Its constant presence, in conjunction with a moderate amount of road noise, detracts from the BMW’s otherwise pleasing nature. The transmission also has a tendency to hang on to higher gears, occasionally loading the engine up and causing some resonance and drone.
Otherwise, the BMW is a fine driving machine with few negative traits. It steers in a precise, easily controlled fashion with minimal body roll, although the steering is a little heavy.
It stops swiftly, visibility is good and it’s easy to manoeuvre. The ride is also delightfully smooth and controlled, and wind noise low. Overall, it’s a relaxing, competent performance.
It’s hard to fault the BMW’s appeal elsewhere. It’s a smart-looking and sensibly sized SUV with an upmarket interior. There’s lots of space front and rear and a big boot adds to its practicality. Even under the bonnet the X3 is well finished, further reinforcing its high-end feel.
Should I buy one?
If the potential economy or tax benefits of the four-cylinder appeal to you, then the BMW is by no means a poor option. Its performance, overall appeal and general characteristics are unlikely to disappoint.
If you can tolerate ditching M Sport trim’s cosmetic extras, the superior six-cylinder diesel X3 is available for £2155 more in lesser SE trim. It’s a comparatively small hike and, for many, the six-cylinder won’t prove to be much more costly to run for private buyers. It’s also faster and more refined and better suits the BMW’s premium status.
However, if you wanted to retain the cleaner, more sporty looks of the M Sport – but with a six-cylinder diesel – you’d have to pay a more significant £5155 more. Company car drivers, considering either trim level, will also have to pay a substantial hike in company car tax for the 3.0-litre diesel version.
BMW X3 xDrive20d M Sport
Price £37,635; 0-62mph 8.1sec; Top speed 131mph; Economy 54.3mpg (combined); CO2 138g/km; Kerb weight 1820kg; Engine 4 cyls, 1995cc, turbo diesel; Power 188bhp at 4000rpm; Torque 295lb ft at 1750-2500rpm; Gearbox 8-spd automatic