Only the most interesting cars make it onto the Autocar long-term test fleet. But which of our 2017 drives deserve some special recognition? We polled the office to dish out some (imaginary) trophies
31 December 2017

When we're selecting cars to add to our long-term fleet, we're careful to only consider the finest or most interesting machines on the market. Spending an extended period of time in them can reveal hidden depths or faults. So which of the machines we've run on our long-term test fleet in 2017 impressed us the most? We asked around the office - and the results are in.

The Escape to the Country Award for the most fun car to drive

WINNER: Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio - Highly commended: McLaren 570GT, Subaru BRZ  

This developed into a straight battle between world-class British precision engineering and classical Italian charm and character, with the Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio sneaking victory from the McLaren 570GT by the narrowest of margins.

“I was beaming within 100 metres,” reckons editor Mark Tisshaw. “So well engineered, it’s more than the sum of its parts. A near-perfect ride and handling balance, an extraordinary Ferrari V6 engine... I could go on.”

Chief tester Matt Saunders was similarly impressed, noting the Alfa was “capable of brightening any journey with that remarkable rear-drive balance”.

Editorial director Jim Holder led the campaign for the McLaren, saying: “It isn’t just sensational to drive, it can be driven with confidence no matter your level of ability.”

The Subaru BRZ came third, championed by senior staff writer Sam Sheehan, who rarely missed an opportunity to pedal it into the country. Although that could just be a desire to escape Tooting.

Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio long-term updates

The ‘Look At Me, Dammit’ Award for the best car to impress your friends and family with

WINNER: Aston Martin Vanquish S - Highly commended: Mazda MX-5 RF, Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio  

Perhaps predictably, the Aston Martin Vanquish S claimed a dominant win in this category, which will please editor-at-large Matt Prior, since he nominated it for every single award. While many of those submissions required somewhat tortuous logic (he explained the Aston’s city car credentials by saying “you get let out at junctions”), few would quibble with the Vanquish’s victory here.

He said it “looks equally as good at the opera, a race track or on a Tinder date” – which probably says too much about how he spends his weekends...

Matt Saunders noted the Aston did not just stand out for its looks, adding: “It’s louder than the end of the world.”

Showing that its folding hard-top really has added some flair, the Mazda MX-5 RF emerged in a (distant) second place. Staff writer Jimi Beckwith, a man who knows his style (even if it is occasionally questionable), said: “I don’t know if my family are terrible at identifying cars, easily pleased or just humouring me, but the MX-5 RF got as much positive reaction as any of the supercars on our f leet would have.”

Aston Martin Vanquish S long-term updates

The Top Floor of the Waitrose Car Park Award for the easiest car to negotiate in tight spaces and city streets

WINNER: Suzuki Ignis - Highly commended: Bentley Bentayga, Dacia Sandero Stepway LPG 

We’ll get to the winner in a minute. First, an explanation. This award is so named because Autocar Towers shares a ridiculously tight multi-storey car park with a Waitrose, and the ten-storey ascent to our top-floor parking area provides an excellent test of a car’s agility in tight spaces.

So, er, how did Bentley’s massive Bentayga SUV finish second in an award that should be all about small, nimble machines? People have some explaining to do... Let’s start with Dan Prosser: “Concrete walls, small building, other vehicles – all swept aside by the hefty Bentley as though they weren’t there.”

Andrew Frankel, can you do any better? “Because my man could just drive around the block until I was ready to come out. Or, better, I could give him the shopping list and drive around the block until he came out.”

Hmmm. Guess there’s a logic there, of sorts. Still, ultimately – and in one of the unlikeliest paragraphs you’ll have read in Autocar in some time – the Bentley Bentayga was swept aside by the new Suzuki Ignis.

Describing the Ignis as a “top- drawer small car”, Jim Holder said: “Yes, it looks a little dorky, with its high-ride height and short length, but that makes it perfect for urban living.”

Holder added a prediction: “Another car maker will take the formula, make it more stylish, double the price and be hailed for inventing a new type of car.”

Throw in the Kitchen Sink Award for the car more suited to load-lugging

WINNER: Mercedes E220D Estate - Highly commended: Skoda Kodiaq, Volvo V90  

“You have an E-class Estate on this list and still have to ask?” exclaimed Andrew Frankel. Well, yes, we did, actually – while the Mercedes did emerge as our leading load-lugger, it was pushed hard by both the Skoda Kodiaq and Volvo V90.

