Currently reading: Hydrogen cars explained: the technology targeting a fuel-cell future
We look at how hydrogen fuel cells work, and investigate when they might become mainstream
News
7 mins read
14 October 2020

Hydrogen has been touted as the ideal zero-carbon fuel for a couple of decades now, yet it has so far failed to catch on. However, in January of this year, the Hydrogen Council, an organisation comprising 92 major companies, claimed that the 2020s will be “the decade of hydrogen”.

Dr David Hart, visiting professor at the Imperial College Centre for Environmental Policy and head of the consultancy e4Tech, agrees, saying: “We’re seeing an enormous amount of serious interest in hydrogen particularly, and fuel cells too.”

Since the late 1990s, there has been huge investment in this technology by car makers, but only Honda, Hyundai and Toyota make fuel cell cars that you can buy today, and only the latter two offer them in Britain. Large-scale introduction has been hampered not so much by the tech but by the difficulty and cost of establishing a filling station network.

That’s about to change, though, thanks to international plans for hydrogen to become a major component of energy systems across the board. Not just for cars but also for domestic and industrial heating and power, for fuelling trucks, trains and ships and, perhaps most importantly, for storing and stockpiling surplus electrical energy.

Last year, the UK became the first country to legislate for net-zero carbon emissions by 2050, a step up from the previous law calling for an 80% reduction over 1990 levels.

This made a big difference, explains Toyota GB’s manager for alternative fuels, John Hunt: “The 80% allowed all the difficult things to be parked and hidden in the 20% as things you didn’t have to do. Once net-zero was put on the table, people had to rethink, and ‘difficult to do’ has come to the front of mind.”

One of those things is hydrogen. Hunt says, in its July Future Energy Scenarios report, “National Grid makes it clear that hydrogen is essential; there’s no question at all.”

The report says that at least 190TWh of energy per year will be needed for producing hydrogen to achieve net-zero and highlights its value for storing energy to cope with peaks and troughs in electricity generation (called grid balancing). During the past decade, 8.7TWh of wind power – equivalent to the capacity of 136 million Kia e-Niro 64kWh batteries – went unused, at a cost of £649 million. That’s because there’s currently no way of storing vast amounts of off-peak electricity.

Hunt is confident the UK has huge potential for harnessing wind power to produce zero-carbon hydrogen. “The UK has some of the most accessible and windiest conditions in the world,” he explains. “The opportunity for the UK to establish close offshore farms producing hydrogen from seawater, then export it to land by pipe or ship, is huge. With the combination of spent oil and gas fields and rigs in place, using those platforms for producing hydrogen on-site is perfectly feasible.”

Advertisement
Advertisement

Find an Autocar review

Read our review

Car review
Land Rover Range Rover review hero front

The fourth-generation Range Rover is here to be judged as a luxury car as much as it is a 4x4

Back to top

The oil-and-gas industry’s UK continental shelf report, also released in July, estimates 30% of the natural gas supply will be converted to hydrogen (with CO2 being captured) and there will be a massive escalation in renewable energy from offshore wind farms from 2030 to produce green hydrogen (no CO2 involved).

Green hydrogen is produced from electricity by the electrolysis of water. Once energy has been converted to hydrogen, it can be stored indefinitely, making use of depleted oil fields and salt caverns, which Hunt says the UK has “excellent geology for”. Thirty salt caverns in the UK are already used for storing natural gas and oil. Pipelines once used for carrying natural gas can be used for hydrogen instead and perform a dual role of storing energy.

The current pipeline network in the European Union not only transports gas but in doing so also stores 1500TWh of energy in gas form. And unlike electricity, the energy carried in hydrogen doesn’t diminish as it’s moved. A consortium of European gas suppliers plans to build another 14,000 miles of pipe to form a hydrogen distribution backbone right across Europe.

Building hydrogen filling stations without many vehicles to make them financially viable has been a sticking point, but regional commercial fleets of trucks, taxis and buses offer a solution. “The original thinking was to build a lot of filling stations and have cars travelling between them,” explains Hart. “Now the thinking is to establish fleets in specific areas to create nodes. Once there are enough areas, they can be joined up.”

Hart labels the EU targets for 2050 “very aggressive” and says a concerted effort will be needed to grow production of the electrolysers needed for making green hydrogen.

