The 2017 Volkswagen Golf was revealed online earlier today, and has already drawn criticism from some for being too similar to the previous model.
Admittedly, there’s a lot of DNA shared between the cars as it's a facelift, but enough differentiation that an uninformed onlooker could pick out the 2017 model as the newer of the two.
All three cars are absolutely crucial to their brands, core products in their ranges, and their similarity to their predecessors is one of two quite similar, but crucially different things: 1 - the manufacturers’ confidence in the quality of the new model, so much that they know they’ll sell well, or 2 - the manufacturers’ terror that a core model won’t live up to its forebear, so an evolutionary design is essential to not scare away droves of customers.
Alll three - the Golf, the Q5 and the 5 Series will sell by the absolute bucket-load, there’s no doubt about that. But, then again, so did the 5 Series from 10 years ago, designed by the infamous Chris Bangle. To some, it was the most inspiringly daring design that BMW had ever created. With others, it was less well-received. The archetypal automotive example of beauty being in the eye of the beholder.