From £22,0608
Big improvements in practicality and refinement serve BMW’s bottom-rung model well on UK roads, and the loss of a driven rear axle is nothing to mourn.

Our Verdict

BMW 1 Series 118i 2019 road test review -

Is BMW’s Golf-rivalling hatchback a better car for ditching rear-wheel drive?

Matt Saunders Autocar
27 September 2019
BMW 1 Series 118i M Sport 2019 UK

What is it?

The third-generation BMW 1-Series hatchback, which has now landed in the UK. And, while it may not be a widely held opinion of any new BMW right now, I’d say that it looks, more or less, like it ought to.

Because it looks nothing at all like a traditional three-box saloon of the 1980s, of course, some will call this car inauthentic – but I’d bet that few of the younger customers at whom BMW is aiming this car will be among them. For your average 2019 thirty-something car-buyer, after all, a typical modern BMW is an X1, an X3 or perhaps a 2-Series Active Tourer – those being the modern BMWs we now see the most of.

If that typical buyer is familiar with an ‘E34’ 5-Series saloon at all, meanwhile, he’ll probably know no part or facet of it more intimately than his memory can conjure of the patterned cloth on the front seatback. Times, they are a changing – and it’s the job of this car, perhaps more than any other, to change BMW’s customer base.

Were you to point out that the styling robs the 1-Series of some of the old models’ distinctiveness, of course, I wouldn’t argue. But wasn’t that inevitable? The ‘F40’-generation car looks a bit Lexusey from the rear, as the 3-Series does – while the adoption of plenty of wedgy, creasy attitude into the frontal aspect and profile doesn’t set it apart from hatchback rivals quite as clearly as intended. Nevertheless, it’s smart enough and doesn’t offend – not, at least, to my eyes.

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

The new 1-Series lineup includes diesel engines ranging from 114bhp 116d to 188bhp 120d xDrive, while the petrols take in the range-topping M135i xDrive (on which a group test is in the pipeline) and this 138bhp 118i. Prices start just below £25,000, and the trim level walk is a familiar progression from SE, through Sport, up to M Sport – with the usual bundled options packages to beef up your equipment level.

For suspension SE- and Sport-spec cars gets standard coil springs; M Sports get lowered, stiffened passive suspension; and adaptive dampers are optional – although can’t be combined with the very biggest 19in alloys of the range or with BMW’s M Sport Plus package (which gets you uprated brakes and a variable-ratio M Sport steering setup).

Our test car has the passive M Sport springs, optional 19in wheels, conventional non-runflat tyres, as well as the car’s standard six-speed manual gearbox. The automatic option is either a seven-speed twin-clutcher or an eight-speed torque converter depending on engine choice (the latter is standard-fit with 120d- and M135i xDrive models).

What's it like?

Moving onto the same model platform as the Mini Clubman and most of BMW’s other compact models, the new 1-Series is slightly shorter than the last – but, because it’s wider too and also because you sit higher up within it, doesn’t feel any smaller. The car is, unsurprisingly, almost exactly as wide as the aforementioned Mini with all-but-identical track widths both to those of the Mini and the BMW X1.

It’s undoubtedly a more spacious and usable car than its forebear, with very respectable amounts of room in the second-row and boot – not least, you suspect, because of the less recumbent layout of the whole car. Perceived cabin quality has taken less of a transformative leap, though; you’ll find harder, wobblier trims as well as pudgy, pleasant ones without searching for long, and so the car’s aura of expensive material solidity isn’t quite as convincing as it might be.

The car’s onboard technology showing isn’t lacking. You get an 8.8in touchscreen infotainment system as standard even on entry-level cars, along with a partly digital instrument setup – and can upgrade to a bigger central display and BMW’s fully digital Live Cockpit Professional instruments, a Harman Kardon premium audio system and better connected services for a not-unreasonable £1500. Less reasonable is the fact that you still don’t get Apple CarPlay smartphone connectivity as standard, but rather as part of BMW’s Connected Drive subscription. Not good enough, BMW. I liked the crisp, responsive infotainment setup particularly since it retains BMW’s rotary iDrive controller; but I liked the digital instruments less, which still seem to me to prioritise style over legibility and don’t offer enough adaptability in their layout.

Out on the road, even in M Sport trim, on optional 19in wheels and with BMW M Sport Plus package equipped, the 1-Series behaves in a more refined and well-rounded way than the old 1-Series ever did. BMW’s three-pot petrol engine is pretty quiet and smooth, and has a responsive power delivery and a broad spread of torque, so you can adopt a fairly brisk stride easily enough. It’s not the sort of three-pot you feel inclined to rev beyond 5000rpm, but it’ll oblige when it needs to. Despite the slightly discouragingly long gear ratios of the car’s six-speed manual gearbox, however, it’s not the sort of three-pot to return particularly impressive real-world fuel economy – the car indicating just shy of 40mpg on our mixed test route. Used more intensively on motorways and cruising more consistently, that return might improve a little.

