With the dawn of the all-electric sports car almost upon us, we ponder (in a Cayman GT4) what it means for the true driving enthusiast
Andrew Frankel Autocar
25 August 2019

The cattle-grid rattles under the car. Not for the first time it occurs to you that as a way of heralding the arrival of a great experience, there’s none more understated than the humble cattlegrid. But there they are, at the start and finish of many of the country’s greatest roads. 

You know this car and you know this road. It’s why you’ve brought it here. You know the drill, too: a kick of the clutch and a blip of the throttle. You’ve already decided how many gears you’re going to drop. Then down goes the foot. Let it build. You feel the engine respond and hear it, too: the induction noise hardening, the exhaust note sharpening. The revs rise, but slowly at first. There’s no external assistance from turbos here, but you’re happy to wait. At 4000rpm it starts to build, at 5000rpm it’s beginning to fly. So you let it go, growling and howling its way past 6000, 7000 and onto 8000rpm before you deftly dip the clutch once more, a mere fraction of a second before the limiter cuts in. 

Okay, so the car happens to be a new Porsche Cayman GT4, but in essence, and saving details like where the red line on any given car might be, what I’ve outlined is an experience enjoyed in one form or another by millions of enthusiastic drivers not just for years or even decades, but for more than a century. Good car, good road. Good fun. That really is all there is to it. 

Let’s do it all over again, except we’re a few years into the future and the car is not a 414bhp Porsche but an electric hypercar with around 2000bhp. If you think that sounds like science fiction it’s not: there are already at least three that have been shown with outputs of 1900bhp or more and which are now being readied for production. The cattle grid rattles under the car. There’s no clutch to kick nor even a paddle to pull, let alone a stick to shift. There is no decision-making process because there’s nothing to do. Except put your foot down. You can still do that. So the car now tries to transmit 2000bhp plus all that attendant and instant torque to the road. 

Our Verdict

Porsche 718 Cayman GT4 2019 road test review - hero front

Porsche reprises arguably the finest driver's car of its generation with an all-new engine but the same purist philosophy

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

Of course it has four-wheel drive, but that’s still a 911 GT3’s worth of power per tyre. Of course it can’t dump it all on the Tarmac, which is perhaps as well. Full throttle in a Bugatti Veyron is a pretty bewildering experience and these cars have double the power. I wouldn’t be able to guarantee the security of my breakfast under such an assault. I’d want to know my passenger was in good nick, too, before springing such a surprise. Perhaps a disclaimer on the passenger door, you know, like the ones they put next to the more vomit-inducing rollercoasters. Involuntary acceleration-induced myocardial infarction: the legals would be interesting. 

But that doesn’t happen. The systems kick in and you are hurled forward only at the rate at which your chocolate slicktermediate tyres can handle – which will still be enough to make you feel uncomfortably giddy and your passenger really rather ill. Is that fun? Maybe for some. 

But what then? Well, and just as an example, Lotus says the Evija will get from rest to 186mph in fewer than nine seconds. Well, you’re not going to reach that speed in public and you won’t start from rest. So just how long do you think you’ll be able to bury the throttle – which, remember, is the only thing this car requires you to do to save steer and brake – before some sense, common or survival, makes you lift? How long can this extraordinary but potentially somewhat disquieting experience be enjoyed? Or should I say endured? Not long. And then what? Slow down and do it all over again? 

Perhaps. But with nothing to listen to and nothing to do save flexing a hoof, I think the novelty might soon wear off, and that’s just for the driver. 

I am being mischievous here, because I’m clearly not comparing like with like. We have already reported that the 2022 Cayman will have a fully electric powertrain at least as an option, but it’s not going to have 2000bhp and the car won’t cost £1.7 million-plus. But I’m doing it to illustrate a point, namely that just because it’s easy to provide electric cars with huge power doesn’t mean it’s the right thing to do. But I understand the temptation. How else do you present electrification as interesting to the enthusiast? These are cars that make no sound worth listening to, don’t need gearboxes and deliver all they have to offer at once. They’re long on instant gratification and thereafter worryingly short on giving the driver stuff to do. 

