Crash safety organisation World NCAP is pledging to eradicate cars that score zero stars by 2020
Jim Holder
26 February 2016

An estimated 20% of cars sold each year fail to meet the minimum United Nations-recommended crash standards. So says World NCAP secretary general David Ward, who has pledged that his organisation will eradicate zero-star-rated cars by 2020.

Speaking exclusively to Autocar, Ward said: “The current arguments being made by car makers as to why they won’t meet minimum standards are absurd, and the regulators and consumers aren’t going to stand for it much longer.”

UN regulation 924 sets out minimum standards for a 35mph crash, which Ward sums up as requiring “a basic crash structure and a single airbag”. In recent years, NCAP has heavily criticised cars - including those built by Datsun, Ford, Hyundai and Tata - for failing to provide sufficient protection.

“The argument put forward by some car makers is that they have to build cheap cars to attract buyers away from motorbikes, but there is no actual evidence to support that assertion,” said Ward. “Car buyers deserve a basic standard of safety, and the cost of providing it is tiny - be it through better engineering of global platforms or investing as little as $50 in an airbag. The arguments against doing this are just absurd.”

Ward pointed to tightening regulation in emerging markets such as Brazil and India as being key in his organisation’s pledge to eradicate all zero-star cars from sale by 2020. He also warned that consumers are turning on manufacturers that don’t take action to meet the standards ahead of time.

“Consumers have a growing understanding of what is required, and car makers that don’t offer the bare minimum will be left at a commercial disadvantage,” said Ward.

Ward’s comments come in the wake of controversy after General Motors boss Mary Barra defended her company’s decision not to fit airbags to some cars the firm was selling in Latin America.

Barra said: “There are many cases where we are well above standards, but we also have to look at affordability, otherwise you cut people out of even having the availability of transportation.”

Comment - who wants ultra-cheap cars?

The race to build the world’s cheapest car was once headline-grabbing stuff, with the Western world agog at what was possible for just a few thousand dollars.

As cars like the Tata Nano, Datsun Go, Suzuki-Maruti Alto 800 and Chevrolet Aveo were born, a revolution in personal mobility was predicted. To date, however, that hasn’t materialised, with budget car sales universally failing to meet expectations.

As global wealth rises, the car-buying population is also expected to grow, but it is clear from the budget cars launched so far that fewer people aspire to them than once thought

Commentators suggest that marketeers have overlooked a serious flaw in their plan: even budget car buyers, it seems, have upward aspirations, and driving around and being seen in a basic car labelled among the world’s cheapest does not meet them.

Our Verdict

Tata Nano
The diminutive Nano is as short and narrow as an original Mini

Cheap and undeniably cheerful. Unbelievable value, if only you could buy one in the UK.

Join the debate


26 February 2016
Would it be legal to stop this crap being brought on the market? If so I am all for it. In fact anything with 2 stars and 1 star and zero star shouldnt be allowed to be placed on any forecourt. Unfortunately whilst they can give out the ratings and inform the appropriate ministries, just imagine the paper shuffling and twaddle and toss that lot will get into because we dont want to upset the apple cart with China or Indonesia or Brazil etc etc etc. Those pussies in Brussels will be even more loated to throw the spanner in the works.

what's life without imagination


26 February 2016
Pretty sure Caterhams and most Morgans don't get airbags. Wonder how they rate at World NCAP, whatever that organisation is.

Oh, its on their website: UK charity, chairman Max Mosley, funding support from Bloomberg Philanthropies, the FIA Foundation, International Consumer Testing and Research, and the Road Safety Fund, offices in Trafalgar Sq. Global NCAP has consultative status with the United Nations (ECOSOC), is a member of the UN Road Safety Collaboration, and supports the UN Decade of Action for Road Safety 2011-2020. So there you go then.

26 February 2016
to see one of its sister cars as the chosen illustration.

26 February 2016
I once bought a Citroen ZX for £150, and it had an airbag. There can be no excuse.

26 February 2016
Who cares what the UN has to say upon any subject. They abuse us in the UK for being unwilling to allow the rest of the world to come here and claim.a house and benefits.

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Honda Civic
    Car review
    21 April 2017
    Honda’s 10th-generation Civic hatchback goes global — but is that good news?
  • Toyota Prius Plug-in
    First Drive
    21 April 2017
    Second-generation Toyota Prius Plug-in hybrid gets a bigger battery with new 39-mile electric range, more tech and styling updates, but it's expensive
  • Seat Ateca 1.4 EcoTSI 150 DSG
    First Drive
    20 April 2017
    Addition of DSG automatic gearbox in this top-spec model doesn't show the Ateca small SUV in its best light
  • Isuzu D-Max Blade
    First Drive
    20 April 2017
    Isuzu treats its rough-and-ready D-Max pick-up truck to a new engine, revised looks, better hauling ability and more equipment
  • MG ZS
    First Drive
    19 April 2017
    We drive MG’s upcoming Ford Ecosport rival in China-spec; good looks and a smart interior bode well for the UK version