From £20,4158
Ford’s baby SUV is already established as a potential class leader, but there are still questions to be asked over engine and suspension choices
Autocar
11 February 2020

What is it?

The Puma is Ford’s second crack at a compact SUV — the first is the marginally smaller Ecosport, now six years old — and it has been making plenty of waves since it hit the market a couple of months ago. 

As well as grabbing generous helpings of buyer interest it has already collared the coveted What Car? Car of the Year award. In truth, it could hardly be more different from the Ecosport: its combination of great styling, a well designed interior, a simple but impressive spec and an ideal size, looks like sending Ford’s latest offering straight to the top of the baby SUV class.

Yet there are questions. Ford currently offers only two three-cylinder mild hybrid (MHEV) petrol powertrains: 123bhp and 153bhp. Choose the former and you'll save £750, but is it a better idea to spend the extra money? The other tricky choice is between the Puma range’s three distinct models, which offer three wheel and suspension combinations: 17in wheels and compliant suspension for the Titanium, 17in wheels and sports suspension for the ST-Line and 18in wheels, again with sports suspension, for the ST-Line X. Which setup gives the best blend of handling and ride comfort?

What's it like?

Having already driven the higher power version at launch, we grabbed a 123bhp First Edition ST-Line X model and took it on the ever-challenging roads of inner and outer London to investigate. 

Advertisement
Advertisement

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

Back to top

The First Edition comes with a comprehensive package of driver and parking aids, LED headlights, keyless entry and a powered tailgate, all for £2300. It’s a value package, though by the time you’ve paid £750 for an exclusive colour like ours (called Grey Matter) you’re in for £25,945; that's quite a lot of money for a Fiesta-based SUV, even if it has an impressive specification.   

In general, the plaudits this car has so far attracted are entirely valid. Its styling is even better than in photos; its quality is very good; its interior is conventional but classy, like a well-cut business suit. The lower-powered 1.0-litre turbo triple is smooth, quiet and pulls amazingly well from low revs (helped at critical times by the 15bhp and 37lb ft that's contributed by the integrated starter-generator of the MHEV system). But it definitely lacks the sporty top end of the 153bhp edition; we’d say that the lesser engine works well enough, but the extra middle-to-top end verve of the more powerful engine suits the sporty character of the ST-Line models.

Among the strongest virtues of either version, however, are their smoothness and quietness, leading to a feeling of relative sophistication. Both engines emit a smooth, thrummy sound when used hard, but are almost completely silent at other times. Another advantage is the tiny triple’s ability to stop and start, reducing CO2 emissions, almost imperceptibly at intersections.   

We're not so sure about the combination of ST-Line suspension and 18-inch wheels, though. With these, the Puma certainly has the enjoyable quality of tautness we’ve come to recognise from small Fords, but it “feels” ruts and ridges too acutely and too noisily at times, and rarely feels truly composed at sub-30mph speeds on pock-marked London roads. We’d say that an ST-Line on 17in wheels is the minimum comfort threshold for UK roads, and that the softer sprung (and more ostensibly luxurious) Titanium will be better for many.

Should I buy one?

It’s certainly a strong contender. It has taken a surprisingly long time for the manufacturers of baby SUVs to offer vehicles of the appeal and capability of the superminis that underpin them. Renault built a terrific-looking Captur that was no great shakes on the road; Nissan’s first Juke won followers for a radical look but failed to impress dynamically speaking. 

Back to top

Now things are changing. The latest versions of the Renault and Nissan are better drivers’ cars — just in time to provide decent opposition for the Puma, which arrives from launch with a large helping of the traditional on-road virtues of small Fords. Yet the excellence of the Puma’s all-round package, along with its award-winning star quality, take it very close to the top of the class — provide you choose the version that rides as you want it to. 

It’ll take a full-on Autocar comparison to establish the class hierarchy but there’s no disguising the Puma’s impressive suite of virtues. It’s simply better executed and more desirable than the general run of BSUV competitors, and given the current high demand for such models, it surely has a big future in prospect.