The car’s ride is firm but fairly settled and well isolated considering its sportier tuning, except over the very sharpest ridges which are dealt with slightly brusquely. Body control is good and handling precise and purposeful, without feeling particularly agile or desperately engaging.

If you expected BMW’s chassis engineers to respond to the technical shift that this car has been through by making it the best-handling car in its class in spite of it all, you’re in for minor disappointment, then. There’s more measure and pragmatism in the new 1-Series’ dynamic makeup than that assumption would imply. It doesn’t dart into corners but rather turns smartly yet progressively, almost as if, after this car’s recent history, Munich had decided that it was a mistake to attempt to make a premium hatchback really ‘fun to drive’. 

There’s certainly enough steering feedback on offer to keep you interested in what’s going on under-wheel, however, while the car’s high grip levels and its impressive handling accuracy and damper control all combine to make it as easy to hurry along quickly as some might assume that a typical BMW driver would want it to be.

Should I buy one?

The new 1-Series would beat most family hatchbacks for driver appeal, then, albeit perhaps not all of them – and some of them not by much.

It’s certainly a better modern hatchback for being a more conventional, front-wheel drive one; especially since, in reality, a driven rear axle never did many dynamic favours for its predecessors anyway. And if you’re surprised that I left out such an apparently important technical fact until the final par, don’t be; this was the car that BMW compromised in myriad ways to make it ‘standard drive’, only to discover years later through market research that the vast majority of 1-Series owners neither knew nor cared that they’d bothered.

Playing by the class’ technical rulebook has undoubtedly given BMW’s A-Class-chasing hatchback a better chance of winning some ground back in its eternal struggle with its old Teutonic rivals – and while it hasn’t made the new 1-Series a dynamic world-beater, it hasn’t made it boring to drive either.

BMW 1 Series 118i M Sport specification

Where Hastings, UK Price £27, 230 On sale now Engine 3cyls inline, 1499cc, turbocharged, petrol Power 138bhp at 4600-6500rpm Torque 162lb ft at 1480-4200rpm Gearbox 6-spd manual Kerb weight 1290kg Top speed 132mph 0-62mph 8.5sec Fuel economy 47-1-45.6mpg (WLTP Combined) CO2 WLTP figures unavailable Rivals VW Golf 1.5 TSI Evo GT, Mercedes A180 AMG Line

Join the debate

Comments
30

27 September 2019
... maybe for you it isn't. For me its simply the reason to not even consider that car.

27 September 2019

Wow... Damning with faint praise if i ever saw it.

 

Not too angry that BMW went the FWD way with the 1er, seeing as the 2er Coupe will still be RWD, but the fact that it's only marginally bigger inside than the old one, with lower quality materials and finish, at the same price... No, thank you.

 

Not even going to comment on the looks. BMWs have been getting uglier with every passing gen, but they keep on selling more and more of them, so what do i know. 

27 September 2019

...except the ugly styling.

Although by BMW’s recent standards it’s just about tolerable.....but not desirable.

27 September 2019

This is a like a half warm bowl of porridge.  And an ugly one at that.

4 stars for this?   Autocar needs to have a re-think....

 

Nothing now to differentiate this from the rest of the small hatchback herd.

 

 

30 September 2019
Cenuijmu wrote:

This is a like a half warm bowl of porridge.  And an ugly one at that.

4 stars for this?   Autocar needs to have a re-think....

Tell us more about how wrong Autocar are, when your body knowledge and experience of this car is a few pictures on the internet...

27 September 2019
I don't think it's ugly, just a bit generic, could be a ceed or focus etc in side profile but as the reviewer said, it's certainly not offensive. As for the loss of rwd, well it makes sense really, it's competitors are all fwd and none the worse for it, the focus has always been lauded as one of if not the best drivers car of its type, beating the rwd 1, rwd is a compromise for most ordinary family cars and considering the competence and ability of fwd, an unnecessary one.

27 September 2019
What if this was an EV? It could still be rear wheel drive, perfect weight distribution, more space, lower running costs...

27 September 2019
...its purchasing cost would be much higher and it would lack the 'fire and forget' flexibility of a petrol or diesel car. Plus, it would be more damaging to the environment.

27 September 2019
Who cares how it drives if it looks like that LOL
BMW probably have most of the top places in the top 50 UGLIEST cars on sale imho

27 September 2019

Not a BMW and ugly.

Sad century.

 

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week