The Defender works either as a pure country vehicle or as an iconic and uniquely characterful leisure machine

Our Verdict

Land Rover Defender

The Land Rover Defender is an institution and unbeatable off road, if crude on it

1 November 2011

What is it?

This is the substantially modified 2012-model year version of the car that won’t lie down and die. Tracing its roots right back to the original 1948 Land Rover concept, the new Land Rover Defender has been given a new engine that meets stringent EU5 standards and a significant overhaul to improve refinement. This overhaul could keep the Defender in the showrooms until at least 2015.

Replacing the old Transit-sourced 2.4-litre diesel is a new 2.2-litre unit, which gets a single variable-vane turbocharger and a new Continental high-pressure (1800 bar) fuel injection system. The engine gets updated fluid seals and a robust single-mass flywheel. (Most modern road cars use dual mass flywheels for refinement, but these can be fragile). Despite all this, the power and torque of the new unit are identical to the outgoing engine.

A bespoke anti-pollution system was also designed for the Defender. The catalyst and particulate filter are mounted close together and the whole assembly is squeezed into the engine bay - ensuring that the expensive and vulnerable equipment is not destroyed by serious off-roading.

The upshot of the re-engineering is that ‘virtually every component in the engine bay has been re-located’. The 2012 Defender also gets a significantly upgraded NVH kit, including a new acoustic hood for the engine, more efficient sound-deadening and improved seals.

There are new option packs for the Defender range, including a £1650 Comfort Pack (including air-con, CD player, electric windows and remote locking) and a £1500 Off-Road Pack (which includes ABS, heavy duty rims and MTR tyres, tow-ball and under-ride protection bar). The whole Defender line-up covers three wheelbases and up to 14 different body styles.

What’s it like?

Better than the old model, but still something of an acquired taste for anybody but the true believer. This Defender is more planted than the outgoing model, still requires some concentration on tarmac. To a driver used to a modern road car, it radiates a nervousness and unpredictability not least through the indirect steering feel.

The engine refinement - while still quite vocal - is clearly a big improvement and the motor’s grunty low-down torque helps make the Defender more driveable. The six-speed ‘box needs a firm hand, but is clean-shifting and positive.

The lack of a rear bulkhead in this 90 means that the seats (which seem to be more generously padded) will just about go back far enough for a six-foot driver, but the narrow cabin means low speed maneuvering requires the elbows to be tucked well in. The centre console is clearly laid out and clearly backlit at night. The heater is volcanic, but its old-school water-valve technology means it is very hard to regulate.

Ergonomic madness abounds (especially the upright handbrake and key that can’t be turned when the headlamp switch is in the ‘on’ position), the column stalks date back to the original Austin Metro, the headlamps are weak and the wipers clear just a tiny part of the screen.

Off-road the Defender is enormously capable, but it takes much more effort from the driver than is needed in an modern, electronically controlled, off-roader, not least in finding - and selecting - the right gear in difficult conditions. One thing that has made it much easier to drive in extreme situations is the engine’s stall control. At crawling speeds it is possible for the driver to lift off the pedals altogether and let the stall-control inch the vehicle forward.

Should I buy one?

Despite global sales falling just under 19,000 units last year, the Defender - especially in short wheelbase form - is staging something of a comeback in the UK as a stylish urban runaround. In truth, the Defender works either as a pure country vehicle for those who really do spend time off-road, or as an iconic and uniquely characterful leisure machine. One Land Rover executive described it as a ‘classic car that you buy new,’ which is as good a summary as any.

Land Rover Defender 90 Hardtop

Price: £20,995; Top speed: 90mph; 0-62mph: 14.7sec; Economy: 28.3mpg; Co2: 266g/km; Kerbweight: 1889kg; Engine type, cc: 2198cc four-cyls, longitudinal, turbodiesel; Power: 120 bhp at 3500rpm; Torque: 265lb ft at 2000rpm; Gearbox: six-speed manual

Join the debate

Comments
21

3 November 2011

[quote Autocar]Replacing the old Transit-sourced 2.4-litre diesel is a new 2.2-litre unit,[/quote]Is this 2.2 diesel the engine used in the common front drive Transit or is it a version of the PSA/Ford unit?

3 November 2011

[quote Maxycat]Is this 2.2 diesel the engine used in the common front drive Transit or is it a version of the PSA/Ford unit?[/quote]

Is it the same 2.2 PSA/Ford HDi/TDCi engine used in the Jag XF?

3 November 2011

[quote sirwiggum] Is it the same 2.2 PSA/Ford HDi/TDCi engine used in the Jag XF? [/quote] I've just spoken to Roger Crathorne, Mr Land Rover himself, and he says the engine is similar, but substantially re-designed. The bore is smaller and the 'top-end' has been completely redesigned to accommodate the new fuelling system and emissions kit.

3 November 2011

It's only 1271kg so why on earth is it so slow? 15 seconds to 60 with 120bhp and a well hefty 265 torques should surely shift this lump a lot quicker than that...

3 November 2011

[quote jmd67]It's only 1271kg so why on earth is it so slow? [/quote]According to Land Rover website, still showing 2.4 engine, the minimum weight of the 90 inch 7 seater is 1744 kgs with the 110 inch version 2050 kgs.

3 November 2011

[quote jmd67]It's only 1271kg so why on earth is it so slow? 15 seconds to 60 with 120bhp and a well hefty 265 torques should surely shift this lump a lot quicker than that...[/quote] 1271kg has to be a typo or error - a hardtop commercial 90 with the 2.4 engine is about 1750kg. Perhaps they typoed 1721kg? Or they were just plain wrong?

3 November 2011

Utilitarian and all the better for it. Let's hope that the concept for the new Defender gets scrapped. This is the only one of its cars that sticks true to its roots, and it certainly deserves a few more decades of mud-plugging.

3 November 2011

[quote theonlydt]erhaps they typoed 1721kg? Or they were just plain wrong?[/quote] A mistake by us.....according the definitive media info site, the weight of the 90 2dr is 1889kg...

3 November 2011

[quote jmd67]It's only 1271kg so why on earth is it so slow?[/quote] It is not 1271KG this figure does not exist. The test Defender weighs in at 1889kg as stated in the review. No typos.

3 November 2011

[quote sputnik][quote jmd67]It's only 1271kg so why on earth is it so slow?[/quote] It is not 1271KG this figure does not exist. The test Defender weighs in at 1889kg as stated in the review. No typos.[/quote]

It says 1271kg at the bottom with the rest of the stats, although it's obviously not that light!

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Lexus LC500
    Car review
    20 October 2017
    Futuristic Lexus LC coupé mixes the latest technology with an old-school atmospheric V8
  • Maserati Levante S GranSport
    First Drive
    20 October 2017
    Get ready to trade in your diesels: Maserati’s luxury SUV finally gets the engine it’s always needed
  • Jaguar XF Sportbrake TDV6
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    The handsome Jaguar XF Sportbrake exhibits all the hallmarks that makes the saloon great, and with the silky smooth diesel V6 makes it a compelling choice
  • Volkswagen T-Roc TDI
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    Volkswagen's new compact crossover has the looks, the engineering and the build quality to be a resounding success, but not with this diesel engine
  • BMW M550i
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    The all-paw M550i is a fast, effortless mile-muncher, but there's a reason why it won't be sold in the UK