From £29,7007
Easygoing, comfortable BMW 420d convertible offers plenty, but its squidgy nature won't excite spirited drivers
Nic Cackett
7 March 2014

What is it?

We’ve already driven the range-topping BMW 435i convertible, now it’s the turn of the car which will make most of the volume - the 420d. Aside from the engine, this is much the same car; a lower, longer and wider prospect than the model it replaces, and one that continues to sport a retractable metal hard-top roof. 

From launch, the familiar 181bhp 2.0-litre unit will be the only diesel engine available with the convertible, and its frugality affords the car 55.4mpg economy and 133g/km CO2 emissions in conjunction with the six-speed manual gearbox. Select BMW’s eight-speed automatic, and they improve to 58.9mpg and 127g/km. 

There are five trim levels to choose from, starting with the SE sampled here (although not on UK roads). The mechanics of a life cycle change means the 420d ends up with more standard kit than its predecessor - including the current 3 Series’s large infotainment screen, iDrive controller, Drive Performance Control, 17-inch alloy wheels and heated front seats. 

The price difference is a modest £495. But that still sees the model start at £36,675 - almost £2500 more than the equivalent Audi A5 cabriolet 2.0 TDI SE. The example tested also featured a number of options - BMW’s Professional media system, 18-inch wheels, adaptive suspension - hiking its final total to £43,850. 

What's it like?

Much like the 435i - hardly short on quality, but overall a disappointment. The blame for this is not difficult to spread around. The bulk of it, appropriately and inevitably, must be placed on the vast, mechanism-festooned roof which barely fits in the boot and weighs the dynamic equivalent of a planet. 

Watching it slowly unfold from its overstuffed hiding place, a lengthy, 20-second process which plays out with with all the irksome methodicalness of an elderly scout leader opening a map, one wonders why BMW insisted on persevering with the three-piece tin-top. 

Its benefits are negligible - under it, the 420d is no more refined than a contemporary fabric roof - and the penalty unavoidable. 

The 320d SE weighs 1495kg. The 420d SE weighs 1755kg. That extra burden is not easily hidden. The 435i buries it under 302bhp of straight-six concealer; the 420d, even with a healthy 280lb ft of torque available, is less able to do the same - especially when the four-cylinder engine’s well-known shortfall in refinement is taken into account. 

However, the vocal, gearknob-rattling motor is at least game; the suspension tune is not. 

BMW’s engineers have certainly beavered away underneath to shoulder the strain - ultra-stiff control arms and axle subframes have been slightly repositioned, pivot points adjusted, the camber angle and roll centre fine-tuned - but even in the most aggressive of its four modes (Sport+), the conspicuously doughy result never settles into quick progress like the 3 Series. 

Clearly, a more benign, agreeably cushioned car was the intention here, and driven in a manner more befitting a mobile sun lounger, the 420d is at least comfortable. 


Find an Autocar review

Back to top

Only the meanest of surfacing infringements will dial themselves into the seat backs, and the roof-down interior is acceptably blustery rather than tempestuous. But too much of the former flair is gone; push on, and the car can no longer push back. 

Should I buy one?

If buying a convertible is merely a four-up vanity exercise or a convenient way of keeping the comb-over flat, then the 420d’s newly inherited interior - typically first rate, easygoing attitude, solid residuals and likely very decent economy will certainly appeal, and duly make BMW’s entrant a match for its similarly fettled opposition in this segment. 

But the car feels even less like the current 3 Series than we expected, and in our book that’s more than just a shame. Just as the folding roof has been allowed to intrude on the model’s usable boot space (reducing it to just 220 litres - less than you’d get in a TT roadster) so has it mercilessly eroded the marvellous handling identity. 

That, above all else, is why the 320d is a five-star car - and why the 420d convertible certainly isn’t. 

BMW 420d convertible SE

Price £36,675; 0-62mph 8.2sec; Top speed 146mph; Economy 55.4mpg; CO2 133g/km; Kerb weight 1755kg; Engine 1995cc, 4 cyls, diesel; Power 181bhp at 4000rpm; Torque 280lb ft at 1750-2750rpm; Gearbox Six-speed manual

Join the debate

Add a comment…
Smilerforce 7 March 2014

I couldn't buy a diesel

I couldn't buy a diesel conviertable!! Especially in a 4 cylinder format. Just idling away would annoy me.

For looks this is pretty BMW, but I think a purchase can only be a 6 cylinder.

Racotau 7 March 2014

Simple solution... a 320d and drive along with your head out of the window. That way u get all the joys of wind in ur hair motoring, you're driving a decent car and you got a ton of cash left in ur wallet.
DBtechnician 7 March 2014

Impressive Car

Right up to the point when you turn the key and realise in a convertible the only sensible choice of engine is petrol powered.
So glad I was able to buy such a car with a turbo petrol engine, soft top & paddle shift gearbox when Saab still had some available in the 9-3.

Find an Autocar car review