Executive editor Matt Burt is the custodian of the E220d estate. As the person tasked with keeping our copy clean and precise, his nomination for the Merc displayed laudable brevity: “Obvious, really.”

Picture editor Ben Summerell-Youde championed the Kodiaq, noting: “It’s massive, and I love the ‘Simply Clever’ gubbins throughout.”

Mark Tisshaw was a fan of the V90, explaining: “I went to Ikea purely for the meatballs and some coat hangers. The coat hangers slid so far into the boot, I had to climb inside to retrieve them.”

And, yes, Matt Prior did nominate the Vanquish in this category, too, “because the boot will hold two sets of golf clubs and the rear seats a 5ft 10in child”.

Mercedes-Benz E-class estate long-term updates

The Hashtag Spoiler Alert Award for the car that surprised you the most

WINNER: Mazda MX-5 RF - Highly commended: Suzuki Ignis, Audi S5

There was plenty of diversity in the voting for this award, with the Mazda MX-5 RF claiming a narrow victory for proving that a folding hard-top can add surprising levels of refinement to a fun two-seater.

“I expected big things, but I didn’t expect it to be of such high quality,” said Sam Sheehan. “The feel of the gearshift, the seating position, the placement of the vents directly onto your hands and that lovely coupé roof line. I’m a big fan.”

Digital editor James Attwood ran the MX-5 RF as his long-termer, and said: “The first time I sat in it, with the roof up, it felt incredibly claustrophobic – and I reached straight for the drop-top button. Five months later, I realised I’d spent more time driving it with the roof up – it just felt more refined.”

The Suzuki Ignis’s SUV reinvention meant it nearly snatched this award too, with Matt Saunders pondering: “How you can get so much space into such a small car is beyond me.”

But not everyone was a fan: Jimi Beckwith nominated the Ignis because it fell short when it came to fuel economy, and didn’t leave him “with the warm and fuzzies”.

The Audi S5 finished third in the voting, although not for entirely positive reasons. While it could be an engaging drive, the soft-top’s disjointed nature annoyed many. Mark Tisshaw noted: “It surprised me how little the various departments in engineering talked to each other in its development...”

Mazda MX-5 RF long-term updates

Game of Thrones Audiobook Award for the best car for very long journeys

WINNER: Volvo V90 - Highly commended: Mercedes E220D Estate, Bentley Bentayga, Aston Martin Vanquish S 

This was another close scrap between the Mercedes and Volvo estates, with strong campaigns from both the Aston Martin Vanquish S and Bentley Bentayga. But, by a narrow margin, the honours in this category went to Sweden.

“Rides gently, loads of space, awesome seats, practically drives itself, does 45mpg and has a fantastic nav system,” reckoned V90 custodian Matt Saunders. “I will entertain no arguments.”

For the sake of argument, though, Sam Sheehan stuck up for the E220d, describing it as “comfortable, luxurious and quick”. “I can’t think of many cars I’d rather cover great distances in,” he added.

James Attwood championed the Bentley Bentayga, after a 90-minute motorway jaunt. “I had to negotiate the M25 at rush hour yet still emerged from the Bentayga feeling more rested than when I got in it,” he said.

Volvo V90 long-term updates

The Inspect-a-Gadget Award for the best/most innovative/useful bit of in-car technology

WINNER: Skoda Kodiaq gripping bottle holder - Highly commended: Toyota Prius plug-in solar roof, Ford Mustang line lock mode

This award attracted the widest range of submissions, risking a multi-way tie. So we decided to hand out the prize based on the quality of submission, and the winning entry came from Jim Holder.

He nominated the Skoda Kodiaq’s drinks bottle holder, saying: “Maybe I’ve lived a sheltered life, but I’ve never encountered drinks bottle holders that grip your bottle for you while you unscrew the cap. It’s a pathetically low-tech solution but very effective, and a small but significant step towards safer driving.”

The Kodiaq just edged out the Toyota Prius Plug-in’s solar roof panels. Mark Tisshaw said: “When this thing called the sun comes out, it charges the battery for you.”

What possibly kept the Prius from winning this award was the rubbish British weather, rendering the system somewhat ineffective – and Tisshaw’s admission that the Prius looked “about as attractive as a 1930s semi with solar panels slapped on”.

Not every bit of tech worthy of praise was there to make life easier – such as Andrew Frankel’s nomination of the Ford Mustang’s tyre-shredding line lock mode.

