From £30,3656
A UK drive of Audi's new potent saloon reveals plenty of talent from the engine and gearbox, but it's let down by numb steering

Our Verdict

Audi S3

Audi Sport has given the A3 range a light going over in the shape of the S3, which is a consummate performer, but not a spirited one

  • First Drive

    2016 Audi S3 review

    The Audi S3 is a quick and capable hot hatch, but has a much calmer everyday side than its rivals
  • First Drive

    2016 Audi S3 Saloon review

    Hot four-door version of Audi's new A3 gains a new look, more equipment and more power for 2016. Does that also equal more fun?

What is it?

Our first chance to try the saloon version of Audi’s rapid S3 hatch on UK roads. Which comes with 296bhp, quattro four-wheel drive and an impressive array of driver aids, provided you have deep pockets.

It’s powered by the VW Group’s latest EA888 2.0 TFSI long stroke engine, a completely redesigned direct-injection, balancer shaft power unit featuring raised injection pressures, variable valve timing, intelligent cooling and an integral exhaust manifold. It only weighs 5kg less than the previous engine, but has a potential power output of 414bhp (as flaunted in the Audi TT Quattro Sport Geneva concept), so it must be tough. And it puts out 35bhp more than the S3’s previous motor.

It can be hooked either to a six-speed manual, or a six-speed DSG S tronic paddle-shift automatic transmission that shortens the 0-62mph sprint time by 0.4sec to 4.9sec, and lifts the combined fuel consumption by 0.5mpg to 40.9mpg. Audi expects this transmission, with its slightly lower 159g/km emissions, to be the more popular.

Besides having a lighter engine the S3 saloon is less hefty than the previous generation S3 hatchback, an alloy front sub-frame, and a bonnet and front wings in aluminium allowing a base weight of 1430kg. Much of the suspension is alloy too, and features actively adjustable magneto-rheological dampers as standard. 

Intriguingly, this car is not exactly an S3 hatch with a boot, the saloon riding on a 35mm longer wheelbase and a fractionally broader track, making it wider than competitors like the BMW M235i, too.

Exterior identifiers include a 25mm lower ride height, a front diffuser, additional air intakes, sill extensions, 19in alloys, four exhaust outlets and boot-lip spoiler, but it’s the interior that has more potential to deliver you a visual blast. Order the 'Parade’ leather pack and the seats’ outer edges will be trimmed in a startlingly bright red leather that’s equally surprising for its softness.

What's it like?

Quick and easy, especially if you’ve boarded the S tronic and deployed its throttle with conviction.

It’s swift to move and stays that way as it blat-blasts through all six gears, sounding like a distant touring car racer even when the exhaust is quietened to its most subtle setting. The drama is in the gearshifts, which are a do-it-all-over-again pleasure to hear, and the unrelenting rate at which where you are heading becomes where you have been.

That said, there’s something curiously undramatic about the engine’s delivery, its Table Mountain torque curve providing a crescendo-free gathering of power that’s faintly disappointing. But it’s certainly effective. Delve deeper, and hold it second, say, to observe the engine’s pull from 1100rpm, and you’ll discover a turbo that needs a pause to spool up. But the broad ratio spread and narrow spacing of the six-speeder masks this deficiency well. In the six-speed manual, you’re more likely to trip over some lag.

All-wheel drive adds a reassuring layer of directional security and freedom from torque-steer, although this quattro set-up uses a Haldex clutch rather than a more sophisticated Torsen differential to parcel torque to the axles. So you don’t get the 60 per cent torque bias to the rear axle that longitudinally engined quattros provide.

Not that the car feels unbalanced, nosing into tight bends with authoritative aplomb, and feeling terrifically stable through fast sweepers. It’s a fluent mover, and the more so with the DSG transmission. For the most part that applies to its ride too, which in comfort or auto musters adequate, if firm, pliancy over most surfaces. Sport induces more vertical jigging, though.

But the S3’s dynamic weakness, as so often with Audis, is its steering, which feels remote from the proceedings regardless of the level of assistance you select. And the absence of this tactile interaction means that for the keen driver, this is a car less rewarding than you’d hope, especially as the Haldex system makes a mid-corner attitude hard to alter with a throttle prod.

Should I buy one?

Despite these flaws, the S3 is quite an alluring proposition. It looks handsome inside and out, its urge is as satisfying as it is effective and the accompanying soundtrack appropriately goading. And like all Audis, the S3 is a very finely finished tool.

Unfortunately for Ingolstadt, its BMW colleagues down the road have just produced a gem of a driver’s car called the M235i, and while it falls two doors short of the Audi’s four, it provides a distinctly superior dynamic experience with its driftable chassis and usefully more connected steering. It’s a direct competitor, and a better one.

