8
Volkswagen successfully miniaturises the performance Golf’s recipe for the first time; the Polo GTI is desirable, well rounded and fun to drive

Our Verdict

Volkswagen Polo

The sixth-generation Polo is bigger and more refined than ever before. But how does it compare with the class-leading Ford Fiesta and Seat Ibiza?

  • First Drive

    Volkswagen Polo GTI 2018 review

    Volkswagen successfully miniaturises the performance Golf’s recipe for the first time; the Polo GTI is desirable, well rounded and fun to drive
  • First Drive

    Volkswagen Polo 1.0 2017 review

    The new Volkswagen Polo has already impressed us, but what's it like with the most powerful naturally aspirated petrol engine in the nose?

What is it?

When you read the letters ‘GTI’, whether it’s in the first sentence of a car review or on the grille of a hatchback, you think ‘Golf’ – don’t you?

Bet you just have. Can’t help but. The Golf GTI celebrated its 40th anniversary last year, after all, and although Volkswagen has been trying to for more than two decades now, it has never quite successfully developed its defining hot hatch identity into a proper performance sub-brand.

There have been good attempts to do that (think Lupo GTI) and not-so-good ones (Mk3 Polo GTI, anyone?) since the mid-1990s, of course. But now there’s a new and more concerted bid to turn ‘GTI’ into an established family of models, and it involves the upcoming Up GTI city car and this: the go-faster version of the sixth-generation Polo.

As this car’s key creators will tell you, VW has toyed with the idea of a proper, supermini-sized GTI on previous attempts, committing to cars midway through a model lifecycle and adapting existing mechanical platforms for the purpose rather than designing them from scratch. But no longer. This Polo GTI has been in the making for the past three years, from the earliest design and specification stages of the VW Group’s ‘MQB-A0’ platform. As a result, the specialised powertrain, suspension and steering components it needs in order to be the best hot hatchback it can be have already been provided – they’re on the shelf, ready to go – while the car’s chassis has already been designed to accept the 18in wheels for the job.

The new Polo GTI gets the Golf GTI’s 2.0-litre turbocharged petrol engine; it’s slightly detuned to 197bhp and 236lb ft of torque but still strong enough to give the car a sub-7.0sec 0-62mph acceleration claim and top speed within a whisker of 150mph.

It’ll be available in May 2018 with a six-speed dual-clutch automatic gearbox, or with a six-speed manual later in the year. It gets lowered, stiffened suspension springs, uprated anti-roll bars and upgraded passive dampers as standard, but it can be had with switchable ‘sport select’ suspension as an option (which isn’t ‘DCC’ adaptive damping as such but instead describes dampers with two lots of compression and rebound settings that you can chop and change between electronically via the car’s driving modes).

Compared with the standard Polo on which it’s based, the GTI also has completely different front suspension knuckles, a stiffer torsion beam at the rear, rerated suspension bushings and entirely different axle geometries and roll centres. On the face of it – not just on the face of it, really – it’s a proper piece of performance engineering.

What's it like?

This car’s suspension tune was signed off by the same guy who was responsible for the handling of the remarkable Golf GTI Clubsport S: VW’s head of chassis development, Karsten Schebsdat. If this Polo GTI turns out to be the first one truly worthy of the badge, Karsten is probably be an important reason why. He’s got quite a CV, and it’s worth explaining before we get into the GTI in greater detail, because it speaks volumes about him.

Schebsdat’s career started at Ford in the mid-1990s, where he learned his trade from acknowledged masters such as Richard Parry-Jones and Lotus’s John Miles. The first car he worked on from a clean sheet was the original, epoch-making Focus. When he joined Volkswagen in the early 2000s, it was to help create Wolfsburg’s response to the Focus: the Golf Mk5. And later that decade he moved to Porsche, where he had a hand in every GT-badged version of the pre-facelift 997-generation 911. Apparently, Clarence Seedorf is the only footballer to have won the Champions’ League at three different clubs (thanks Google); he must be the only footballer with a CV to rival Karsten’s, I reckon.

But before we get too carried away, we should remember that Schebstad was creating a GTI, not a Renaultsport RS or a Ford ST, and those three letters have come to stand for a particularly driveable, pragmatic and rounded blend of affordable performance over the past decade or so – and not by accident. So the fact that this new hot Polo isn’t as firm-riding or as pointy and lively in its handling as the last, yobby but brilliant Fiesta ST probably won’t surprise you. That doesn’t mean it’s not a giggle to drive, however, or that it’s missing too much in the way of pace, grip, dynamic purpose or performance flavour. Far from it. It simply means that Volkswagen understands how the majority of GTI owners want to use their cars: every day, for every journey, whatever the road or the weather might throw up – and they don’t really want to be made to suffer for their fun, either.

As we already know, the new Polo’s cabin is a very spacious, expensive-looking and well-equipped place to be, but the GTI takes that rich, upmarket ambience up a notch. ‘Clark plaid’ tartan cloth sports seats go with the territory, of course – and although the Polo’s are a touch small and short in the cushion, they clench your backside very comfortably and securely enough, and they look great.

