler and its neatly integrated bodykit. Also in the mix is a revvy, variable-valve 1.8-litre motor and a sweet-changing six-speed ’box. Finally, few exist and it was made by Toyota, so it’ll never break.

Clash of the classifieds

Brief: Find me a Ferrari-beater for less than £35,000.

Back to top

2 Chevrolet corvette z06 stationary front

Chevrolet Corvette Z06, £34,970

1 Audi r8 v8 stationary front

Audi R8 V8, £34,995

Max Adams: When you need to outmuscle a Ferrari, get yourself a Corvette. But not just any old ’Vette; find a Z06 as I’ve done and you’ll have a monster 7.0-litre V8 with 505bhp. What’s more, 0-60mph is rattled off in just 3.9sec and the top speed is 198mph. Beat that, Mr Pearson.

Mark Pearson: Ha! Easy. I don’t have to dazzle with figures ’cos what I’ve got is a manual Audi R8 quattro with just 40,000 miles on the clock. This is the car that shoved it to Ferrari in spectacular fashion: no mid-engined supercar was as finely balanced or as densely engineered. See? It’s a high-performance car for the discerning, unlike that lairy Corvette.

Back to top

MA: I don’t think anyone would describe a Ferrari as being subtle, so my little red 2008 Corvette still fulfils the brief. And it does a dirty great burnout all over it.

MP: Pah! Pumped-up kicks. What you want is maximum on-the-limit driver enjoyment, and guess what gives you that?

MA: A Ferrari, obviously. But the next best thing is my Corvette.

MP: I think you’ll find my 2008 R8 is practically a Lambo.

MA: I think it’s just a jumped-up Audi TT. What say you, John?

Verdict: Cor, that ’Vette looks the business. I’ll take it.

READ MORE

Nearly-new buying guide: Audi Q3 

Audi cuts product portfolio by nearly a third 

Audi Sport to go electric with RS-branded E-tron GT

Join the debate

Comments
2
Add a comment…
catnip 28 February 2020

The RX8 is the perfect

The RX8 is the perfect example of how to fit in rear doors, if you really have to, without spoiling the proportions of the vehicle. Forget shut lines or whether you can see door handles or not, keeping the B-pillar back and the long front doors is what matters.

harf 28 February 2020

Soft spot for RX8

During one of my 2 week long flirtations with autocar  some years back I took the RX8 out as part of one of the features when it was brand new. It’s the only time I’ve driven round in a brand new car and was conscious of how much attention it attracted. It was good fun and it was a cracker - great styling, wonderfully packaged and brisk if not outrageously fast. 

As for me, some bloke called Matt Saunders was there the week before me. Whatever became of him I wonder ;-)