The best sport saloons - driven, rated and ranked

A chassis of unequalled dynamic agility and super-direct steering makes this car feel more like a sports car, at times, than a practical five-seater. It has really wonderfully well-balanced grip levels also, and deserves a properly switchable stability control system that might allow you to explore and exploit those grip levels to maximum amusement. Sadly, the range-topping Quadrifoglio is the only Giulia on which you can fully deactivate the electronic nannies, although the Veloce does at least get a limited slip differential.

Alfa’s turbocharged 2.0-litre petrol engine gives the car a healthy 276bhp, and it sounds fairly pleasant and revs freely by 4-cyl turbo standards. It’s just a shame that’s not quite what the chassis is worthy of, or what rivals for the same money will provide; because in other ways this car is little short of brilliant, especially when you consider it's priced at a whisker over £46,000 and that a facelift in 2023 will bring subtly updated looks and vastly improved interior tech and finish.

Save money with new Giulia deals from What Car?

3. Mercedes-AMG C43

The Mercedes-AMG C43 gave us our first glimpse of the high performance four-cylinder powered C-Class, which would ultimately lead to the plug-in hybrid C63 that has so far received a lukewarm welcome. Unlike its more muscular brother, the C43 does without the high voltage electricals, getting instead for the same turbocharged (the compresser is assisted by an electric motor for less lag) 2.0-litre that is here linked to a 48V mild hybrid system. The result is 402bhp and 369lb ft of torque - figures that trump the old V6-engined model.

As you'd expect, the latest C43 lacks the aural character of its predecessor, but the four-pot is a smooth and eager performer, plus with a 0-62mph time of 4.6 seconds this isn't a slow car. It feels posed and nimble in the corners too, with direct and well-weighted steering, stong grip and good body control. Yet despite its 4MATIC all-wheel drive transmission promising a 31:69 front to rear torque split, the Merc doesn't have the same rear-driven feel as the BMW M340i, preferring instead a more neutral stance that bleeds into understeer at the limit. 

Everywhere else it's pure C-Class, which means a cosseting and beautifully finished cabin (that's a trifle overdone with tech), plus top notch cruising refinement - although the ride remains firm even in the softest adaptive damper settings. It's also hobbled by a price tag that's the thick end of £10,000 more than its BMW arch-rival.

4. Peugeot 508 PSE

Peugeot’s sportiest-option 508 saloon (it's really a hatchback) comes in plug-in petrol electric guise only, which makes it a top option for company car users looking for some fun outside of the 9 to 5. With its combination of turbocharged 1.6-litre petrol and a pair of electric motors, the PSE (that's Peugeot Sport Engineered) delivers a healthy 355bhp, yet can travel 26 miles in EV mode and attracts a 14% BiK rating (which isn't outstanding by hybrid standards, but knocks the others here, bar the Tesla, into a cocked hat).

More importantly for our purposes, the 508 handles with appealing directness and keenness, demonstrating a rare combination of control and compliance that used to be a French car calling card. The Peugeot dives into corners with enthusiasm and clings on hard, while you can feel the rear-mounted electric motor trying to straighten your line at the exit of corner. Yet all the time, the PSE is breathing with surface, allowing you to pick apart a twisty stretch of tarmac with a satisfying fluidity.

The hybrid powertrain also has strong in-gear performance (once the slightly clumsy transmission has decided which ratio to pick), which makes it perfect for give-and-tack back roads as well as picking off slower traffic. And when you want to relax, the hushed and smooth riding Peugeot delivers, the sense of calm enhanced by a boldly designed interior that's almost matches premium players for material richness and solidity. Vive le difference!

Save money with new 508 deals from What Car?

5. Mercedes-AMG CLA 35 4MATIC

Smaller can quite often mean better when you’re comparing one driver’s car to another. Does it mean as much, then, in the case of Mercedes’ smaller, lower-order-AMG, four-door coupe: the CLA 35? Frankly, it depends what you’re comparing it with.

The CLA is, for starters, the smaller of two Mercedes four-door coupes, and does offer much more of the elegance and style of the bigger CLS for a cut-down price than the original CLA managed. Being part of Mercedes’ compact-car model family, however, the CLA is less practical, arguably, than even an A-Class hatchback. Meanwhile, being transverse-engined, it’s only ever four-wheel drive in fairly transient and qualified terms, and can’t compete with natively rear-driven 4WD options for throttle-on handling balance.

The ‘-35’ suffixed AMG version uses a 302bhp 2.0-litre four-cylinder turbo engine which has plenty to recommend it, as does the car’s meaty, tactile steering and its measured-yet-composed ride and handling. The car’s two-pedal, twin-clutch gearbox is less slick, though, and can disappoint with its roughness as well as its unpredictability. 

Save money with new CLA deals from What Car?

6. Audi S3 Saloon

Audi’s four-door S3 didn’t become a part of the wider S3 model family until the third-generation car arrived in 2013, but quickly seemed to make itself at home in the model range thereafter. It was therefore no surprise this swift saloon was a part of the all-new A3 line-up that debute in 2020. Once again, this model since below the growling, howling RS3 in Audi's compact performance car pecking order.