In front of you, if you’ve paid extra for them, are VW’s Active Info Display digital instruments in new, second-gen form – which means, technically, that this car has a more advanced instrument pack than any Golf, Tiguan, Arteon or Passat. The car’s driving position feels promisingly low and purposeful for a compact hatchback, and you can’t quibble with the equipment available (6.5in touchscreen infotainment system standard, 8.0in as an upgrade) nor the car’s very impressive standard of perceived quality.

The Polo GTI’s engine starts and settles to an undemonstrative hum, and the car can be driven around in Comfort mode as easily as if it were a mid-range model. With those optional switchable dampers in their Normal setting, it rides smoothly and quietly, asks little of you in terms of steering weight and gets along without much drama or fuss. If it didn’t, you get the impression it wouldn’t get signed off as a modern GTI, because modern GTI drivers want the option, at times, not to be jiggled, wearied, bothered or asked to invest much in the driving experience of their cars.

Cycle into Sport mode, though, and things change a fair bit. The car’s sports exhaust doesn’t exactly bellow or zing, but it rasps with a certain crackling menace that serves as the right sort of accompaniment to the car’s brisk turn of mid-range pace. The steering’s got weight and feel now to match its carefully metered directness and precision, while there's a tautness and bite to the body control that wasn’t present before. Now we’re talking.

The GTI’s six-speed DSG gearbox has the familiar manual mode, in which it’s quick-shifting, and for the most part it gives you a dependable sense of close control over the driving forces going into the front axle both under power and on a trailing throttle. This is important in a fast front-driver, I’ve always thought. It won’t hold onto a gear at the very top of the rev range even in manual mode, though, shifting up automatically well short of the marked 6500rpm redline. And, even in manual mode, the kickdown switch at the bottom of the accelerator pedal’s travel isn’t frozen out from proceedings. One way or another, then, you can have shifts foisted on you in this car – which is a bit annoying and a mistake that it’s unlike VW to make.

Outright performance feels fast but doesn’t take your breath away; by and large, of course, fast superminis don’t – although some of them certainly rev more keenly than the Polo GTI above 5000rpm. Not many have more peak torque than this, however - something that allows the GTI to make short work of the meat of its rev range and makes it easier to drive quickly than most of its opponents.

The fact that its ride is fairly moderately tuned, supple even in Sport mode, also makes it particularly well suited to fast, undemanding road driving – although it doesn’t make it feel soft or inert on a tight racetrack. Here, VW’s investment in hardware gives the Polo GTI reserves of grip and composure, in both wet and dry conditions, that mark it out as a true driver’s car. You can lean on the car’s outside wheels as hard as you like through a fast bend without running out of handling balance; hustle the car into a slower one on trailed brakes and you can feel the rear axle arc gently but usefully wide to neutralise your cornering line. You can be needle-and-thread precise with the car, feeling for every available bit of adhesive asphalt; or you can bully it around a track, unloading the rear axle for fun and giving the brakes a really hard time, without fear of overheating them. They’re good brakes, and this is a thoroughly engineered performance car.

Just as on the Golf GTI, the Polo’s stability control system isn’t fully switchable, but the ESP-Sport mode gives you enough freedom to make for a really involving and unintruded track drive. It also just about reins in the inevitable spinning consequence of 236lb ft at the front wheels when you’re too keen with the accelerator pedal, although it does so pretty untidily at times.

Should I buy one?

This is undoubtedly the best GTI-badged driver’s car yet to delivered by Volkswagen outside of the Golf range: a hot hatchback with more credibility than any Polo before it, and a proper GTI – with all that implies in 2017. It’s not a car without room for improvement, mind you – and, while it’s exactly the car that Karsten Schebsdat and his team intended, it might not be the hot supermini to best enliven your weekend driving, either.

For this tester’s money, cars at the affordable end of the hot hatchback spectrum are at their best when they’re a bit less grown-up than this. Driver thrills that are accessible, performance flavour that’s abundant and instant, and handling that’s compelling at real-world-relevant everyday speeds: these are the things that the greatest and most compelling examples do well. And I’m not sure that miniaturising the Golf GTI’s dynamic character, while that trick’s been successfully pulled off here for the very first time, has given us a car that can quite outstrip any of its rivals in those key areas.

I wouldn’t, in short, choose this over a Ford Fiesta ST or a well-specced Mini Cooper S. But then I wouldn’t imagine buying a car like this to be used every day, for every journey, as you would a larger car – or a Golf GTI. And if you would, you’d probably see the appeal.

It would have been quite a coup if Volkswagen had taken on the best in class at their own game and won here, but in fact they’ve brought something new to the fast supermini table that is classy, desirable, practical and rounded enough to wear the GTI badge very comfortably indeed. And it’s no dynamic half-measure, either.

Volkswagen Polo GTI DSG

Where Majorca, Spain On sale January 2018 Price £19,995 (est) Engine 4cyls, 1984cc, turbo, petrol Power 197bhp at 4400-6000rpm Torque 236lb ft at 1500-4400rpm Gearbox 6-spd dual-clutch automatic Kerb weight na Top speed 147mph 0-62mph 6.7sec Fuel economy na CO2, tax band na Rivals Ford Fiesta ST, Peugeot 208 GTI

Join the debate

Comments
31

6 December 2017
What an achingly dull looker.

The interior is also a rather soulless straight edged affair.

