From £90,0858
Flagship Jaguar XJR now puts out 567bhp from a supercharged 5.0-litre V8 as part of a wider XJ revamp, but is it a match for an S-Class?

Our Verdict

Jaguar XJR

The Jaguar XJR is an enormously attractive and satisfyingly rapid luxury saloon marred only by a slightly firm ride

  • First Drive

    Jaguar XJR 575 2017 UK review

    Super-saloon is super slick, dynamic, luxurious and fast in a straight line, but the XJR 575 lacks the modern sophistication of its newer, fitter rivals
  • First Drive

    Jaguar XJR 575 SWB 2017 review

    Flagship Jaguar XJR now puts out 567bhp from a supercharged 5.0-litre V8 as part of a wider XJ revamp, but is it a match for an S-Class?
Matt Prior
25 October 2017

What is it?

I almost wonder if the most important thing to know about the Jaguar XJ is that there’ll definitely be another generation after this one. “A flagship car company needs a flagship car,” says Ian Callum, Jaguar’s design director.

But that it even came up for discussion – it wouldn’t with the Mercedes-Benz S-Class or BMW 7 Series, you suspect – shows you where the XJ is. Celebs phone Jaguar and say they’d like to arrive at events in the back of an XJ because not many other people will. It’s starting to become a hero of its own lack of success.

Anyway, this one has been around for seven years now. Doesn’t quite seem possible, does it? So here it is. Surely, we’ll see the new one in the next couple of years – and Callum says it’ll be “wilfully different” from something like an S-Class “because there’s no point taking them on at their game”. Which sounds fair. Meanwhile, though, the current XJ has been given a range of tweaks to make it, if not an all-singing, all-dancing technological marvel, then at least humming gently and tapping its foot. I’d forgotten how broad the XJ range is – depending on where you live. 

You can have a 3.0-litre diesel, which is what most UK buyers have. But there’s also a 3.0-litre supercharged V6 petrol, which can be had in rear drive or all-wheel drive (AWD). Then there’s the 5.0-litre V8 petrol, which is itself available in three versions. There’s one with 464bhp, another with 503bhp and then there’s the full-fat XJR 575, which now has 567bhp (575PS) rather than 542bhp. And all of these can be had in standard or long-wheelbase styles.

Because the XJR is the only one in the range to have received a power increase, that seems like the most suitable car on which to base our review of the 2018-model-year car. No other reason at all. Definitely not that it also has the ability to smoke up its tyres at will and that this sounds like a giggle. No, no.

What's it like?

All rear-driven XJs receive electric rather than hydraulic power steering (although the AWD retains a hydraulic rack). There’s a new 10.0in touchscreen in the middle of the dashboard and around all of that comes updated software, plus some new technological and active safety features such as lane keeping and parking assist (hence the electric steering), city braking and radar cruise that can take you to and from a standstill. 

The nice thing about the XJ has always been that it is wilfully different from the German luxury car club. I can feel people at Bentley wincing at the word ‘luxury’ even as I type it. An S-Class isn’t luxury, they’re thinking, because nobody hangs off a cliff on guide ropes to cut burrs from an incredibly rare tree so they can use them for veneer. They don’t do that at Jaguar, either, but the word ‘luxury’ feels less dirty in relation to an XJ than it does to an S-Class or Audi A8 even though, in fact, it’s less luxurious – if you’re counting toys – than both.

Why is that? It isn’t the perceived quality, because there’s nothing in an S-Class that has anything remotely to fear from an XJ’s interior. And, like I say, it certainly isn’t that the XJ has more buttons or is more advanced. But there is something, and I’m not sure it’s solely the fact that it’s rarer.

Maybe it’s the design. The Jaguar is an attractive car inside and out. Mostly out, but it’s swishy around the dash top, too. But perhaps it’s because it also feels a little more old-school in its charm. It’s a bit more involving, a bit more engaging, a bit more personal. If I had to pick a car in this class that felt most like a Rolls-Royce Phantom, a car that is the very epitome of luxury, I suppose it would be the XJ. Although I can’t yet pinpoint why. Maybe you can’t define it. Or maybe I just don’t understand it.

Still, let’s start with the rear seats. They’re good. In the long-wheelbase XJ, where rear leg room is excellent, Jaguar says they are ‘airline-style’ individual chairs, which move and whatnot. Very comfy, too. Personally, I’d ditch the term ‘airline’ next time, because having your shampoo X-rayed before and paying £4.75 for an M&S bacon roll leave the word feeling less glamorous than it used to be. For a short-haul flight, sign me up to the back of an XJ every time.

But it’s the front seat where my – and, I suspect, your – real interest lies. It is in driving where the XJ range in general and the XJR in particular remain the most endearing luxury-class car of all.

Even with electric assistance, it still steers. I’ll admit it has been a good couple of years since I drove an XJ, so I can’t tell you whether it is better or worse now than it was before, but it’s certainly still oily smooth and pleasingly weighted, with the right amount of self-centring. There’s nothing else in the class quite this good.

Likewise, it has a remarkable deftness to its ride quality. Its ability to sooth bumps is superior to all but the most pillowy versions of the S-Class and yet it retains control of its 1875kg body. Design and dynamics: that’s what Jaguar seems to get right every time.

The engine and ’box combo is rather good, too. All that has liberated the extra 25bhp is a change to the engine control unit, so it remains a terrific-sounding, mellow yet linearly responsive engine that shifts smoothly and smokes its rear tyres with ease; not that anybody ever will, away from a Middle Eastern or Russian highway. It can’t go on forever, can it, a powertrain like this? A 5.0-litre supercharged donkey with 567bhp but 25.5mpg and 264g/km? We saw about 18mpg, by the way. I suppose it will for a long while yet, in some parts of the world, but it’s starting to feel – albeit wonderfully – out of kilter with northern Europe. 

