Currently reading: Matt Prior's tester's notes - long live the manual transmission
BMW's upcoming M2 will come with a manual transmission - and in an age of auto-only sports cars, that can only be a good thing

Praise be. The manual gearbox isn’t dead. Okay, I don’t really imagine it was ever quite going to be. Car makers can only spend a certain amount of money on the cheapest cars and still return a profit, which means three-pedal models are going nowhere.

But for a time there, on some of the exciting stuff, it was touch and go. We don’t even think about mentioning manual gearboxes when it comes to Mercedes-AMGs, Ferraris or McLarens these days. I take it as read that you know there’s no stick-shift option coming. It looked like you might have to actively search out an Ariel or Caterham to find a thrilling car with a manual transmission.

There are decent reasons for the move towards autos. Modern two-pedal set-ups are quicker to shift, cleaner and more tuneable than manuals. Add an electric hybrid set-up and the fact that gearbox software can talk to the rest of the powertrain, andit can torque-fill and coast or do whatever the hell you want it to do. You can’t do that with a manual.

And I’ll accept that if a commuter car, or a luxury car with increasing levels of autonomy, has to make shifts for me, then such is life.

But the PDK-only Porsche 911 GT3 was the worrying one. Here’s a car whose emissions mattered not a jot and whose driving pleasure was its all.

On a GT3, there are no electric motors or even turbos to get in the way – although I once read that the GT3’s dynamic engine mounts require a hydraulic pump and that, at the time, only a PDK gearbox could provide it. But the GT3 seemed like the start of something significant, of car makers deciding they knew best and giving you what they thought you should have, rather than what you want.

But we’ve done it. Or rather, you’ve done it. By being noisy enough about it, the Porsche Cayman GT4 arrived exclusively with a manual gearbox. And now word reaches us – although BMW hasn’t even announced the model, let alone the transmission – that the BMW M2 will have a manual gearbox.

Better than that, in a market dominated by models such as the Mercedes-AMG A45 and Audi RS3, the M2 could just be another car in the GT4’s vein: an old-school scorcher that hits you right in the feels.

I like the A45, and I suspect the RS3 will be good, but I like the sound of an M2 even more. If word reaches us correctly, it has the ‘right’ amount of power, at 375bhp, and only the correct wheels are driven.

Yes, it’ll be turbocharged, but you can’t have everything. And besides, there have been plenty of exciting turbocharged cars over the years. Porsche calls the Cayman GT4 “old-school, not old-fashioned”. 

I hope it’s not the only car of that ilk that’ll arrive this year.

Back to top

Join the debate

Add a comment…
bezor Ta 24 May 2015

It's us consumers choosing the auto

When the vast majority (over 90%) choose to buy their M5 M6 with twin clutch, it's natural BMW put their money on developing that gearbox and stops selling manual. It was what forced Ferrari and many other manufacturers to give up manual gear boxes. If 95% choose auto or twin clutch it simply doesn't make any sense to keep developing manuals. And that is what happening with big high performance sedans, coupes and high performance sports cars. When it comes to smaller and cheaper performance cars such as Cayman GT4 and M2 it makes sense to have manual to those cars.
david RS 3 April 2015

Just another step. Suppress

Just another step. Suppress the turbo, and it will be good !
artill 2 April 2015

Nice to see some support for

Nice to see some support for the good old fashioned manual gearbox in autocar. For many of us the theoretical superior performance or economy is irrelevant. And as the choice of car with a manual gets smaller, those left offering the option will pick up all the sales. I am not alone i suspect in saying it is a deal breaker....So well done Jaguar for letting us choose a manual F Type (perhaps that option will be made available in the more powerful saloons as well?). Well done Ford for bringing us a manual Mustang. Shame on BMW for making the M5 and M6 with manual boxes and not selling them here. Same too for Audi and the S4 and S5.