Ford Puma ST-Line X specification

Where Greater London, UK Price £25,195 On sale now Engine 3cyl, 999cc, turbocharged, petrol Power 123bhp at 6000rpm Torque 155lb ft at 1400 to 4500rpm Gearbox Six-speed manual Kerb weight 1280kg Top speed 119mph 0-62mph 9.8sec Fuel economy 48.7-51.4mpg (combined) CO2 99g/km Rivals Renault Captur, Nissan Juke

Join the debate

Comments
18

11 February 2020

Yet another road test compromised by the manufacturer’s desire to send a press car out on oversized wheels. It was an idiotic decision by Ford, for the sake of a few photos, to send the ST-Line out on thumping, uncomfortable optional 18” wheels. It’s for the writer to opine if it might have got a prestigious four-and-a-half-star rating, but one has to wonder.

A suggestion for Autocar. Why not insist that a manufacturer sends a press car out in basic from, without options? As the very least demand that a vehicle is supplied without larger wheels. Ford shot themselves in the foot here, doesn’t anyone learn that enthusiast have wised up to this and not reading Max Power?

11 February 2020
That some buyers just want the biggest possible wheels for their looks only. In speccing my car I always choose the biggest wheels and tyres and if they still don’t look big enough, reject the car. I almost bought an entry level Model 3 Tesla until I found there were no wheel/tyre options and the 18s it came on looked tiny and lost in a car that size. My current car has 21’s. The other reason to reject Model 3 was the “any colour you like as long as it’s black” interior. I never buy black: Ford please note!
Is the ride comfort a bit compromised on big wheels? Maybe a bit but I doubt it’s a large margin. Does it handle any better? Maybe, but I doubt most people could tell.
No, it’s all about the looks.

Robbo
A View from Down Under

11 February 2020
Aussierob wrote:

That some buyers just want the biggest possible wheels for their looks only. In speccing my car I always choose the biggest wheels and tyres and if they still don’t look big enough, reject the car. I almost bought an entry level Model 3 Tesla until I found there were no wheel/tyre options and the 18s it came on looked tiny and lost in a car that size. My current car has 21’s. The other reason to reject Model 3 was the “any colour you like as long as it’s black” interior. I never buy black: Ford please note!
Is the ride comfort a bit compromised on big wheels? Maybe a bit but I doubt it’s a large margin. Does it handle any better? Maybe, but I doubt most people could tell.
No, it’s all about the looks.

Robbo
A View from Down Under

Well, no wonder your ancestors were transported to the southern hemisphere. Another "I almost bought"..., "if it wasn't for"...fill in any spurious excuse you can muster.

You choose the biggest "whatever", because you have a small intellect, and a large amount of money, you are the exact reason why car people get to laugh when they read these comments columns.

You are right though...Ford should just for your convenience offer a paler shade for the interior and limit availability to just you, at no extra cost of course.

Awaiting your next revelation with eager anticipation...fixed the corks on your hat yet?.

FM8

11 February 2020
Takeitslowly wrote:
Aussierob wrote:

That some buyers just want the biggest possible wheels for their looks only. In speccing my car I always choose the biggest wheels and tyres and if they still don’t look big enough, reject the car. I almost bought an entry level Model 3 Tesla until I found there were no wheel/tyre options and the 18s it came on looked tiny and lost in a car that size. My current car has 21’s. The other reason to reject Model 3 was the “any colour you like as long as it’s black” interior. I never buy black: Ford please note!
Is the ride comfort a bit compromised on big wheels? Maybe a bit but I doubt it’s a large margin. Does it handle any better? Maybe, but I doubt most people could tell.
No, it’s all about the looks.

Robbo
A View from Down Under

Well, no wonder your ancestors were transported to the southern hemisphere. Another "I almost bought"..., "if it wasn't for"...fill in any spurious excuse you can muster.

You choose the biggest "whatever", because you have a small intellect, and a large amount of money, you are the exact reason why car people get to laugh when they read these comments columns.

You are right though...Ford should just for your convenience offer a paler shade for the interior and limit availability to just you, at no extra cost of course.

Awaiting your next revelation with eager anticipation...fixed the corks on your hat yet?.

One thing is for sure in terms of size, you're the biggest bellend around.

