Transport Select Committee addresses the state of UK’s roads, claiming that resurfacing work has tailed off significantly

The state of the UK’s roads has attracted the attention of the Transport Select Committee, which is launching an inquiry into how road repairs are funded. 

Road resurfacing, research from the Asphalt Industry Association (AIA) says, has dropped in average frequency from every 55 years to once every 92 years, raising concerns about the effect this is having on the state of repair of Britain's roads. 

The AIA’s Alarm survey says the percentage of budget spent on fixing carriageways in England this year has fallen by 2% compared with last year, to 56%, although it’s risen by 5% to 63% in Wales. The English carriageway maintenance budget has risen by £1.9 million, meanwhile, to £14.7 million.

The committee is calling for evidence from the public on road conditions, as well as insight into the knock-on effects of poorly maintained roads and any thoughts on how the roads should be maintained. 

Concerns about cyclist safety and damage to cars are cited as areas of interest, with the committee saying: “Road condition and maintenance has been a matter of public concern for several years, with potholes plaguing the country.” 

Committee chair Lilian Greenwood said: “This plague of potholes represents a major headache for all of us. The consequences of a deteriorating local road network are significant – undermining local economic performance and resulting in direct costs to motorists, through damage to road vehicles. The safety of other road users, particularly cyclists, is compromised.

"Our inquiry aims to investigate the situation in England, including current funding constraints and potential alternative models that could offer a solution. We know that this is a high-priority issue among the public and I hope our inquiry will help put the onus on the Government to address it sooner rather than later."

Our Verdict

Seat Ateca

Seat's first attempt at building an SUV is a cracker and knocked the Nissan Qashqai off its perch in the process, so we discover what makes the Ateca our class leader

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Alpina B7 2019 first drive review - hero front
    20 May 2019
    First Drive
    Alpina's latest take on the 7 Series packs more performance than a...
  • Mazda 3 2019 UK first drive review - hero front
    20 May 2019
    First Drive
    Sharp-suited Mazda 3 touches down in UK. It’s got the handling smarts, but a...
  • Alpina B4 99 Edition 2019 first drive review - hero front
    20 May 2019
    First Drive
    Last hurrah for the current B4 S Biturbo brings unprecedented athleticism for...

Join the debate

Comments
10

3 August 2018

 The simple reason is that, through lack of proper funding for something which is akin Painting the Forth Rail Bridge needs done and done well hasn’t happened for decades, Drivers of all Vehicles have just had to put up with it, it’s only recently that you could claim damages if you met the criteria for it, the repairs are done to whatever contract price take (usually the cheapest!) there often done at the wrong time of Year and whole isn’t prepared before it’s filled, it’s just two or three guys one put a shovel full of Tar in and the other take turns in tapping it down!, ok, contractors have deadlines and if they don’t meet it they get fined, hence you sometimes get a bad Job!. I don’t think there’s a solution out there, more money? More time. It’s a difficult situation.

Peter Cavellini.

3 August 2018

It's not just the potholes that are a disgrace...When they re-surface the roads by us, they don't raise the manhole covers leaving them 2 inches too deep. Another clattering for my new car.

richy

3 August 2018

 Road workers, most workers do what’s required, no more, don’t have to think, just do what it says, certain amount of time to do the job and move onto the next one, sad but true...

Peter Cavellini.

3 August 2018

This is what happens when repairs are done to price. As has already been said, the prep work is abysmal, the quality of materials used is no good and continued monitoring is non existent. But to be fair, the local council has just spend the best part of a month resurfacing....the pavements! While the road next to it is scarred with years worth of poor patch jobs and gas/water mains related works.

3 August 2018

If it were down to me, i would bring road maintainence under the control of central government. We just cant trust local government with the job. As for cost, well it cost what ever it costs to sort out. Firstly its a national disgrace that our first world roads are so poor. But it also costs the economy a fortune in lost revenue. Thousands of People spend millions of wasted hours sitting in queues, deliveries take longer, not to mention the huge amount of damage to cars caused by the poor state of the roads. So even though it would take a huge investment to get the roads into a decent state, i suspect it would be good for the economy in the long run. Its for certain that the current way of doing things does not work at all. 

3 August 2018

Abolish the foreign aid budget and spend the money on replacing the UK's worn out roads instead.

3 August 2018
Patching is a poor quality 'sticking plaster' approach that doesn't last more than a few months, so the contractors get paid time and again to repair the same holes or highlight 2 or 3, leaving others that are a matter of feet away, so they can return again in a few weeks or months.