Whichever way you cut it, the new S3 looks more aggressive than before, sharing as it does the standard car's more angular design complete with its subtly flared wheelarches. However, under the skin it's surprisingly similar, with a development of the MQB scalable architecture and the time-honoured EA888 turbocharged 2.0-litre four-cylinder motor that delivers a decent 306bhp and drives all four wheels through a Haldex controlled transmission. Like all cars with this engine, the S3 is a smooth and lusty performance, with plenty of low down muscle and a linear power delivery that delivers 0-62mph in 4.8 seconds.

Also unchanged is a driving experience that's a little reserved, the Audi's speed being delivered through a luxury filter which kills some - although far from all - of the fun factor. It always feels poised and planted on the road, and when the weather turns bad few can keep up, but as an involving driver's tool it trails the best, including the Mercedes-AMG CLA35. And if you don't tick the box for the optional adaptive dampers, then you can throw a firm ride into the mix too.

Elsewhere, trademark Audi design appeal comes together with plenty of material cabin quality to give the car unrivalled premium appeal, and as swift and easy-going small saloon to live with day in and out, it takes some beating.

Save money with new S3 deals from What Car?

7. VW Arteon R

Like the Peugeot 508, the Arteon is actually a hatchback, but its sleek lines fool you into thinking it's a saloon and that's a good enough reason for its inclusion here. Following the demise of the Passat, this is now VW's standard-bearer in the increasinly small D-segment. Handome lines and a high quality interior help it compete with premium rivals for showroom appeal, while this version makes it onto this list because its suave exterior hides the heart of a Golf R, meaning its got the performance chops too.

As with the Audi S3, the Arteon features the tried-and-tested EA888 2.0-litre four-pot, although here its tuned for 316bhp to deliver 0-62mph in 4.9 seconds, but as always with this motor it's the lusty mid-range and linear delivery that mark it out. It's aided by four-wheel drive traction that allows slingshot exits from slower corners, roundabouts and junctions, while the seven-speed twin-clutch auto serves-up smooth an quick shifts.

There's no escaping the fact the Arteon is a big car, but it handles with poise and precision nonetheless. The steering is slick and features a natural rate of response, while there's plenty of turn-in bite and limpet-like grip as the the car swivels nicely around your hips. There's very little adjustability and only enough feedback to give you the basics when it comes to what's going on at ground level, but the VW is still a fast and satisfying device for picking apart a favourite back road. Factor in a spacious cabin, decent ride comfort and strong refinement, and the German machine represents a fine choice for those seeking a rapid family hack that can do it all.

8. Audi S4

For Audi to decide to switch so many of its brisk but businesslike ‘S express’ sporting derivatives from petrol- to diesel in 2019 was a bold decision, especially considering the fall out from dieselgate over the last few years. It’s also a key sign that some of the most thorough engineers and key decision-makers in the car industry still accept the notion that, for those who want both real-world speed and drivability from a sport saloon as well as efficiency and refinement, there is still nothing to beat a big diesel engine.

And so a big diesel engine is what the Audi S4 now comes with. Specifically it’s a turbocharged 3.0-litre V6 diesel with a 48-volt electrical architecture and an additional electrically driven turbo in the mix, producing 336bhp and 516lb ft. That’s enough to send this car to 60mph in 4.6sec thanks to a very effective launch control system and quattro all-wheel drive transmission. From there the car rifles through the intermediate ratios of its eight-speed automatic gearbox very quickly indeed, piling on speed without really giving you much cause to notice.

The S4 is easy to drive quickly and very assured with it, although the driving experience it creates isn’t terrifically exciting or rich. That V6 isn’t particularly memorable to listen to, and while it’s ever-composed, the car’s handling only comes alive and begins to engage you really if you commit to over-driving it; which, on the road, you’ll likely seldom if ever do. That said, if you want to cover ground quickly, discreetly and surprisingly efficiently, then the S4 derserves a look.

Save money with new S4 deals from What Car?

9. Jaguar XF P300 R-Dynamic

Considering how much of Jaguar’s sporting reputation has been built by big-engined, rear-driven sport saloons, it’s surprising to find how scant the choice has become for Jaguar buyers who want a smooth multi-cylinder engine and the purity of a driven rear axle in their modern fast four-door. In fact, it's become impossible, because neither the XE or the XF offer such a combination anymore, which is as depressing to write as it no doubt is to read.

Today, those looking for a quick and capable big cat saloon are limited to a 296bhp turbocharged 2.0-litre that's mated to an all-wheel drive system that's driven through an eight-speed automatic. If you want rear-drive only, then power drops to 247bhp, which is just a little weak-kneed in the sports saloon club. Both the XE and XF are available in the higher powered spec, but our preference is for the latter, which offers much of the same driving experience but with a roomier and more upmarket interior.

Happily, the XF is a particularly sweet-handling option. Naturally paced, intuitive steering and a supple chassis deliver both poise and ride comfort in impressive measure to make this P300 the Jaguar saloon you’d pick from the current crop. And while purists might miss rear-wheel drive, the rear-biased all-wheel drive set-up gives a similar feel on the road but without the risk of an unexpected sideways whoopsie. Obviously, the weakest link is that engine, which is fairly characterless and, with a 0-62mpg time of 7.1 seconds, should be considered brisk rather than quick.