At least it's engineered to thoroughness I guess.

6 December 2017

i really can’t wait for someone to reveal what cheat device vw use for motoring journalists to continually spout this nonsense about quality interiors. The central air vents look like they have come from the original 70s golf never mind the later gti. The red plastic dash looks like something from the current mg range, I know tartan is gti tradition, but so were measles once upon a time. 

As for the 0-60 time I’m guessing that’s artificially limited so not to steal sales from the golf. If Vauxhall can get the new Astra in 0-60 quicker in a 1.6 which isn’t even a performance varient then vw should be embarrassed.

still, I think the outside is nicer than the fiesta. 

 

9 December 2017
ridnufc wrote:

i really can’t wait for someone to reveal what cheat device vw use for motoring journalists to continually spout this nonsense about quality interiors. The central air vents look like they have come from the original 70s golf never mind the later gti. The red plastic dash looks like something from the current mg range,

Glad to hear it's not just me!

My ex and I briefly considered a Golf or Polo GTI a few years back. The interior of the Polo was chintzy and felt insubstantial - shiny plastic and fake metal trim all over the shop. The Golf was better, but only barely.

6 December 2017

I think those who have fond memories of the first two generations of Golf GTi will like this. Its narrower width makes it more suitable for the city.

The simplicity and ergonomically sound interior of this Polo also recalls the well laid out interior of the Mk1 Golf (At last the satnav is placed above the air vents)

I am surprised neither the A class nor the 1 series exploits this size of car, the bloated A class is nolonger a small car. The Fiesta, its interior expecially, is too ugly to contemplate, however accomplished its driving dynamics.

6 December 2017

golf mk7; length 4258mm, width 1799mm, wheelbase 2620mm. polo mk6; length 4053mm, width 1946mm, wheelbase 2548mm. unless paerkers are lying, the polo is; 20.5cm (8") shorter, 7.2cm (2.8") shorter wheelbase, 14.7cm (5.8") wider. which brings me to my point: miniaturised? somehow, it's just under £6000 cheaper.

6 December 2017
russ13b wrote:

golf mk7; length 4258mm, width 1799mm, wheelbase 2620mm. polo mk6; length 4053mm, width 1946mm, wheelbase 2548mm. unless paerkers are lying, the polo is; 20.5cm (8") shorter, 7.2cm (2.8") shorter wheelbase, 14.7cm (5.8") wider. which brings me to my point: miniaturised? somehow, it's just under £6000 cheaper.

The Polo is not a miniature Golf, it is a Golf!  Bigger than a Mk1, 2, 3 and now closer to a Mk4 in size.  Thankfully not in handling.

The Up GTi is like the Mk1 Golf in terms of size.

What the hell is a Golf 7 then?  No idea, some kind of truncated Passat hatch?

The march of time means each generation gets attached to a bigger, usually fatter, wider but almost always (strangely) lower car than its predecessor.

6 December 2017

That width is wrong - the Polo measurements have been given with mirrors, and the Golf without. The Golf's width including mirrors is 2027mm

6 December 2017

Bit dull but a stonking 2.0 tfsi engine that after a couple of owners will be chipable to 250hp. Bear in mind a Fiesta 5dr Titanium 1.0 Auto costs nearly £18.5k (crazy) so if they can keep to around 20k it'll will do very well indeed   

 

Hydrogen cars just went POP

6 December 2017

I think Autocar's £20k estimate is way off, the 1.0 115 SEL DSG is already £19.5k.

There's still the R-Line trim to be announced and the 1.5 TSI 150 engine to fit in, too. This GTI will be pushing £23k and the GTI+ versions higher still.


6 December 2017

Looks like a big increase then, the old 1.8 GTI started at £19,500 (it's still available apparently)

 

Hydrogen cars just went POP

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Vauxhall Viva Rocks
    The Vauxhall Viva Rocks will sit at the top of the city car range
    First Drive
    15 December 2017
    Vauxhall's city car gets an urban SUV makeover in a bid to court younger buyers. Is that enough to turn it into a Suzuki Ignis beater?
  • Volkswagen T-Roc 2.0 TSI
    First Drive
    15 December 2017
    Do 187bhp and 4Motion all-wheel drive make the current top-spec T-Roc exciting to drive?
  • Nissan Micra 1.0
    First Drive
    15 December 2017
    Nissan plugs the gap in its Micra range with a naturally aspirated 1.0-litre petrol engine, but is it good enough to unseat the Ford Fiesta, Seat Ibiza and Volkswagen Polo equivalents?
  • Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio
    First Drive
    15 December 2017
    The super-saloon version of Alfa’s long-awaited M3 rival has already wowed our road testers, but what’s it like to live with?
  • Lexus LS 500h
    First Drive
    14 December 2017
    New flagship saloon from Lexus provides a luxury interior to rival the best but comes up short due to its hybrid powertrain