This pairing – the final match-up wrestled from our sprawling sub £30k shootout – is probably most notable for the obvious absentee.
The Ford Fiesta ST is our small hot hatch champ by a troublingly huge margin, it won last year’s contest and came within a whisker of taking top honours again this time round.
In contrast, the Mini Cooper S and Audi S1 have both been somewhat damned by faint praise. Both have their likeable sides. Both are pleasantly premium, and easy to imagine living with. Both are competent and undeniably quick, too. But where the Fiesta frequently dazzles, they tend to fizzle out.
Between them, they share the last two positions in the affordable fun countdown. However, in this case, not quite measuring up to the standard isn’t anything to feel ashamed about. Especially as, excluding the Fiesta, these were the cheapest cars on test - and cheap, as the criteria suggests, is good.
In the case of the S1 that does place us on admittedly shaky ground, referring to a £25k inhabitant of the B segment as ‘cheap’ is like calling a commuter train season ticket ‘good value’.
But it’s worth remembering that this is still the low-cost way into Audi’s coveted S-brand, and included in the price is a 228bhp 2.0-litre engine mated to a multi-plate clutch four-wheel-drive system.
Read the full Mini Cooper S review
If that combination appeals on paper, then you’ll probably appreciate the way the S1 goes down a road. Like practically all of quattro GmBH’s progeny, its supermini is primarily concerned with turning turbocharged torque - 273lb ft of it in this case - into forward motion.
By doing this more effectively than any of its two-wheel-drive rivals, the tiny Audi is nearly a second quicker to 62mph than the Mini.
It feels it, too. Through the first few gears, the familiar EA888 motor - usually labouring under the higher workload of bigger hatchbacks - makes the S1 properly ferocious. And because it comes without the slightly haywire lack of composure endemic to overpowered front-drivers, its potential never seems less than fully exploitable.
While it obviously can’t overcome a near 30bhp deficit, no one would accuse the new Mini of tardiness during get away.
All the old scamper is present and correct, enhanced by the better mid-range delivered by the upgrade to BMW’s larger 2.0-litre four pot and a 100kg weight-saving over the more mechanically complicated Audi.
Read the affordable fun special - Ford Fiesta ST3 Mountune versus VW Golf R
Join the debate
Add your comment
tired old tune.
Weak power from the Mini's turbo 2.0
This seems very very poor- Honda were getting 240hp in the S2000 without a turbo 15 years ago. BMW are getting similar power from a diesel in a 320d. Are Mini holding back to make room for a RS model?
CWBROWN wrote:189hp from a
They'll be using the same engine in a different tune for the JCW and eventually the GP model, many would say the cooper s power level is the sweetspot for a mini though.
.
.
.
.
There's something about the little Audis...