Currently reading: Analysis: 2020 is the year to take emissions targets seriously
Dramatically reducing fleet average emissions is now the priority for car makers, if they are to avoid heavy fines

This year will mark a revolution in new-car selling: for the first time, car makers will place the CO2 output of every model in their ranges at the top of their priority list, outweighing design, performance and other traditional sales points.

The EU’s 95g/km fleet average CO2 regulation – under discussion in Brussels for a decade – means from 2020 every car maker faces significant fines if they miss their target.

With such a long preparation time, car makers have at least had a chance to develop low-CO2 technologies, but most have only fed the improvements through in the past couple of years – and fresh into 2020 we have already seen car makers reshuffling the mix of engines in their model ranges and rushing to introduce low-CO2 models.

Ford, for example, has pruned 2.0 and 1.5-litre petrol engines from the Ford S-Max and Ford Mondeo and will be dropping the thirsty Ford Edge SUV from its range. Meanwhile, Volkswagen and Skoda have canned the most polluting 2.0 TSI petrol motor from its large SUVs.

In fact, data supplied to Autocar by Jato Dynamics indicates that around 184 models have been trimmed from the 7345 variants listed on UK price lists in November 2018 – a small percentage, but an unusual reverse in an industry more used to expanding model ranges.

28 Ford edge

Anecdotally, there is also evidence that waiting lists on some models are unusually long as car makers throttle off supply, especially of lightweight cars like hot hatchbacks with high-emitting powerful engines, because they score very badly under the regulations.

Last month, the Financial Times reported that Mercedes dealers are expecting to have supply of the most polluting AMG models restricted by up to 7.5% in 2020.

There are also suggestions that car makers have been filling their distribution centres with low-CO2 and zero-emission models ready for this month, but did not make them available to customers in 2019.

“We have our suspicions that some battery-electric cars were being built in 2019 and stockpiled ready for sale this year,” analyst Colin Couchman of IHS Markit told Autocar. “There’s a discrepancy between build rates and shipping numbers.”

Back to top

Why would car makers do this? For 2020, to speed up the introduction of battery-electric models, they qualify for ‘super-credits’ under the EU regulation (effectively they count twice towards a car maker’s average), which makes it easier to achieve their target.

There are also UK-specific incentives. For example, battery-electric cars will be zero-rated for BIK (Benefit in Kind) tax for two years from April 2020. So a company car driver – for example, in a Merc C220d AMG Line saloon who switches to a BEV in April – will save £2381 per year in tax alone. “These changes to UK company car taxation are going to give BEV and plug-in sales a significant lift in the UK,” says Matthias Schmidt, a Berlin-based consultant who specialises in low-carbon technologies.

29 Dsc 1723

In the spring Ford, for example, will launch 1.0-litre 48V mild-hybrid Ford Fiesta and Ford Focus models in time for the new company car tax rules, cutting CO2 to 106g/km in the Focus. Expect plenty of similar announcements from other car makers throughout 2020.

There has been a significant switch in the determination of manufacturers to hit their EU target – the prospect of heavy fines has clearly focused minds. And this is despite three trends that have forced up fleet averages in the run-in to January: increasing sales of SUVs, reduced diesel demand and the shift to tougher WLTP regulation.

Back to top

BMW and Ford, which along with JLR and VW were in the bottom five of a PA Consulting CO2 study last year, are now explicitly saying they will hit their target. Mercedes, also in the bottom five, says it is its “goal” to do so. 

Greg Archer of Transport and Environment (T&E), whose lobbying partly shaped the EU regulation, is not so sure the industry will be able to turn around its performance so easily.

“It will require a high level of electrification and while the 2020 target might be achievable, in 2021 there is a risk of three car makers incurring penalties,”

T&E published a report in September that outlined four strategies car makers could take and, depending on how they are introduced on individual models, these will influence the chances of hitting the target.

Whatever happens, the job of car company bosses to get the right mix of low-CO2 models is their new challenge. This year, car buyers can expect model ranges to evolve with the emphasis on hybrids, plug-ins and electrification and not on lightweight cars with powerful engines.

How the EU regulations work

27 Up gti

The headline figure is 95g/km. But during the political horse-trading in Brussels as the figures were agreed, the German and UK industry succeeded in tweaking the regulation so that weight was taken into account – ensuring it could work for heavier luxury cars as well as lighter ones.

Back to top

As a result, Fiat Chrysler Automobiles, with a range dominated by small cars, has a target of 92g/km in 2020, while BMW has 102g/km.

But Autocar understands the figure will change for 2021. That’s also when an exemption for the top five percent highest emitters will expire.

Each company average is built up from CO2 target figures calculated for individual models and based on a reference mass of 1379.88kg (about the weight of a BMW 1 Series).

The formula is: CO2 Target = 95 + [0.033 x (Model Mass – 1379.88kg)]

Taking a model such as the BMW 116d SE, which weighs 1440kg, its CO2 target is: 95 + [0.033 (1440 – 1379.88)] = 95 + [1.98] = 97.0g/km. The 116d is rated at 111g/km, so is subject to a fine of €95 (£81) per g/km over the target, per car sold.

The lightweight 1100kg but 120g/km VW Up GTi is a particular loser, facing a possible fine of around €3252 (£2771) per car.


Car ownership “not compatible” with emissions targets

Hydrogen is key for meeting emissions targets, says Hyundai

Opinion: The UK car industry's 2021 Brexit timebomb

Join the debate

Add a comment…
artill 20 January 2020

Assuming you have a nice car

Assuming you have a nice car now, its going to be hard to tempt people to buy something inferior for more money. I see a very tough time ahead for car makers, and those selling new cars.

One day EVs will be better, and cheaper, and might make a decent purchase but for the next few years who really wants an emasculated ICE car?

comment8 20 January 2020

Unintended Consequences

Thanks the last minute weight factor industry lobbying for the Up!'s demise though truth be told 1100kg  is not light at all for a car this size with a 3-pot. PSA have down the hard yards and plenty of their small cars slip under 1000kg with consequent lower emissions. The new Golf 8 uses the old and relatively heavy Golf 7 MQB architecture so expect a big push on the ID3 and raive reviews from the press. The press also face an extistential threat after years of all care for performance and zero care for emissions. 

Deputy 20 January 2020

Is your maths right on the VW Up GTi?

I thought the aim was to penalise heavy vehicles that go over the target.  Doesn't the formula above work differently if it's lighter the 1379Kg?  I could be wrong....

JacobE 20 January 2020

Ligthweight suffers

Deputy wrote:

I thought the aim was to penalise heavy vehicles that go over the target.  Doesn't the formula above work differently if it's lighter the 1379Kg?  I could be wrong....

Given the formula lightweights suffer because the 95g/km is actually lowered. So say the UP is 1100 kgs with 120g/km. It's target becomes

95+(0.033*(1100-1379)) = 95 + (-9.2) so about 84g/km.

Given the 34.2g/km over target I come out at the same figure as Autocar. Main point, low weight and high power is hugely penalised.