And that’s an enormous problem, not for manufacturers making electric cars as mere transport – in fact, for them it’s probably a net bonus – but for those with reputations for producing genuinely fun and sporting cars to maintain. As statements of the bleedin’ obvious go, to observe that the more involving a car is, the more involved its driver will be is right up there with the best. But so too is it true. 

The reason I love old cars is that they’re mostly rubbish. If they are to conduct themselves from one place to the next with any degree of decorum, you have no choice but to get involved. And that means there’s always stuff to do. Among your many other roles, you are the engine management, responsible for using the tools at your disposal – the clutch and gearbox – for ensuring the motor remains in that narrow band where it sounds and performs the best. And that’s not just fun, if you get it right it’s pretty satisfying, too. 

Back in the near future you could, of course, synthesise much of what has been lost, and perhaps that will happen. The car you drive now is perhaps already synthesising more than you might imagine, from the feel of its electric steering to the sound of its engine. So why not equip your electric car with a sound selector? You could go to work sounding like an Italian V12 and come home sounding like an American V8. But there’s still no gearbox. No, but you could programme the electric motors to behave as if there were and tailor the sound to suit. You could choose your own ratios, too. All seems a bit artificial, doesn’t it? But then so is life, increasingly. I read that E-sports (which I don’t understand at all) is now a $1 billion industry with close to half a billion viewers, and they all know that what they’re doing or watching isn’t real, so maybe it doesn’t matter. 

In some areas electric sports cars will be better than those we have now because they will be able to let you enjoy driving in ways that are either impossible or unwise today. People like me love to talk about sliding cars, but you can’t just oversteer anywhere on demand, even in a car like a Cayman GT4, at least not safely. Electric cars promise to bring a new level of controllability, because power can be released to the four corners of the car and controlled to the last electron in a way that’s simply not possible with the blunt instrument that is even the sharpest of internal combustion engines. And it doesn’t stop there. Remember that electric cars can put their centres of gravity at earthworm altitude and that while they seem hopelessly heavy right now, they’re already getting lighter, and that process will accelerate dramatically when someone in the near future works out how to productionise a solid-state battery

So it’s far from all doom and gloom and I’m trying to figure out whether it says more about me or the cars of the future that I’m still struggling to get excited about it. How important is it that what is perceived is the same as what is actually happening? A sound is a sound and a slide a slide – why should it matter whether they occur naturally or are manufactured in laboratories? But it does matter, at least to me, and for two reasons. One is the same reason my wristwatch is mechanical rather than electronic, even though that makes it both far more expensive and less accurate than it could be. I like engineering, oil and metal, cog and wheel engineering. It feels authentic. I can see how you can synthesise almost any noise, and even almost any feeling. But you can’t synthesise character. The greatest appeal of the Cayman GT4 is not its speed or grip, nor its balance and poise. It’s the car’s character; it is what makes me want to drive it. And you can’t fake that. 

Stuck in the past though I must accept I am, my second concern lies far into the future: follow the logical progression as cars become electrified, their sound, feel, action and reaction increasingly synthesised. Where does that road end for the enthusiast? In an arcade game that marketing departments will call a simulator, where you can oversteer to your heart’s content without wearing out your tyres, annoying the public, parking your car in a field or spending hours getting to the right road and back. Then all those selfish speed demons and road hogs who once had the temerity to try to enjoy driving in public can be confined to practicing electronic automotive onanism, safe and secure in their own bedrooms. 

If that sounds like fun to you, good luck. For me, and for as long as I still can, I’ll stick to driving real cars on real roads. It’s an effort for sure, but I’ve never come across a proper enthusiast who didn’t think the effort was worth it.

Solid-state batteries: the answer to the enthusiast’s prayers?

Possibly. Probably, even. But not definitely. On paper we all stand to benefit from solid-state batteries in cars because they charge quicker and go farther. But enthusiasts stand to gain the most because they are lighter and need a fraction of the cooling required by conventional lithium ion batteries. 