British firm ITM Power is ahead of the game on that score. “We have been producing electrolysers for two full decades now and at the end of this year will create a gigafactory for electrolysers,” explains ITM Motive managing director Duncan Yellen.

ITM Motive is a new offshoot of ITM Power set up to focus expressly on the development of hydrogen filling stations. It has seven already, mainly around London, and another six under development – two in the London area and four further north. “We need about 100 to have a sensible geographical coverage,” says Yellen. “My ambition is to achieve the magic 100 stations within the next five years. Because of the excellent range of fuel cell vehicles, that will give us a nationwide coverage.”

Back to top

ITM hydrogen stations already serve taxi fleets and emergency services, including the Metropolitan Police, which runs 11 Toyota Mirais. “Those organisations need their vehicles 24 hours a day and don’t have time to plug in and recharge,” says Yellen, who has run the same Mirai as his daily driver since 2015 and seen no drop in performance.

The cost of refuelling today at ITM stations is £10 per kilogramme plus VAT (a Mirai can take 5kg). Yellen is aiming for that to fall to around £7 plus VAT, which would represent only a small premium over diesel. He firmly believes hydrogen will be an essential part of future energy scenarios, saying: “It’s absolutely clear that if you want to get to net-zero, you must have hydrogen in the mix. You won’t be able to do seasonal storage, standby generation or heavy goods transport without it.”

It’s estimated that there are 53,600 hydrogen vehicles in use globally today – 18,000 cars and 31,000 forklift trucks, the rest commercial vehicles. Just 240 are registered in the UK, but that total could well rise rapidly in the next decade or two.

How hydrogen cars work

Fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEVs) are electric vehicles with a hydrogen fuel cell system instead of a large battery pack. Hydrogen is stored in a tank at 700bar, a stack generates high-voltage electricity and a small buffer battery provides transient power for acceleration and storing energy from regenerative braking.

Stacks are made up of smaller fuel cells (there are 370 in Toyota’s system), each containing a polymer membrane sandwiched between a catalyst-coated anode and cathode. Hydrogen flows through the cathode side and air through the anode side. Protons in the hydrogen atoms are attracted through the membrane to combine with oxygen in the air to make water, giving this type of fuel cell the name proton exchange membrane (PEM). The electrons left behind produce an electrical current between the anode and cathode.

Back to top

Challenges during development included water produced inside the stack, robustness and starting up in very low temperatures. Fuel cells were expensive, too, but their cost has been falling and Toyota expects parity with hybrids by 2025. Full hydrogen tanks have been subjected to violent testing over the years – including being shot – and hydrogen is dangerous only in a confined space, so fuel cell systems have leakage sensors. Otherwise, it disperses harmlessly into the air.

Refilling an FCEV with hydrogen is much the same as refilling a traditional car with petrol or diesel, except the pump nozzle locks firmly into the filler to deliver the high pressure. Drivers of FCEVs experience little difference in refuelling, while the driving experience is exactly the same as in a battery EV.

Who's doing what?

Mercedes-Benz: In 1998, Mercedes became the first maker of a road-legal FCEV: the A-Class-based Necar 4. It’s more focused on battery EVs now but has the GLC F-Cell prototype and decades of research behind it.

General Motors: GM had invested £1.9bn in fuel cell tech by 2016, produced the innovative Hywire concept in 2002 and the Equinox FCEV in 2008 and partnered with Honda, but it recently shelved its FCEV plans.

Back to top

Ford: Once in partnership with Daimler and major Canadian fuel cell developer Ballard, Ford has scaled back its FCEV interest. However, its Chinese partner, Jiangling, produces hydrogen-fuelled heavy trucks.

BMW: Late to the party but now in partnership with experienced Toyota, BMW sees the potential for fuel cells predominantly in larger vehicles. It’s currently developing the i Hydrogen Next, an X5-sized SUV.

Jaguar Land Rover: JLR has no previous with FCEVs, but its recent interest – the creation of Project Zeus, which aims to produce a Range Rover FCEV – highlights the fact this tech has matured and is now far more accessible.

Back to top

Toyota: Toyota started seriously working on hydrogen fuel cell tech way back in 1992 and put the Mirai on sale in 2015. A second-generation version is due later this year.

