As a brand statement, this A-Class was intended to herald a new dynamism for Mercedes-Benz.

In several significant ways, it does. Visually, it is a sharpened arrowhead of a car; inside, it speaks to the quality and class of the badge.

Matt Prior

Matt Prior

Road test editor
The A-Class is a divisive car. It appeals with its new looks and sporty demeanor, but its hard ride may limit its chances of success in the UK.

These attention-getting elements are intertwined with clever, cleaner engines, great proportions and dialled-in handling to jump-start the kind of enviable allure that has been absent from small Mercedes in the past. Yet while its imaginative predecessor ran contrary to the path plotted by cars such as the Audi A3, the latest A-Class flatters its rival by reproducing not only its strengths, but also its perceived weaknesses.

In attempting to harness the high-end athleticism that Ingolstadt has made its own, Mercedes has produced a model shorn of the fundamental comfort so essential to success in the UK.

Because of this, and despite invoking enough raw desirability to snare its audience, the A-Class can’t qualify for the class-leading status its makers would have been aiming for.

Top 5 Premium hatches

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • First Drive
    26 April 2017
    The compromises of adding a plug-in hybrid drivetrain to the 5 Series make the new 530e iPerformance tough to recommend
  • 2017 BMW 440i Coupé
    First Drive
    26 April 2017
    The assumption was that a few minor tweaks to the 2017 BMW 440i Coupé wouldn't make much of a difference. It turns out they do
  • Porsche 911 GT3
    First Drive
    26 April 2017
    Brilliant new Porsche GT 911 GT3 picks up where the previous GT3 RS and 911 R left off
  • Honda Clarity Fuell Cell
    First Drive
    26 April 2017
    You can't buy the Honda Clarity Fuel Cell, but the innovative hatchback does enough to show that hydrogen models deserve a more mainstream future
  • Nissan Micra
    Car review
    26 April 2017
    Has this much-needed reinvention turned it into a real contender once again?