Time is up with Peugeot’s rival to the Ford Focus ST and VW Golf GTI. So how has life been with our fast French hatch?

The Peugeot 308 GTi 270’s life with us was a tumultuous one through no fault of its own.

Our first longtermer was written off in a serious accident, which at least proved something you’d never hope to prove: that the crumple zone was incredibly effective at protecting its occupants.

Then as soon as a replacement arrived, someone smashed the front passenger window glass. The reason for the break-in remains a mystery; the only thing visible in the car was a yoga mat – which wasn’t taken.

And so, as our seven-month stint with the car comes to an end, I’m sad to say goodbye to it. It has become a trusty companion: practical and unassuming but with all the poke you need to live everyday life in the fast lane.

As always at Autocar, and particularly so with a hot hatch, plenty of people wanted a go in the Peugeot, and that resulted in a number of differing opinions.

One thing everyone agreed on was how excellent the 266bhp version of Peugeot’s turbocharged 1.6-litre engine is. While many rivals use 2.0-litre engines, the upshot of Peugeot’s downsizing is that the 308 GTi has better fuel economy and lower emissions. The official combined figure is 47.1mpg; our time with the car gave us an average of 34.2mpg, a drop of almost 30%. Economy aside (quite frankly, it’s never the key reason for buying a hot hatch), the GTi’s engine didn’t want for performance, feeling nippier than you’d expect. By way of comparison, its nearest equivalents, the Volkswagen Golf GTI Clubsport 40 produces 261bhp and the Ford Focus ST makes do with 247bhp.

It’s the same engine that’s used in the now-defunct RCZ R coupé, but retuned to provide a broader torque curve. The benefits are clear, the GTi 270 delivering ample power throughout the rev range with consistency and enthusiasm.

Creating more debate among Autocar staff was the steering, and specifically the reduced-diameter steering wheel. Described by Peugeot as “compact” and providing “natural grip and flawless precision”, it’s a divisive feature, to say the least. I quickly adapted to the wheel’s size, having driven a number of Peugeots since the feature’s introduction, and hardly noticed the difference over a typical wheel, but there were some strong aversions to it in the office. “I just can’t get on with that stupid wheel,” said one colleague.

The steering itself is also a little hit and miss and the most obvious area where Peugeot could improve the GTi’s offering. There’s little feedback, and while the weighting is good for medium-speed driving, it becomes over-assisted at motorway speeds.

Living in the London suburbs means the 308’s ride was regularly tested over many an unforgiving speed bump, but it fared well. Despite the 19in alloy wheels and Michelin Pilot Super Sport tyres, the 308 GTi proved largely stable and supple. As an aside, those alloys and high London kerbs don’t mix.

Out on the open road or on track (as we did on one occasion at Anglesey), the GTi’s handling wasn’t quite as rapier-like in its responses as that of a Focus ST or a Renault Mégane RS, but it had a grown-up feel that made it an easy, fast companion.

That maturity continued inside, with a minimalist, calming interior. I was rarely restless on long journeys thanks to comfortable seats, and I like the staid black finish. But the absence of buttons on the dashboard means you have to deal with the glitchy infotainment system, which has a small but highly irritating delay in reacting to inputs on its 9.7in touchscreen. Moving around the system isn’t as intuitive as it is in, say, a Volkswagen Group equivalent. Still, the second-gen system, which has arrived in the new 3008, has been praised for addressing these issues.

My other grumble is the driving position. However I adjusted it, I just couldn’t get on with it. To have my seat and steering wheel in a comfortable position, I had to crane my neck to see the instrument panel. And it wasn’t just me; the only person in the office who seemed unfazed by it was our editorial director Jim Holder, who really is very tall.

At least the cabin had ample space. Two 6ft-tall friends could sit one behind the other without getting cramp, although they did note a shortage of head room in the back. Front and rear access was good, too, particularly for putting in and taking out a child seat and the associated niece. The cavernous boot proved as practical as it gets in this class, too, beating both the Golf and Focus for size by some margin, with a 470-litre capacity versus 380 and 316 litres for the Golf and Focus respectively.

Other quirks and quibbles? I liked the massage seat functions. I liked the Sport button, a nice addition that tweaks throttle mapping and adds a synthesised exhaust note. I didn’t like that plastic was coming off the floor mats within the first six months.

So would I choose one again? No. It doesn’t quite cut it for me as the hot hatch of choice. But I did enjoy every minute with this well-rounded car. What it lacks in grin-inducing zest, it makes up for with speedy, practical and understated motoring.