Should I buy one?

All of which leaves the XJR where, exactly? A bit old-fashioned and a bit old-school? Perhaps. Is it as tech-laden as an S-Class or the latest A8? Is it heck. Is it as crushingly capable as a Porsche Panamera? Could it wrestle a live rhino to the ground like a BMW 760Li? I shouldn’t imagine so for a second. For all of these reasons and more, I couldn’t bring myself to give the XJ any more than four stars. But I also don’t think it matters that much, which is why I’d recommend one in a second.

Jaguar XJR 575 SWB

Where Leiria, Portugal; On sale Now; Price £93,710; Engine 5000cc, V8, supercharged petrol; Power 567bhp at 6250-6500rpm; Torque 517lb ft at 3500-4500rpm; Gearbox 8-spd automatic; Kerbweight 1875kg; Top speed 186mph; 0-62mph 4.4sec; Fuel economy 25.5mpg; CO2 rating/BIK 264g/km, 37%; Rivals BMW M760Li, Mercedes-AMG S65, Porsche Panamera Turbo

Join the debate

Comments
16

25 October 2017

Reviewer seems to have alot of issues with this £94,000 old slow selling barge but one of the last sentences about 'not being able to give more than 4 stars' is interesting given the number of posts regarding bias towards JLR

typos1 - Just can’t respect opinion

25 October 2017
I have a soft spot does these but it needs chrome and silver wheels. This this horrible dechroming black wheel trend is painfull

25 October 2017

Still looks a great alternative to boring Germanic trio or an suv.Probably best purchased 2 to 3 yrs old like the German trio

25 October 2017
Autocar wrote:

...If I had to pick a car in this class that felt most like a Rolls-Royce Phantom, a car that is the very epitome of luxury, I suppose it would be the XJ. Although I can’t yet pinpoint why. Maybe you can’t define it. Or maybe I just don’t understand it...

Allow me to offer a possible explantion. It's a kind of subjectivity called: "a British tester, talking about a British (if Indian owned) car". I'm not necessarily talking about deliberate favourtism, but it's natural to subconciously want a 'home grown' car and brand to be better, more desirable and classier than the foriegn competition.

As you say yourself, the German competion rivals are better built, have higher quality standards, are more refined, have lovely interiors, are smoother and more soothing to drive and have all manner of advanced gizmos. So, it's gotta be a subjective thing to regard the XJR 575 as more luxurious, isn't it?

25 October 2017

I think you've nailed it!

25 October 2017

If you're going to pony up a preposterous sum of money it has to this or a Maserati Quattroporte. The German alternatives may be a more rational choice but they will always just be big BMWs and Mercs with all the allure and prescence of upmarket taxis.

 

25 October 2017

Audi and BMW dealers writing on here during their lunch break or a genuine gripe with Autocar's editorial bias?  Reading all the various JLR reviews on here plus the comments that follow, I think both sides balance each other out nicely.  Keep up the good work troops: the truth, as usual, is somewhere in between.

25 October 2017

The XJ may be 7 years old now but on looks alone, both inside and out, it still exudes desirability and prestige which an A8, 7 Series or S Class can never get close too. The outside styling may polarise opinion but it also has presence, class, prestige and exquisitieness which its aforementioned rivals simply don't possess, more so as they look just like the smaller cars in their company's model line up. And the interior still exudes class, luxury, warmth and desirability which again its rivals don't come close to matching with their dull, uninspiring and cold styling. And more importantly on looks inside and out the XJ looks and feels expensive which the Audi, BMW and Mercedes do not, again mainly because they look like their smaller siblings. Park a XJ next to an A8, 7 Series or S Class and its clear which one looks far more special, prestigious, classy and expensive and the car everyone would walk towards. And you know it'd be Jaguar without fail. Only the Ghost, Flying Spur and Quattroporte can match the Jaguar in these areas, as can the new Lexus LS in my opinion.

25 October 2017

Noble attempt Roadster but the only thing falling faster than XJ sales is it's deprication. 

S class outsells it nearly 10-1, 7 Series about 8-1 in Europe.

In the US the Tesla Model S outsells it by about 7-1.

typos1 - Just can’t respect opinion

25 October 2017

Sort it out please Jaguar!

Steam cars are due a revival.

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Mercedes-Benz C-Class C200 2018 review hero front
    First Drive
    20 June 2018
    Mild hybrid engine completes an extensive facelift for Mercedes’ fourth-generation junior saloon, but the C200 isn’t the most convincing choice in the line-up
  • Mercedes-AMG C43 2018 first drive review hero front
    First Drive
    19 June 2018
    Greater shove and some subtle styling tweaks for the 'baby' AMG C-Class, but the C 43 Coupe makes less of a case for itself than the saloon or estate
  • Citroen Berlingo 2018 first drive review hero front
    First Drive
    19 June 2018
    Boxy, slightly quirky van-based car returns to top form in only third iteration in more than two decades
  • Porsche Cayenne 2018 UK first drive review hero front
    First Drive
    19 June 2018
    Performance doesn't come at the expense of comfort and composure in Porsche's mid-range Cayenne
  • Skoda Kodiaq
    First Drive
    18 June 2018
    High-spec seven-seater Kodiaq begins its family life with a lot to prove — for Skoda and SUVs