Like most drivers, I'm sick and tired of dodging potholes in the day-time and hearing the horrific noise as my wheels hit those I can't see at night or in the rain.

As if poor quality patches weren't bad enough, they then cover large areas in loose chippings, which remain a skid hazard and damage paint and windscreens for months to come.

It may seem cheap to patch and cover up like this but like many of the governments money saving policies, in the long term it's a false economy with a much wider and greater impact to the economy (as others have said).

The only long-term solution is to properly resurface roads like they used to do, tear it up, lay a solid foundation, resurface to a decent standard with good quality materials.

The last time I saw a good stretch of road resurfaced like that was in Wales. During a 120 mile journey that crossed two English counties to get to Wales the ratio of potholes must have been around 5:1 and the last 15 or so miles on fresh tarmac was smooth, silent and stress free - a rare pleasure in England these days...

My advice to the government is get your finances in order: If you can't and need more money, stop faffing around and deal with corporate tax avoidance like you promised: For a start off get Amazon to pay the correct amount of corporation tax and spend it on our roads - all their dirty diesel vans thundering up and down certainly don't help the roads or the air quality.

It's a national disgrace so central government should deal with it - stop the political blame game and just fix it!!!

4 August 2018

Mark11@ , We all now or think that We the Car Drivers fund everything, well if that’s true, what would you rather have?, an already always struggling NHS or, a better performing Tax collection?, yes the Roads wherever you live are atrocious, your Local Council can only fix it with the Money Centrai Government gives them which is money for the whole of local council provision, each department has to fight for its budget and often doesn’t get it, putting the Road problem back in Central Government control won’t solve it it’ll take longer to get repairs done, yes I’m cynical because that’s how it happens, Roads aren’t going to improve, there more and more traffic on the Roads every year, Beeching in the sixties screwed up distribution by closing Stations and Yards, that put more Traffic on the Road, why can’t we reverse that and put it back on Trains with distribution from there?, it’s not your Councils fault, it’s ours, because we all want it yesterday and moan about it if it doesn’t!

Peter Cavellini.

5 August 2018
Peter, if you're going to take issue with what I say then take issue with what I SAY - please don't presume to put words in my mouth or misquote me.

I did not say anything about car drivers funding everything - those are your words and do not reflect my view.

The tax paying public and companies of Great Britain fund the government through all forms of taxation but there is considerable inefficiency, waste, misuse and misapplication of money on many levels and in many areas: Vast sums are spent on pointless projects, think tanks, investigations that take years to reach a conclusion most could in 5 minutes, overseas aid that whikst laudablr should not come before we have our own house in order, whilst all the time funding for the NHS, social care, infrastructure (such as roads etc) and business development go to hell in a hand cart.

As far as collecting taxes, HMRC should be tough on all tax avoidance but they're not, they go after the minoes whilst the big fish get away - billions of pounds that could have been helping this country have been lost and don't get me started on the money that disappered on the banking fiasco.

You mention the Beeching report and the decimation that caused to our rail infrastructure and I agree with you but if the government can't keep our existing roads in good order then redeveloping nearly 5,000 miles of lost track is never going to happen.

I don't accept your last point either, it's not my fault, your fault or our fault collectively as Britains - we voters put a national and local government into place to represent the best interests of this country and to properly administer the private and company tax funds that we generate. We place considerable trust that they will do so wisely but rarely is our trust repaid - politicians and councillors screw up regularly with few consequences personally and despite their failures, most walk away richer than when they arrived in office.

I said the state of our roads was a national disgrace and central government should sort it out, that doesn't mean control goes back to London it just means the solution to a national issue should come from central government - a suitable long term policy and sufficient annual funding ring-fenced specifically for that purpose.

You see Peter, I know there is a bigger picture, all I'm saying is with specific regard to road repairs, in the long term, patching is an inefficient waste of public funds.

A better way is needed.

4 August 2018

Hopefully Jimi you meant 1.9 BILLION otherwise i'll be wanting some of my road and fuel tax back

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Alpina B7 2019 first drive review - hero front
    20 May 2019
    First Drive
    Alpina's latest take on the 7 Series packs more performance than a...
  • Mazda 3 2019 UK first drive review - hero front
    20 May 2019
    First Drive
    Sharp-suited Mazda 3 touches down in UK. It’s got the handling smarts, but a...
  • Alpina B4 99 Edition 2019 first drive review - hero front
    20 May 2019
    First Drive
    Last hurrah for the current B4 S Biturbo brings unprecedented athleticism for...