8
Trophy reworking makes the Clio RS quicker and plainly better, but the EDC concept is still hard to love

Our Verdict

Renault Clio Renaultsport

New Renaultsport hot hatch has sophistication, but can it excite?

Nic Cackett
17 July 2015

What is it?

It’s fair to say that, thus far, the current iteration of the Clio RS has been a disappointment. Previous to it, four generations (five if you include the Williams) of the Renaultsport-fettled supermini were imperious, successive class leaders, and most an object lesson in fast and cheap fun. Their replacement managed to be none of these things, saddled as it was with too many doors, too little power and a fun-dampener of an EDC dual-clutch automatic gearbox.

Its shortcomings, one suspects, were not lost on the engineers in Renault’s famed motorsport division, because many of them have been seen to in this, the 220 Trophy version. It’s still a five-door and still an automatic, but the '220' part of the name refers to a 10% power hike bestowed on the car’s now Euro 6-compliant 1.6-litre turbocharged petrol engine, the new 217bhp output distinguishing it from the 197bhp variant still below it in the range pecking order.

The extra power comes courtesy of a marginally larger blower and an engine remap. An increase in boost pressure delivers more peak torque, too - 192lb ft at 2000rpm. It's an improvement so crucial to the Clio’s drivability that it migrates to the cheaper 200 version as well. Exclusive to the Trophy, however, is a ‘substantially recalibrated’ EDC ’box, which now shifts 50% quicker than before, along with a bespoke chassis set-up.

This includes substantially firmer springs, the rear twist beam having been stiffened by 40%, with dampers to match. The steering ratio has been reduced, too, for better directness, and the standard 18in wheels teamed with Michelin Pilot Super Sport tyres, for better traction. There’s still no proper limited-slip differential (Renault’s RS Diff being an electronic emulator), but there is launch control and the potential for 47.9mpg economy if you go nowhere near the former.

What's it like?

To look at, lower. Previously, even in Cup format, Renault barely dropped the Clio at all. Here, the height reduction is a more substantial 20mm at the front and 10mm at the back, making the Trophy a much squatter prospect and even more fetching in a special matt white colour scheme that adds both a gloss black roof and £1300 to the bill. Extra badges inevitably feature, too, and inside there’s a leather-bound steering wheel to go with some carbonfibre-effect trim bits.

Everything else around you remains the same, including the dull, hollow clunk of a gear selector more suited to a worn-out SUV than a new supermini. Renault has reduced the travel of the associated column-mounted paddles by 30% but, unfortunately, there’s still no crispness or click to them, just a gummy ‘meh’ of wilting resistance.

This lack of fingertip fulfilment proves all the more frustrating because at the business end both up and downshifts do indeed possess far more zip, which, more happily, proves to be a merit of the Trophy in general. One of the turbocharged Clio’s most disappointing traits was its inability to feel even remotely brisk when left in plain old auto mode; thanks to the additional torque - and an extra 15lb ft that only the Trophy gets in fourth and fifth - the range-topper feels not only livelier but also easier to get along with.

That’s without trying. Thumb the RS button for its ‘race’ setting (holding it down extinguishes the traction control in manual mode) and the newfound liveliness approaches actual exuberance. The engine’s modestly larger muscle has been further enhanced by a seemingly greater lung capacity, with a revised air intake and exhaust system meaning the four-pot threshes its way to a higher 6800rpm rev limit with rasp and far greater gusto. It's a virtual metamorphosis in a unit that formerly toiled on its way to mediocrity.

The result is not rampantly quick in the mould of an Audi S1 or Mini Cooper JCW (both an additional leg up the ladder), but a Fiesta ST might just find itself going backwards now. Don’t expect a corner to slow it up much either: the Trophy lives up to its suspension’s billing, negating the 200’s weight transfer tendencies by barely dipping a wing at turn-in, and thereafter turning the engine’s faster, freer spin into a balanced and properly tacky mid-bend hunker - one made all the more palpable by a steering rack that feels as though some of the old responsiveness has been returned to it.

Should I buy one?

The hardly surprising downside of turning up the chassis’ wick is that Renault has taken a substantial bite out of the Clio’s ride comfort, which was previously one of its most likable assets. The uncompromising approach taken to vertical body movements is decidedly old school, so expect jowls to jiggle in town and bottoms to leave seats on bumpy B-roads. Clearly, this speaks to the Trophy’s circuit-focused tuning - a stated Renaultsport objective - and is of the type that a right-minded niche buyer probably wouldn’t blanche at.

Whether the Clio still appeals to that kind of audience now is questionable, though. Some of the old Dieppe pixie dust has been sprinkled but it settles only patchily on what is a resolutely expensive five-door, two-pedal product. Renault made the RS softer, slower and more sensible to lure the masses; restiffening the sinews doesn’t guarantee the gushing return of a hardcore minority, especially given that most are now rightly Ford customers, driving a replica of the cheap-to-buy, three-door, three-pedal, three-times-the-fun machines that Renault spent the best part of two decades championing.

Rather than chasing lap times, the manufacturer would have been better served in this case by simply splicing its improved powertrain to the existing Cup chassis and cleaving £2k from the £21,780 price tag. As it is, the Trophy is still by far the best EDC-equipped Clio we’ve driven, and a fine alternative to something like the 208 GTi 30th. But its real imperfections are marrow-deep, and - for once - a single-minded special-edition isn’t necessarily the solution. 

Clio Renaultsport 220 Trophy

Location Surrey; On sale Now; Price From £21,780; Engine 4 cyls, 1618cc, turbocharged, petrol; Power 217bhp at 6800rpm; Torque 192lb ft at 2000rpm; Kerb weight 1204kg; Gearbox 6-spd dual-clutch automatic; 0-62mph 6.6sec; Top speed 146mph; Economy 47.9mpg (combined); CO2/tax band 135g/km, 22%

Join the debate

Comments
3

17 July 2015
What this car really needs is a manual transmission to maximise driver involvement. Manual option should also be lighter, cheaper and offer lower emissions.

17 July 2015
Metallic blue ? Gold wheels.

www.KOOOLcr.com

 

20 July 2015
If you want a manual petrol Clio the most powerful engine is a crappy 90 hp. The Meganne's not much better on the petrol front

 

Hydrogen cars just went POP

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Seat Leon ST Cupra 2.0 TSI 4Drive 300PS DSG
    First Drive
    28 April 2017
    Seat's fastest Leon ST is fun to drive quickly and has enough space for all the family, but VW's own Golf R Estate is even better to drive
  • Porsche 911 GT3 manual 2017 review
    First Drive
    28 April 2017
    The new 911 GT3 is an excellent machine; does the addition of a manual gearbox make it even better?
  • Skoda Karoq
    First Drive
    28 April 2017
    The Yeti has morphed into the Karoq for its second generation, and this early drive reveals a solid, practical small SUV that could challenge the class best
  • Opel Ampera-e
    First Drive
    27 April 2017
    Opel's second-generation Ampera is smaller than the first, and now purely electric. It's also very capable with a remarkable range
  • Lotus Elise Sprint
    First Drive
    27 April 2017
    The latest incarnation of the Elise may be out of its depth on track, but on the public road it is probably the purest version since the original