From £83,63510
A Taycan for the very well off rather than the unfeasibly wealthy, yet which in almost all normal usage is as good as a Turbo, if not better
Andrew Frankel Autocar
10 December 2019

What is it?

If you’re interested in buying a Porsche Taycan, it is the one you should look at first. And then ask yourself a very serious question: what is the extra £32,000 or £55,000 required to upgrade this Taycan 4S to a Turbo or Turbo S actually buying you? 

If the answer is a slug more power you may never use, a load of equipment you might never spec and a boot badge for which you give not two hoots, do yourself a favour and spare yourself the money. I would suggest that for most prospects, or at least those who can stomach the opprobrium of friends and colleagues when they see – oh the shame of it – that it’s not the top model, this Taycan 4S is for now the Taycan au choix. The one you should buy. And the only non-neg option should be the performance plus battery at £4613. 

That buys you a 93.4kWh battery compared to a 79.2kWh unit, which not only provides additional range, but faster charging and better performance. So it’s a win, win, win.

And even this (for now) entry-level Taycan will still hit 62mph in four seconds flat, and because electric cars deliver their torque instantly, even that can be quite an uncomfortably rapid experience. It will do rest to 100mph in 8.5sec, for goodness sake, and I’m old enough to remember when that was a perfectly passable 0-60mph time.

Put it this way: in all remotely normal use, this poverty-spec Taycan will still accelerate you from any speed you’re at to any speed you could want at any rate you might choose.

Like the Turbo and Turbo S, it comes with an electric motor at either end of the car and four-wheel drive as a result. Unlike all other EVs, it shares their 800V electric infrastructure. It even sits on triple-chamber air springs at each corner and has Porsche’s PASM adaptive dampers as standard.

Such similarities might lead you to suspect that a Taycan 4S powertrain is, in reality, that of a Turbo or even a Turbo S with only a line of pesky software holding it back: crack the code and a 740bhp Taycan 4S can be yours. Sadly not: The 4S has a smaller rear motor than either of the Turbo twins, and before you start thinking you could still turn a Turbo into a Turbo S, think again: the Turbo has the same 300-amp front inverter as the 4S, while the Turbo S has a 600-amp inverter. So now you know.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Find an Autocar review

Back to top

What's it like?

Regardless of what the figures say, I have no doubt the 4S with the big battery will have the longest range of any Taycan, not just because of the performance differential, but because it weighs a whopping 165kg less than the Turbo. And because the Turbos are so fast as to actually seem briefly alarming (at least to any unsuspecting passengers), they at least will be glad its performance remains somewhere within the bounds of sanity.

But while everyone bangs on about the powertrain, to me the chassis is arguably its greater achievement. When I drove the Turbo S, I marvelled at how well Porsche had been able to manage such enormous mass, and the lighter 4S is better still. No four-door car of this kind of weight blends handling and ride so skilfully – and certainly not a Panamera – and the way the car delivers limousine ride comfort with steering response and accuracy to make it feel far smaller than it is, is unapproached in the marketplace regardless of what’s under the bonnet.

I’d still not call it fun, at least once the novelty value of its power delivery has worn off, but if there is a genuinely fun electric production car out there, I’ve not driven it. It is engaging, satisfying and ultimately rewarding to drive and, for where most electric cars are right now, that is a triumph.

Should I buy one?

A five-star verdict from Autocar is not like one from most other publications. They are rare and when they appear they mean something. I agonised over this one so much I felt the need to ring the editor and reappraise myself of the terms of reference. But if a car is genuinely outstanding in all areas that matter relative to its peers – in this case, other four-door EVs – and deficient in none, five stars are appropriate.

Back to top

I’d not consider it for either the Turbo or Turbo S, but when the 4S provides so much of their magic with so little downside and for such vast savings, nothing less seems right. The Taycan was already the best electric car on sale, the 4S is nothing less than the best of the best. Five stars it is.