That in turns means cars won’t need such robust structures or suspension to support them and will be able to use narrower tyres, smaller brakes and so on. As with every time you deduct weight from a car, this is the circle of virtue in which you exist. 

But you’re still dealing with a battery so it’ll not sound any better. And while the theory of solid-state batteries is sound, finding an electrolyte that actually works in practice and which can then be produced reliably and affordably by the million remains very much work in progress. 

James Dyson appears to have bet the farm on the technology, while Toyota reckons it will unveil a car with a solid-state battery next year – but whether it will actually put one on sale is another matter altogether. 

But you only have to look at the Prius to know that when Toyota starts making noises about new technology, it’s not doing it just to grab the headlines.

The first (and only) sports EV

Evidence of just how thorny a problem designing a purely sporting electric car can be is found in the fact that, to date, only one person has tried. And they didn’t get very far. One of the most trenchant critics of the original Tesla Roadster is none other than Elon Musk himself, who loved his so much he shot it into space. 

The truth was that while the Roadster was interesting, it just didn’t work in reality. It was quick but prohibitively expensive, had a deathly dull sound and at least in its early days was at times more than a little lacking in the reliability area. Worse was the decision to base it around the platform of a Lotus Elise. For a start it required so much modification that Musk described it as like deciding to do up your house and ending with just one basement wall of the original structure still standing. It sat on a slightly lengthened wheelbase which would not have helped agility, but worse – far worse – was the fact that it weighed around 1300kg, or at least half as much again as the Elise. 

I drove one once, briefly, found the exercise of academic interest alone and wondered then as I do now how an electrical architecture can be adapted into providing a truly inspirational powertrain.

Read more

Porsche 718 Cayman GT4 UK review​

2022 Porsche Boxster and Cayman to get hybrid and EV options​

The ultimate motoring bucket list, according to Autocar writers

Join the debate

Comments
18

25 August 2019

As ever a really good article from Andrew Frankel, but I think there is another looming issue which is bound to influence the future of driving in the UK and Europe generally. That is the EU proposal to introduce speed limiters to all new cars from, I understand, 2022. A road safety measure I would agree, but also the slippery slope to speed and journey logging. You don’t need much imagination to realise where this will lead if you enjoy driving in a “spirited” fashion on the kind of rural road described in Andrew’s article.

The supposed freedom of the open road, with the ability to safely use the performance of a suitable car in the right circumstances, has long been a joy for driving enthusiasts. Changing legislation and electrification will change the face of driving and this is inevitable. On the plus side there is great scope for improving road safety and, having recently bought my first hybrid car, I can see the appeal of growing electrification. On a personal note, I can also say that some of my greatest car journeys have resulted from the beauty and challenge of the environment, not pushing the car to its limits or particularly thinking about the power source.

25 August 2019
This is such a daft topic. Nobody's ever said that a go kart isn't fun because it just has the one gear (and most cars - super or otherwise - are driven as automatics now anyway).

Also, cars with a genuinely great exhaust note are increasingly few on the ground. I'd rather have an electric car, in which you get sci-fi motor noises and a deeper connection to what the tires are doing, than have the world drowned out by the farty drone of a four-pot with an antisocial exhaust mod.

You don't need massive horsepower to have fun in an electric car (I've had more fun driving a 180bhp i3S at Silverstone than a 200bhp GT86 or 500bhp Gallardo). If you think it's one-dimensional, you're not doing it right.

25 August 2019

Andrew, I'm thankful that you continue to write the unpalatable about the future of driving for car enthusiasts. I get very tired of reading rose-tinted articles by motoring journalists who, hoping they won't be losing their jobs, constantly tell us how exciting electric cars will be. And let's not forget those with heavy financial investments to promote their E - racing involvement (yawn). Yes, I'm talking about you, Nico Rosberg. A man who believes F! should go electric.