Hyundai: Hyundai has also been developing fuel cell technology since the 1990s. Following an FCEV version of the ix35 came the bespoke Nexo, which is now on UK sale.

Honda: Honda was one of the first to the table, starting basic research on hydrogen fuel cells in the late 1980s, and has offered its Clarity FCEV in the US since 2008.

READ MORE

BMW i Hydrogen Next concept previews fuel cell range 

BMW details hydrogen plans including 369bhp powertrain 

Jaguar Land Rover project aims for hydrogen SUVs by 2030

Join the debate

Comments
14

14 October 2020

There are so many things wrong in this article its laughable. Toyota and Hyundai sell hydrogen cars in the UK, really, 10 a year to dealers maybe. Besides they cannot sell them they only lease them, no fool would buy one. In the states were registrations have been falling, they are now down to less than 2000 a year despite giving them away, even secondhand ones get 15,000 worth of fuel credits 

14 October 2020

Where it says electicity dimishes during transport but hydrogen does not. Yes hydrogen does, it is always leaking, it also makes everything brittle it touches to the point it becomes dangerous over time. 

14 October 2020

You have 40 miles left in the tank and the nearest station closed. Only choice is to wait for a tow truck.

14 October 2020

Cars are 60k a pop and more 10kg for the fuel, you will be lucky to get the equivalent of 25mpg opposed to 220mpg in a Leaf or Model 3.   You can fill up a BEV every night at home whilst you are asleep, good look finding a hydrogen station to queue up at.

14 October 2020

XXXX, with only 4 comments to this article, i am still a little unsure if you like Hydrogen cars or prefer BEVs? Perhaps you could be clearer next time.

I prefer the idea of Hydrogen as a future fuel to batteries but can see the technology is not as far developed as EVs today, however I look forward to a future with choice

14 October 2020

I could have come up with alot more. Yes to choice, BEVs and ICEs will make a good mix for the next 30 years, but if you are going to wait to travel in a sensible hydrogen cars it will probably be hearse the tech is so far behind

14 October 2020
xxxx wrote:

I could have come up with alot more. Yes to choice, BEVs and ICEs will make a good mix for the next 30 years, but if you are going to wait to travel in a sensible hydrogen cars it will probably be hearse the tech is so far behind

But where are we without experimenting, researching and testing.  It's part of how we evolve.  Hydrogen may or may not work but we learn nothing without trying.

14 October 2020

If EVs become 30-40% better - range, refuelling time, cost - then I don't see how hydrogen can compete. This is not based on some breakthrough tech, like solid state batteries, but incremental improvement... and the car industry is very good at this.

HOWEVER, for shipping, aviation and trucks, Hydrogen looks very promising, and the car industry could help pave the way. Green hydrogen - just imagine how much renewable you could install at Heathrow for example - solar and compact wind turbines. There are even reservoirs nearby for water supply, or you could collect run off from the runways.

 

21 October 2020
scrap wrote:

If EVs become 30-40% better - range, refuelling time, cost - then I don't see how hydrogen can compete.

Hydrogen fuel cell vehicles are EVs.

The fuel cells generates the electrical energy to drive the electric motors, in real time while the electricity is being consumed (with a smaller buffer battery in between, which also is being loaded by energy recovery by braking).

The difference of such a FCEV to a BEV is that the BEV's battery is large and very heavy (they add 50% weight in the CMP platform based small cars of the PSA brands compared to the ICE powered version) and that the electrical energy to load the battery must be available in the grid in real time when the car is standing still for charging the battery. Most users will want to charge the BEV battery in the night when they are sleeping, but then the photovoltaic energy is not available...

 

14 October 2020
Marc wrote:

xxxx wrote:

I could have come up with alot more. Yes to choice, BEVs and ICEs will make a good mix for the next 30 years, but if you are going to wait to travel in a sensible hydrogen cars it will probably be hearse the tech is so far behind

But where are we without experimenting, researching and testing.  It's part of how we evolve.  Hydrogen may or may not work but we learn nothing without trying.

But dont gloss over the drawbacks and pretend it is brilliant and better than a bev.

The project has had billions spent on it over decades and yet they still sell every car at a loss of tens of thousands of pounds.  Wait till it is ready then make a car, like the LEAF then soon afterwards the Model S.

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review