Reports suggest an Italian emission-cheating investigation allowed FCA to skip tests designed to catch cheat devices

Fiat Chrysler Automobiles (FCA) was allowed to skip tests in Italy's emissions-cheating investigation, according to a report from Italy's transport ministry.

The tests, designed to find illegal engine software, were completed by BMW, Ford, Mercedes-Benz, Volkswagen and General Motors but three of the seven FCA models tested didn't record results, according to Reuters

The three models were a Jeep Cherokee 2.0, Alfa Romeo Giulietta 1.6 and Lancia Ypsilon 1.3, but transport ministry spokeswoman Luisa Gabbi told Reuters more results for FCA models would follow and added that "no key test has been omitted for FCA". FCA also denies breaking any laws.

The news has led to calls for the relationships between national testing authorities and domestic car makers to be scrutinised more closely ahead of a vote on Thursday on tougher EU control of vehicle testing conducted by national authorities.

Prosecution in France

FCA could still face prosecution in France after investigators recorded abnormal emissions of nitrogen oxide (NOx) pollutants from some of its diesel engines.

The investigation allegedly revealed emissions from some of the manufacturer's models were several times higher than regulatory limits, and FCA has been referred for possible prosecution while investigations into other car brands continue. Both Volkswagen and Renault have previously been referred to French prosecutors.

Results from a testing programme carried out by French regulators last July showed that the Jeep Cherokee emitted eight times the NOx limit during lab tests, while the Fiat 500X emitted almost 17 times the limit in road testing, according to the report.

An FCA spokesman told Reuters that its diesels were fully compliant with applicable emissions requirements and said that while it had reservations about the tests carried out, it will cooperate with the investigation.

Cheat devices in Europe and America

Earlier this year, it was reported that more than 700,000 FCA Chrysler Automobiles cars in Europe and America are potentially fitted with emissions-cheating software, with 600,000 of these in Europe alone, according to a report in the Financial Times.

The US's Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has publically accused Fiat Chrysler Automobiles (FCA) of using cheat software akin to that used by Volkswagen in the dieselgate emissions scandal, according to Reuters.

FCA cars accused of cheating include the Dodge Ram 1500 and Jeep Grand Cherokee, which are fitted with the manufacturer's 3.0-litre diesel engine – more than 104,000 of which have been sold in the US – with cars sold since 2014 alleged to be fitted with software which ‘allowed excess diesel emissions’. 

According to the Society of Motor Manufacturers & Traders (SMMT), the number of cars fitted with the implicated 3.0-litre diesel engine in the UK is 4235, although it's not yet clear if all applications of this engine have the software. Nevertheless, the BBC reports that the Department for Transport (DfT) has asked the EPA for further details on the issue.

FCA has been mentioned in emissions controversies; Fiat had to answer to German regulators last spring, before being accused of using an emissions cheat device in October.

In the midst of the Volkswagen emissions scandal at the beginning of 2016, FCA also released an unprompted statement saying that its cars do not cheat emissions tests.

Volkswagen’s US emissions scandal has involved the arrest of two senior employees and charges held against five more, who are believed to be in Germany. The manufacturer agreed to pay a $4.3 billion (£3.55bn) fine to US regulators as a settlement.

FCA released the following statement in reaction to the EPA's accusation: "FCA US is disappointed that the EPA has chosen to issue a notice of violation with respect to the emissions control technology employed in the company’s 2014-16 model year light-duty 3.0-litre diesel engines.

"FCA US looks forward to the opportunity to meet with the EPA’s enforcement division and representatives of the new administration to demonstrate that FCA US’s emissions control strategies are properly justified and thus are not defeat devices under applicable regulations and to resolve this matter expeditiously."

Our Verdict

Fiat 500

The Fiat 500 is a deserved success story for the brand, offering bags of style, a fine drive and low costs

Join the debate

Comments
8

12 January 2017
If Volkswagen case is anything to go by then the Fiat should settle the matter with the US authorities. Unlike the lame European authorities, the Americans don't take porky pies for an answer. Ask Volkswagen.

12 January 2017
They might be more inclined to accept Porky Pies from US car brands. In which case expect a full on trade dispute with the EU...

12 January 2017
As soon as all emissions are checked in the real world, co2, nox, particlates etc, the sooner no one will be able to try to dodge them, and the better off we will all be. I guess diesels, under sized turbo engines, direct injection etc will all fall under the spot light. I am sure FCA wont be the last to be found out.

At least its reasuring the US authorities are continuing to test things. Shame we in Europe dont appear to care...

12 January 2017
artill wrote:

As soon as all emissions are checked in the real world, co2, nox, particlates etc, the sooner no one will be able to try to dodge them, and the better off we will all be. I guess diesels, under sized turbo engines, direct injection etc will all fall under the spot light. I am sure FCA wont be the last to be found out.

At least its reasuring the US authorities are continuing to test things. Shame we in Europe dont appear to care...

Yes, reasuring for their citizens that their government care so much for their health, safety and welfare. Yet that same government is happy to bomb the sh1t out of innocent men, women and children in some far off land all for instilling good ole democracy, spreading the word of christianity to the savages and perhaps hoovering up the control of a few puddles of the black stuff.

God bless America.

13 January 2017
Have we forgotten who actually owns FCA? Are we rewriting history here? I always thought the Yanks would do this.
Chrysler went bust in the GFC and, even after taking federal money they still couldn't keep going and so were bought out by Fiat.
So don't suggest the US authorities are bearing down on domestic automakers. They just aren't.
This is yet another case of hitting Jonny Foreigner to protect good old Uncle Sam.

Aussie Rob - a view from down under

13 January 2017
Aussierob wrote:

Have we forgotten who actually owns FCA? Are we rewriting history here? I always thought the Yanks would do this.
Chrysler went bust in the GFC and, even after taking federal money they still couldn't keep going and so were bought out by Fiat.
So don't suggest the US authorities are bearing down on domestic automakers. They just aren't.
This is yet another case of hitting Jonny Foreigner to protect good old Uncle Sam.

They not bearing down on BMW, Honda, Toyota etc either (none of which are American companies). Reason - because like various American car companies as of yet they’ve done nothing wrong.
American car makers sell next to no diesel’s in America so would have little to gain by cheating Nox figures so they don’t. Do you have any evidence otherwise?

 

Hydrogen cars just went POP

13 January 2017
Marchionne: "Darn, just when I'm courting Mary for the 100th time. Pretty Em-Barra-ssing."

13 January 2017
Which are the 600k European models implicated then? It can't just be the V6 engine, surely. Autocar seems to publish more half-baked stories these days.

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • BMW 220d Convertible M Sport 2017 review
    First Drive
    26 July 2017
    The 2 Series range receives a light facelift, enhancing its exterior and interior look, improving infotainment and adding more standard kit
  • Renault Captur Dynamique S Nav dCI 110
    First Drive
    26 July 2017
    To keep pace with rivals in this increasingly competitive category, Renault's popular compact crossover has had a mild refresh both inside and out
  • Porsche Panamera Turbo S E-Hybrid
    First Drive
    25 July 2017
    New top-of-the-line Porsche hybrid, though fast and flexible, is simply too heavy to strike the same sweet sporting compromise as its siblings
  • Caterham Seven 420R Donington Edition
    First Drive
    25 July 2017
    Limited-edition road-legal Caterham track car is a superbly enthralling drive, with enough creature comforts to be used on the road as well. Even more addictive than most of its rangemates
  • McLaren 570S Spider
    First Drive
    25 July 2017
    McLaren has created its most attainable drop-top by removing the roof from the 570S coupé, but none of the car's talent has come away with it