Skoda Kodiaq long-term updates

The 'pick your own' award for a car you think deserves extra recognition

Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadtrifoglio - Mark Tisshaw: “The ‘thank you for not cocking it up’ award. The best car I’ve driven all year.”

Renault Scenic - Matt Saunders: “For being good enough to produce faintly warm sentiments from snapper Luc Lacey, who usually only cracks a smile for 500bhp drift machines.”

Dacia Sandero Stepway LPG - Jim Holder: “A shout-out to the cheapest car we’ve run and proof that LPG could be part of the short-term solution to emissions.”

Aston Martin Vanquish S - Matt Prior: “For being the only car that has ever made me contemplate selling everything I own to buy a car with that shape and a V12 engine.”

Read more

Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio review 

Mazda MX-5 RF review 

Mercedes-Benz E220D review

Our Verdict

Honda Civic

Honda’s 10th-generation Civic hatchback goes global — but is that good news?

Join the debate


31 December 2017

Alfa Romeo may receieve in the short future its first Toni award for long term stay at the workshop. Toni is the well known guy from Fix It Again Toni.

31 December 2017

The "Alfas are unreliable" myth is just that, like the "VWs are incredibly well built and reliable" myth.

XXXX just went POP.

31 December 2017

Further to the above and to regular automotive reporters' complaints regarding FCA reliability: it is time FCA cooperate with a Japanese company in reliability issues in exchane of Italian design.

31 December 2017
sabre wrote:

Further to the above and to regular automotive reporters' complaints regarding FCA reliability: it is time FCA cooperate with a Japanese company in reliability issues in exchane of Italian design.

... or Tesla built in Japan would be ideal.

31 December 2017

FCA is now 4th in reliability in the USA,so they are improving.

31 December 2017

A Jaguar XF and a Land Rover Discovery Sport were also used for long term reviews this year, yet no mention of them above. Do I also detect a lack of the usual expected JLR coverage in other end of year articles? What's up, their 2018 sponsorship cheque hasn't arrived? Autocar and JLR no longer BFF? Or will regular service be resumed in the New Year?

31 December 2017
k12479 wrote:

A Jaguar XF and a Land Rover Discovery Sport were also used for long term reviews this year, yet no mention of them above. Do I also detect a lack of the usual expected JLR coverage in other end of year articles? What's up, their 2018 sponsorship cheque hasn't arrived? Autocar and JLR no longer BFF? Or will regular service be resumed in the New Year?

Yawn, yawn! Get over it or go and read some other free motoring rag instead



You're not stuck in traffic - you are traffic!!

31 December 2017
harf wrote:

Yawn, yawn! Get over it or go...

You don't find it all odd that the XF, rated 4.5 stars, matching the Alfa and the Bentley, and the Discovery Sport, rated 4 stars, matching the Aston, Mazda, Suzuki, Mercedes, Skoda and Volvo and rated higher than the 3.5 star Audi and Renault don't warrant a single mention?

31 December 2017

I've just bought a Skoda which has these grips that supposedly hold the bottle in place whilst you unscrew it. Haven't used it yet so can't comment on how effective it is, but lets assume it works 100% as intended.

autocar wrote:

It’s a pathetically low-tech solution but very effective, and a small but significant step towards safer driving.

Does Autocar realise that here in the UK, you can be prosecuted for careless driving if you're caught drinking at the wheel?

"But your Honour, Autocar said..."

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • First Drive
    23 March 2018
    Fully-loaded, big-hitting diesel CLS shows the potential perils of ticking too many options boxes on your order form. A good car with a bad suspension combination.
  • BMW M5
    First Drive
    22 March 2018
    Super saloon deploys four-wheel drive to improve every facet of its driving experience. Faster and more capable than any, and more exciting than most, of its celebrated predecessors
  • Range Rover Sport SVR
    First Drive
    22 March 2018
    More power and an intoxicating soundtrack have breathed new life into our love affair with the biggest, baddest Range Rover Sport variant
  • First Drive
    21 March 2018
    The new Vantage has been developed as a Porsche 911 beater, and our first taste on UK roads suggests it can live up to that bold claim
  • Nissan Leaf Tekna
    The is the new Nissan Leaf
    First Drive
    21 March 2018
    The new version of the world's best-selling electric car gains a bigger battery and more power. How does it compare to rivals such as the Volkswagen e-Golf?