Left rear passenger belt came undone during Finnish magazine's high-speed lane-change tests of the Arona, Ibiza and Polo

A seatbelt issue that can leave a rear passenger unbuckled during a high-speed manoeuvre has been identified in the Seat AronaSeat Ibiza and Volkswagen Polo, and VW has now advised that owners of the affected cars do not use the middle rear seat until a recall is issued. 

Finnish automotive magazine Tekniikan Maailma found that the left rear buckle in the three models, which are based on the VW Group's MQB underpinnings, was released when the cars were carrying five people.

A VW spokesman has confirmed to Autocar that it is aware of the issue and said the brand "will provide a technical solution shortly and recall the vehicles concerned".

The problem appears to relate to the location of the middle buckle, which is mounted slightly higher than the one to its left. During a high-speed lane change to the right, the weight of the middle passenger pushes that buckle onto the left buckle at an angle that presses the left buckle's release button (see illustration below).

Tekniikan Maailma said this happened on numerous occasions in each identified model. It tested two Aronas in order to confirm that the issue wasn’t isolated to those particular test cars and said the problem wasn't found in previous tests because they were not conducted with five passengers aboard.

“According to our judgement, the unlatching is caused by a design fault,” Tekniikan Maailma said in a statement. “The easiest fix for the problem would be either to shorten or lengthen the attaching belt of the middle buckle by a couple of centimetres.”

Volkswagen's spokesman told Autocar that the recall will be "carried out in co-operation with the national vehicle registration authorities, who also approve the safety recall measures".

He continued: "As an immediate action, we will inform customers and advise not to have passengers use the middle rear seat of current Polo models (Mk6) until the cars have been equipped with the redesigned belt lock fixture."

Seat has also confirmed that it has found the same issue during new tests of the Arona and Ibiza. A spokesman for the brand said: “We're working on possible solutions for it and will inform you about the final decision as soon as possible.”

More content:

New ultra-capacitor tech could drastically boost battery EV range

Ford Fiesta ST 2018 review

Our Verdict

Seat Arona

Seat is on a roll but can the Arona, its new junior SUV, cut it in such an ultra-competitive class?

Join the debate

Comments
14

9 May 2018

Didn't pay off, did it?

 

 

9 May 2018

Nothing to do with cost cutting, the new Ibiza was designed several years ago. Just bad design and lack of foresight. 

typos1 - Just can’t respect opinion

10 May 2018
But, but, but, the engineering must be excellent because Autocar said the cabin is so premium with lots of premiumy soft plastic and premiumy plastic painted premiumy silver!

10 May 2018
jason_recliner wrote:

But, but, but, the engineering must be excellent because Autocar said the cabin is so premium with lots of premiumy soft plastic and premiumy plastic painted premiumy silver!

Ah that’s the thing though.... The T-Roc, Ibiza, Arona and Polo don’t actually have that premium feel in the cabin no more, all full of hard scratchy plastics! So the magazines only touch on that slightly to avoid upset...

9 May 2018

So as long as the car isnt out of control, spinning or turning sharply just before an accident you will be fine - Oh!!

9 May 2018

I would have thought any car with the release latch on top would be prone to this, a kid putting a hand down their side to brace themselves might push it accidently. Will check my japanese car when I get home, maybe a fix might be moving the switch to the side, cheap enough fix.

typos1 - Just can’t respect opinion

9 May 2018

Another week another issue with a VAG product... thought they were meant to be a quality reliable brand? Seems to be quite a few issues recently..

289

9 May 2018

...believe me, I see the global lists of recalls every month...there are literally dozens of these across all brands. For some reason only the VW Group items make the news!....secret agenda in the Press maybe....?

No brand is imune from this.

9 May 2018
289 wrote:

...believe me, I see the global lists of recalls every month...there are literally dozens of these across all brands. For some reason only the VW Group items make the news!....secret agenda in the Press maybe....?

No brand is imune from this.

What no brand is immune to unlatching its own seatbelts?  Would you like to name the  others? I realise many manufacturers issue recalls, and many are safety related, but I cant remeber a manufacturer ever advising owners not to carry the legally allowed amount of passengers because of safety issues, and the fact is they havent issued a recall, they apparently stated they knew about the issue, but it took a test from a magazine to bring it out into the open.

As for only VW items making the news, is there really any wonder given the sorry state the company is in and the disregard it has for its customers.  They have virtually killed off the diesel engine with their fuckwittery.  

289

10 May 2018

quote "they practically killed off the diesel engine with their fuckwittery!

And I will always be grateful to them for that....filthy stinking tractor engines. They should never have been in anything other than commercial/agricultural vehicles in the first place.

Good riddance.

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Land Rover Discovery
    First Drive
    23 May 2018
    Does the Land Rover Discovery – a vehicle designed to put in the hard yards – cut it as an executive company car? We ran it for seven months to find out
  • Aston Martin Vantage 2018 review hero front
    Car review
    23 May 2018
    Aston Martin’s cheapest model takes a big step up into the 21st century
  • Hyundai i30 N
    Standard spec is good so paint colour is our car’s only option
    First Drive
    22 May 2018
    What’s Hyundai’s first hot hatch and N-brand debutant really like? Let’s find out
  • DS 7 Crossback PureTech 225 2018 review hero front
    First Drive
    22 May 2018
    New petrol engine and top-end Ultra Prestige spec help broaden the Crossback's appeal, but do little to help it stand out in a crowded market
  • Audi TT RS Coupé
    First Drive
    22 May 2018
    The Audi TT RS has the looks, a vociferous engine and the supercar-baiting performance, but is it too uncompromising to use as a daily driver?