OPTIONS

Peugeot Connect SOS Assistance £240

FUEL CONSUMPTION AND RANGE

Claimed economy 47.1mpg (combined) Fuel tank 53 litres Test average 34.2mpg Test best 28.2mpg Test worst 37.6mpg Real-world range 399 miles

TECH HIGHLIGHTS

0-62mph 6.0sec Top speed 155mph Engine 4 cyls, 1598cc, turbocharged, petrol Max power 266bhp at 6000rpm Max torque 243lb ft at 1900rpm Transmission 6-spd manual Boot 470-1309 litres Wheels 8Jx19in Tyres 235/35 R19, Michelin Pilot Super Sport Kerb weight 1205kg

SERVICE AND RUNNING COSTS

Contract hire rate £362.52 per month CO2 139g/km Service costs None Other costs None Fuel costs £1750 Running costs inc fuel £1750 Cost per mile 30 pence Depreciation £11,910 Cost per mile inc dep’n £2.33 Faults None

Our Verdict

Peugeot 308 GTi 270

Peugeot Sport hot hatchback turns up the pressure on the Volkswagen Golf GTI

Join the debate

Comments
12

4 June 2017
One man's 308 is another man's Golf,Ford I guess......?

Peter Cavellini.

4 June 2017
Poor steering and bad ergonomics! Ouch!
Steam cars are due a revival.

4 June 2017
Until they go back to simple to use at a glance climate control dials, I won't be tempted by this 'minimalist' interior. Why go against the principles of good ergonomics and compromise safety?

4 June 2017
Being the owner of a little red 308 for the past two years I really should stop reading reviews by others who spend five minutes driving the car ( even if the car is in their fleet for a few months) then whinge because its slightly different to a Golf. Heaven forbid.

Honestly folks. Test drive the car yourself because i cannot fathom these complaints about ergonomics. Set the wheel as recommended by Peugeot and see how it works. I found it, the steering in general, the infotainment controls and the air conditioning adjustment (its climate control folks, its self adjusting, even in steamy Australia) all just work.

Went for a drive on mountain roads last weekend ( just for fun) and the little wheel feels great. 300km of highway driving the previous Saturday- could not fault it, arrived fresh and relaxed, great long distance car.

In fact the " little" wheel in the 308 does not feel like a little wheel, it feels like the right size. When i drive company cars their steering wheels feel ridiculously large by comparison.

Could the sat nav be a bit more intuitive? Probably, Might the rear legroom not suit some folks? fair enough. Do i agree with a single quibble in this review? Nope. Could not agree less and i have had alot more time behind the wheel to find any faults.

As for your photo of the obscured instruments, why do you have the steering set so high, its like you are trying to make it not work. Its probably why you thought the steering was over assisted. Set the CENTER of the wheel at the same height as you would for any other car. Your arms will then be in a relaxed position. The car is actually very relaxed and stable on the motorway. Maybe yours had something wrong with it.

4 June 2017
"As for your photo of the obscured instruments, why do you have the steering set so high, its like you are trying to make it not work."
Well exactly..that's just plain thick to set the wheel like in that photo, fake news. Sometimes people's resistance to change is strong enough to not appreciate innovation.

5 June 2017
7 months and £11.910 depreciation. Ouch.
Spanner

5 June 2017
£11,910, not £11.910!!

Point remains, that is £1700 a month!!!!!

Spanner

5 June 2017
That does not add up. What one of the following is true?

1. a £9000 lump sum paid on his car at the beginning of the term,
2. the finance company got severely stung
3. The depreciation was not £11,910

£362 PCM + £11,910 depreciation does not add up. 7 months would make this the bargain of the century to buy if it were possible.

Am I missing something?

Spanner

5 June 2017
That's very encouraging from a Peugeot. I bet my parents, who have just handed back their fourth courtesy car in exchange for their still-faulty Golf (duff stop/'start') would be jealous. Nice car the 308. They always catch my eye on the road.

5 June 2017
androo wrote:

That's very encouraging from a Peugeot. I bet my parents, who have just handed back their fourth courtesy car in exchange for their still-faulty Golf (duff stop/'start') would be jealous. Nice car the 308. They always catch my eye on the road.

My golf is 7 months old, and it has steadfastly refused to go wrong. Should I take it back to the dealer, as it must be a "bad 'un/ Friday job", where they put it together properly? Or do you think there is still time for me?

I have probably angered the gods of motoring now and will spend tomorrow in the piddling rain at the side of the motorway cursing my arrogance :) if I do, I'll let you know!

Spanner

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Lexus LC500
    Car review
    20 October 2017
    Futuristic Lexus LC coupé mixes the latest technology with an old-school atmospheric V8
  • Maserati Levante S GranSport
    First Drive
    20 October 2017
    Get ready to trade in your diesels: Maserati’s luxury SUV finally gets the engine it’s always needed
  • Jaguar XF Sportbrake TDV6
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    The handsome Jaguar XF Sportbrake exhibits all the hallmarks that makes the saloon great, and with the silky smooth diesel V6 makes it a compelling choice
  • Volkswagen T-Roc TDI
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    Volkswagen's new compact crossover has the looks, the engineering and the build quality to be a resounding success, but not with this diesel engine
  • BMW M550i
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    The all-paw M550i is a fast, effortless mile-muncher, but there's a reason why it won't be sold in the UK