Porsche Taycan 4S specification

Where Los Angeles, US Price £86,367 On sale Now Engine Two asynchronous electric motors Power 429bhp (523bhp on overboost); 498bhp with performance plus battery (563bhp on overboost) Torque 472lb ft (479lb ft with performance plus battery) Gearbox 2-spd automatic Kerb weight 2140kg Top speed 155mph (governed) 0-62mph 4.0sec Range 207-253 miles (240-288 miles with performance plus battery) CO2 0g/km Rivals Tesla Model S P100D, Jaguar I-Pace

Join the debate

Comments
30
Add a comment…
275not599 11 December 2019

This is what you expect a

This is what you expect a Porsche EV to be: well made, good to drive and very expensive.  But if I were a designer, I would rather have the Hyundai Kona on my CV.

jer 11 December 2019

Suppose its 95k with battery and basic options

But a nice car non the less. Porsche make good cars and also have a large press fleet i notice.

xxxx 11 December 2019

Out of interest

jer wrote:

But a nice car non the less. Porsche make good cars and also have a large press fleet i notice.

What are the BASIC £4,500 options?

xxxx 11 December 2019

Check box, potential outcome

£79k Model S or £86k Porsche:

Acceleration - Draw

Range - Tesla

Cornering and driver experience - Porsche

Depreciation and reliability - Porsche

Quality and ownership experience - Porsche

After reading the review the only advantage the Model S has is an extra 50 miles of range and 10% purchase price saving. 

p.s. I'm Tesla fan by the way! 

Cenuijmu 11 December 2019

xxxx wrote:

xxxx wrote:

£79k Model S or £86k Porsche:

Acceleration - Draw

Range - Tesla

Cornering and driver experience - Porsche

Depreciation and reliability - Porsche

Quality and ownership experience - Porsche

After reading the review the only advantage the Model S has is an extra 50 miles of range and 10% purchase price saving. 

p.s. I'm Tesla fan by the way! 

Good summary. Although perhaps you could say the Tesla has better software and upgradability? 

I think the S is badly showing it's age now and I'd rather have a model 3 if I had to have a Tesla, or the Y if it was being made now. 

Technomad 11 December 2019

I had a Model S loaner a

I had a Model S loaner a couple of weeks ago, whilst my Model 3 was having some work done. The S is still nice to drive, but it did feel rather old-fashioned!

Torque Stear 11 December 2019

xxxx wrote:

xxxx wrote:

£79k Model S or £86k Porsche:

Acceleration - Draw

Range - Tesla

Cornering and driver experience - Porsche

Depreciation and reliability - Porsche

Quality and ownership experience - Porsche

After reading the review the only advantage the Model S has is an extra 50 miles of range and 10% purchase price saving. 

p.s. I'm Tesla fan by the way! 

Item 1: The Tesla is much better equipped, you would need to add a whole load of options to the Taycan make it comparable, the only real option on the Tesla is full self driving which is not availible on the Porsche at any price.

Item 2: Interior space, the Porsche is more comparible to a Model 3

Item 3: Import duty, Tesla pays 10% to come to the EU and Porsche pays 10% in the US, the Tesla is much cheaper especially when combined with item 1.

Item 4: The Model S is due a refresh, the Nurburgring test cars had a centrally mounted screen like a Model 3.

As the TopGear test said the two cars aren't really rivals apart from being about as quick as each other. The interior space and practicality for example aren't really an issue for most Taycan drivers, they are trading practicality for looks.

Peter Cavellini 11 December 2019

And one is,,?

Torque Stear wrote:

xxxx wrote:

£79k Model S or £86k Porsche:

Acceleration - Draw

Range - Tesla

Cornering and driver experience - Porsche

Depreciation and reliability - Porsche

Quality and ownership experience - Porsche

After reading the review the only advantage the Model S has is an extra 50 miles of range and 10% purchase price saving. 

p.s. I'm Tesla fan by the way! 

Item 1: The Tesla is much better equipped, you would need to add a whole load of options to the Taycan make it comparable, the only real option on the Tesla is full self driving which is not availible on the Porsche at any price.

Item 2: Interior space, the Porsche is more comparible to a Model 3

Item 3: Import duty, Tesla pays 10% to come to the EU and Porsche pays 10% in the US, the Tesla is much cheaper especially when combined with item 1.

Item 4: The Model S is due a refresh, the Nurburgring test cars had a centrally mounted screen like a Model 3.

As the TopGear test said the two cars aren't really rivals apart from being about as quick as each other. The interior space and practicality for example aren't really an issue for most Taycan drivers, they are trading practicality for looks.

I agree, they are different, ones a sports car the other..isn't, one gets compared to everything, the other....doesn't, I try not to compare,there both pricey, but one should stop taking the moral high ground, as if it's the bench mark, it may have started the rush but the big boys are catching up quick, Elon Musk is a genius but Tesla's will not take over the car market.

Find an Autocar car review