These are interesting times right now for learner drivers.

On the one hand, there are groups trying to work out how to try and re-enthuse teenagers about driving again, and on the other there are recommendations to improve safety that will force up the age of getting a license and the cost. Finding the right balance is tough.

The most recent suggestions have resulted in calls for the introduction of a 12-month learner period, and enforcing 120 hours of driver training during that period, including 20 hours of night time driving.

Thereafter, there would be a further probationary year that (under the proposals) would include a night time curfew, carrying a P badge, a ban on any kind of phone use - including hands-free - plus a lower blood alcohol limit than is standard now and a ban on carrying any passengers under 30 if the driver is under 30.

It’s hard to argue against proposals that promote safety, but there has been a noticeable backlash against the cost and restrictions of the legislation.

Arguments against the plans range from the fact the proposals are so punishing they will surely just encourage more illegal driving, through to the fact that employment in rural communities depends on being able to drive.

Is there a middle ground? Clearly there’s much debate still to be had, but if you can forgive the party political broadcast, I’d urge law makers and opinion-formers to keep an eye on Autocar Start. Regular readers will remember this was launched earlier this year, and provides a car, training and insurance for a fixed monthly fee.

To qualify, the driver must complete a set number of hours of tuition with an expert, the same amount with a trained friend, including night time driving, and then undergo a period of training after they have passed their test. In many ways, then, it does exactly what’s being proposed, but without imposing so many restrictions. 

The philosophy is very much one of demanding that the learner driver take their responsibilities seriously, and putting the framework around them to do that, and in return offering a competitive price and certain freedoms, such as avoiding restrictions on night driving or carrying passengers.