Audi S3 Saloon 2.0 TFSI S tronic

Price £34,720; 0-62mph 4.9sec; Top speed 155mph; Economy 40.9mpg; Co2 159g/km; Kerbweight 1430kg (excl driver); Engine 4 cyls in line, 1984cc, turbocharged; Power 296bhp at 5500-6200rpm; Torque 280lb ft at 1800-5500rpm; Gearbox 6-spd DSG

Join the debate

Comments
6

13 March 2014
For me personally, no matter how good the car might be, I simply would never buy an Audi . Everyone I've ever known with an Audi either hasn't got a clue about cars or are the kinda blokes to wear a shiny suit to work...topped off with a brown pair of shoes and a non-matching black belt. Honestly would rather a Skoda and a decent watch than be seen driving anything with four rings. Same could be said about the R8, would look as if you're an extra at Amir Kahn's wedding.

13 March 2014
You would never buy an Audi? Good. Maybe you could also refrain from posting irrelevant drivel and leave the clueless among us to discuss cars. Happy in the knowledge that our 'brown shoes and black belt combo' is offending the GQ readers out there.

What nonsense...

19 March 2014
What's not relevant in my previous comment? Everything I stated was fact. What exactly is there to even say about the Audi A3/S3- it's just another generic Audi that will soon litter the streets of every working-class suburb in Britain, also I don't understand what all the fuss is about with Audi interiors either- seems like the only credible reason why anyone should purchase one. Audi's are essentially Volkswagens with mediocre diesel engines coupled with a front wheel drive layout, they are bought by pretentious prats who haven't a clue about cars, but simply like the daylight running LEDS in your face and the idea that 4 rings on your bonnet means you're a success.
Surely anyone in the market for a small saloon with a posh badge and limited driving capacity would go for a Mercedes CLA- at least that's a good looking car with some degree of class. I often feel as if I have been given superpowers- I can actually see Audi for what they are, behind the slick advertising campaigns they are nothing more than tarted up VW's typically with 2.0 tdi engines combined with a FF layout... front wheel drive- just like a Vauxhall Corsa.

13 March 2014
Isn't this the size the old A4 used to be? I saw an new 63 reg A4 recently. It was the size of an old A6. At this rate, in 10 years time, the A3 saloon will be A6 sized. As roads / parking spaces / garages are limited in size, we will eventually get to the stage when the A3 / A4 / A6 / A8 are pretty much the maximum size allowed by the road network, all within a whisker of each other. What will they do then? Introduce an A0.5, A0.25, A0.1 to fill the gaps? Why not just keep the current models at the same size but improve the tech. So stupid.

13 March 2014
I would never buy an Audi as I would not pay £00s or even £000s more for a Volkswagen/Skoda/SEAT than I need to. Having said that there is something to be said for a well made four-wheel drive rapid and sporty small 4 door saloon. Unfortunately as the report makes clear Audi cannot tune the steering sufficiently well for the drive to be involving. This is very likley because Audi do not start with a clean sheet design but have to put up with whatever VW chassis their engineers are given by the VAG board. The Audi engineers are then mostly likely hampered still further by VAG's confused "brand Strategy" where Skoda = value; SEAT = sporty; VW = quality and Audi = whatever they are currently rivals against (BMW for some cars (A5/S5 etc or Mercedes (A&/A8). BMW do not make cars for anyone else so can design the chassis they want and tune it how they like. If VAG could crack the steering feel/handling/ride of certain Audi models and do away with front wheel drive where they can use four wheel drive or even rear wheel drive I would be very tempted by a fast discrete small saloon that can be parked (relatively easily). Stereotyping drivers of different brands of cars is not helpful.

14 March 2014
Stereotyping isn't helpful, but it's funny and there's quite a bit of truth there. I don't see why anyone would buy an Audi either (other than the Quattro system), although the 4matic and xDrive BMW/Mercedes counterparts are now becoming more relevant. I just can't tell which Audi is which anymore, they really do all look the same (with the exception of the A1/S1, which is my personal favourite Audi).

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Lexus LC500
    Car review
    20 October 2017
    Futuristic Lexus LC coupé mixes the latest technology with an old-school atmospheric V8
  • Maserati Levante S GranSport
    First Drive
    20 October 2017
    Get ready to trade in your diesels: Maserati’s luxury SUV finally gets the engine it’s always needed
  • Jaguar XF Sportbrake TDV6
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    The handsome Jaguar XF Sportbrake exhibits all the hallmarks that makes the saloon great, and with the silky smooth diesel V6 makes it a compelling choice
  • Volkswagen T-Roc TDI
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    Volkswagen's new compact crossover has the looks, the engineering and the build quality to be a resounding success, but not with this diesel engine
  • BMW M550i
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    The all-paw M550i is a fast, effortless mile-muncher, but there's a reason why it won't be sold in the UK