Yes, electric cars can be ultra-fast, so what? If you believe that speed-alone should excite car enthusiasts, you obviously are not one of us. Once you stopped giggling after you have taken off from the 'lights' at warp speed (looking like a complete jerk in the process), what's next? The mechanical sounds, 'feel' and interaction of a petrol-powered are in no way replicated by an electric car. Electric cars are very fast, so what? So is a Jumbo Jet - how exciting is that when you're cruising the skies 920 kph? Besides, how does this warp-speed capability equate with our upcoming GPS-controlled speed limiters?

And, sorry to disagree with 'TheDriver', if I'm on a great driving road with next to no traffic, I'll be exploring the delights of my car, not gazing at the scenery. I'm never going to be pushing any limits (that's for tracks only), but I'll be enjoying the sound of the engine, the handling balance and making the most of my manual gearbox. Brisk enough to have fun. 

I'm not in any way a climate change denier, I'm just sad that a cleaner future is likely to make motoring a thoroughly dull affair for true car enthusiasts. 

25 August 2019

I suppose the real message behind this is that we won’t need motoring journalists any more as we already know what the car sounds like and there’s no gearbox. Actually, I welcome the electric car as the overall standards of an average car will be higher. It will be faster, cleaner and quieter with fewer bits to go wrong. 95% (at least) of our journeys will be improved in that basis, and I’m pretty sure we will still be capable of enjoying the other 5%. 

The article would have been much more interesting if it had talked about the joy of a near silent convertible, or how much better 4wd traction will be with each wheel monitored.

25 August 2019
As a owner of an electric car for 5 years, it's a fine car for the 60 mile found trip for work, but a fun and involving drive it is not.

That's why I've got a weekend car. It's a low tech NA manual, tucked away in the garage for when I want to drive for enjoyment. They'll never make them like that again, not with the continued progression in regulations.

25 August 2019

 Transportation has to change, more and more Cars on the Roads year on year, if you live in a City you’ll no the daily drudge of commuting, so every so often it’s nice to squeeze the throttle pedal a little bit harder, enjoy the sudden rush forward, feel the G force increase round a Corner, this isn’t going to go over night, we’re suddenly not going to be watched every second we’re driving, it won’t affect my generation, we’ve had our freedom, and the next gen will not know the difference because they’ll be educated how to drive or use an autonomous transport, and even this does come to fruition, there bound to be more Trackdays or Race Circuits where you can drive Cars from the old Days....

25 August 2019

 As mentioned above the limiting factor to fun future driving won't be the power train it will be legislation and traffic. I've just spent 7 hours in a borrowed BMW M5 getting very frustrated at 37mph on A roads behind other traffic, average speed cameras, continuous solid white lines for miles and miles.... I once got to floor it in second gear. Never saw the red line in 3rd let alone 4th 5th 6th......

25 August 2019
Good article with many relevant points but taking the gt4 as the baseline misses the fact that over the last 10years or so cars have already shifted a long way towards being white goods with driving pleasure a long way down the priory list. The average fast-ish saloon has gone from a rwd NA v6 manual to a 4wd turbocharged in line 4 with an automatic box - none of which adds to the experience. You can't blame the manufacturers, legislation and customer demand leave them no choice; most customers would rather pay for optional extras like bigger touch screens over ones that add to the driving experience like adaptive dampers. And just look at the fall in demand for manual gearboxes on anything premium.
Does all of this matter? Won't there always be manufacturers catering to the demands of the small number of enthusiasts? At the top end of the market maybe, but where does that leave ordinary people who buy second hand, need a car that's capable of getting them to work and carrying the family as well as raising a smile on the weekend? Sunk I think.

25 August 2019

which exceed the average driver's capabilities? Cars we need to use on the race track to find out that we will be able of maybe using 80-90 percent of what those cars are capable of... I'd rather have an older classic GT, for instance the 60's Alfa Giulia Chris Harris rode to the max. Sports cars have become way too wide too. Motorcyclists have more fun.

25 August 2019

I won't mourn the loss of the gearbox, mainly because most of my entertaining driving has been in a kart, probably the most pure of driving machines.  

 

Driving is less fun now because cars are so capable. It means the limit on the road is usually visibility, not grip. Perhaps that is why so many people choose joyless SUVs.

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week