12 February 2020
FM8 wrote:
Takeitslowly wrote:
Aussierob wrote:

That some buyers just want the biggest possible wheels for their looks only. In speccing my car I always choose the biggest wheels and tyres and if they still don’t look big enough, reject the car. I almost bought an entry level Model 3 Tesla until I found there were no wheel/tyre options and the 18s it came on looked tiny and lost in a car that size. My current car has 21’s. The other reason to reject Model 3 was the “any colour you like as long as it’s black” interior. I never buy black: Ford please note!
Is the ride comfort a bit compromised on big wheels? Maybe a bit but I doubt it’s a large margin. Does it handle any better? Maybe, but I doubt most people could tell.
No, it’s all about the looks.

Robbo
A View from Down Under

Well, no wonder your ancestors were transported to the southern hemisphere. Another "I almost bought"..., "if it wasn't for"...fill in any spurious excuse you can muster.

You choose the biggest "whatever", because you have a small intellect, and a large amount of money, you are the exact reason why car people get to laugh when they read these comments columns.

You are right though...Ford should just for your convenience offer a paler shade for the interior and limit availability to just you, at no extra cost of course.

Awaiting your next revelation with eager anticipation...fixed the corks on your hat yet?.

One thing is for sure in terms of size, you're the biggest bellend around.

Thats a bit harsh, Aussierob does come across as a bit of a tw*t - why couldnt he buy a set of after market wheels for the Model 3 ? But hes right about black interiors, not everyone wants to sit in a stupidly dark and boring coal hole, there should be a light option too. And at least hes honest about being as shallow as fcuk ("its all about the looks").

12 February 2020
And if it was "All about the looks" why anyone would buy either a Model 3 or a fake SUV Puma is beyond me, there a plenty of far better looking cars out there.

12 February 2020
Is that it would be illegal to fit non-type-approved wheels/tyres here. I had no idea you could legally do that in the UK.
I’m not going to honour the rest of the anti comments with a response. Indeed without a translator I’m not sure I understand some of them, but I would point out that I was merely expressing my personal preferences, which I expect people to respect.
Aesthetically, bigger wheels ALWAYS look better and if people can’t see that, well, save your money and buy small ones.
Robbo
A View from Down Under

17 February 2020
Big wheels now come with stiff-walled low profile rubber, my Fiesta suffering no less than 3 buckled wheels due to the UK's potholes. Best today seems to cut back a bit on wheel diameter to allow higher profile, better cushioned tyres - still filling well the wheel arches

1 May 2020
Aussierob wrote:

Is that it would be illegal to fit non-type-approved wheels/tyres here. I had no idea you could legally do that in the UK. I’m not going to honour the rest of the anti comments with a response. Indeed without a translator I’m not sure I understand some of them, but I would point out that I was merely expressing my personal preferences, which I expect people to respect. Aesthetically, bigger wheels ALWAYS look better and if people can’t see that, well, save your money and buy small ones. Robbo A View from Down Under

 

"Bit of a TW*T, shallow as FCUK"...not MY words, though find it impossible to disagree.:)

1 May 2020
FM8 wrote:
Takeitslowly wrote:
Aussierob wrote:

That some buyers just want the biggest possible wheels for their looks only. In speccing my car I always choose the biggest wheels and tyres and if they still don’t look big enough, reject the car. I almost bought an entry level Model 3 Tesla until I found there were no wheel/tyre options and the 18s it came on looked tiny and lost in a car that size. My current car has 21’s. The other reason to reject Model 3 was the “any colour you like as long as it’s black” interior. I never buy black: Ford please note! Is the ride comfort a bit compromised on big wheels? Maybe a bit but I doubt it’s a large margin. Does it handle any better? Maybe, but I doubt most people could tell. No, it’s all about the looks. Robbo A View from Down Under

Well, no wonder your ancestors were transported to the southern hemisphere. Another "I almost bought"..., "if it wasn't for"...fill in any spurious excuse you can muster. You choose the biggest "whatever", because you have a small intellect, and a large amount of money, you are the exact reason why car people get to laugh when they read these comments columns. You are right though...Ford should just for your convenience offer a paler shade for the interior and limit availability to just you, at no extra cost of course. Awaiting your next revelation with eager anticipation...fixed the corks on your hat yet?.

One thing is for sure in terms of size, you're the biggest bellend around.

 

Clearly, the adornments hanging from your hat, not the only items about you, made of cork. :)

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week