So the theory goes, saloons look and feel more upmarket than hatches. I don’t buy that. And I certainly don’t buy it when it comes to the Audi A5, available in five-door Sportback form, three-door coupé and cabriolet form.

It’s considerably more glamorous than the A4 saloon and not just for its relative rarity. It’s sleeker, prettier and more muscular than the four-door. The 2017 Audi A5 takes a meaner, more aggressive stance than before, which has impressed us thus far. 

As for the second generation S5, available in all three bodystyles, it is a no-nonsense fast mid-size Audi set to take the battle to the BMW 440i and the Mercedes-AMG C43, while leaving the grand battle for the AMG C63, M4 and the RS5 - although there are no definites one is on the horizon. Under the bonnet is an all-new 3.0-litre V6 turbocharged engine producing 349bhp putting in the same ballpark as its closest rivals.

But the first generation S5, we are focussing on here uses same 328bhp supercharged 3.0-litre V6 as the last S4, and comes as standard with four-wheel drive and a seven-speed dual-clutch gearbox.

A supercharged six is an esoteric engine in this type of car but it’s easily one of the best things about the S5, especially when paired to the DSG ’box.

As for trim levels the S5 is certainly well equipped with an aggressive bodykit and Audi Sport tweaks differentiating it from a normal A5. The second generation S5 gets 19in alloy wheels, sporty suspension, an enhanced braking system, an aggressive bodykit and adaptive headlights on the outside, while inside there is an Audi MMI infotainment system with an 8.3in display, sat nav, Bluetooth, DAB radio and a 10GB hard drive.

It’s lusty and linear right up to the red line and provides explosive overtaking potential from pretty much any speed. It doesn’t sound quite as spirited as the V8 that used to power the S-badged Audis. But it’s hardly shy and retiring at full chat, either, and there are clear fuel economy and emissions advantages.

Some of the usual Audi vices are in evidence, though, such as a lumpy low-speed ride and numb handling. Nothing wrong with the crisp way it tackles corners, however, though the caveat is that our test car was fitted with the optional sports differential and ‘dynamic’ steering. But even those pricey extras don’t result in a lot of information being telegraphed back to the driver..

If you’re a company car buyer, the S5 makes little fiscal sense and you’d be far better off with one of the diesels.

Top 5 Super saloons

  • Jaguar XFR
    Not only is the XFR the class leader, it is also exceptional value compared to rivals

    Jaguar XFR 2013-2015

  • Mercedes-AMG C 63
    Mercedes-AMG C 63 saloon is priced from £59,800

    Mercedes-AMG C 63

  • BMW M3

    BMW M3

  • Mercedes-AMG E 63
    The old 6.2-litre V8 has been dropped in favour of a twin-turbo 5.5-litre V8

    Mercedes-AMG E 63

  • Jaguar XJR
    The Jaguar XJR offers monstrous, relentless performance

    Jaguar XJR


First drives

Find an Autocar car review

Explore the Audi range

Driven this week

  • MX-5 RF 2.0 160
    First Drive
    17 January 2017
    The distinctive 'retractable fastback' roadster promises typical MX-5 dynamics coupled with better refinement. It achieves the former, but the latter isn't quite there yet
  • Hyundai i30 1.4 T-GDi Premium
    First Drive
    17 January 2017
    Facing increasingly formidable opposition, the Hyundai i30 has been overhauled for 2017. The result is a recognisably mixed bag
  • 2016 Infiniti Q50 Country Road
    First Drive
    12 January 2017
    Infiniti’s premium mid-sized saloon packs a serious punch, but lacks the dynamic prowess of European rivals
  • Nissan Micra Tekna IG-T
    First Drive
    10 January 2017
    Not quite a class-leading return to form, but a more stylish and tech-savvy kind of Micra than we’ve ever known – and an encouraging one to drive
  • Infiniti Q60 2.0t Premium Tech
    First Drive
    9 January 2017
    Infiniti’s entry-level mid-sized coupé has the looks to do well, but little of the substance to go with them