To be honest, its performance is still nothing startling – rival coupes such as the Audi TTS and BMW 135i Coupe are quicker off the line and more flexible in their power delivery – but the Cayman makes the most of what it’s got, and the result is a very satisfying package.
A lot of that is down to its sweet handling and tactile steering, which are on a different level from its German rivals and more than make up for any deficit in performance (though you wouldn’t ever call it slow, with a 0-62mph time of 5.8sec).
On standard suspension the Cayman’s ride can be quite jiggly at low speeds (despite the fact that our test car was riding on standard 17in wheels). But it comes right at higher speeds, where the Cayman displays astonishing poise and suppleness, seemingly irrespective of the road surface below. Extending the engine and probing the limits of the Cayman’s idiotproof chassis add up to an unusually cohesive and rewarding experience, especially considering how usable the Cayman is day to day.
The new six-speed manual gearbox is very welcome too. As well as removing the nagging ‘poor relation’ feeling that you got with the old five-speed Cayman, the new ’box brings a more ideal set of gear ratios (for both cross-country and motorway cruising use) and a typically lovely gearshift action. The optional PDK ’box is a far better alternative to the old Tiptronic auto if you must have a two-pedal layout (and helps the 0-62 time and CO2 output), but it’s hard to imagine it being more satisfying than the regular manual version.
The only real disappointment is the way the Cayman sounds. There’s a bit of induction howl under hard acceleration that dies away all too quickly as you ease off, but for the majority of the time the engine is just too quiet, whining away behind the cabin. A shouty sports exhaust would seem to be the answer – and it might also distract your attention from the amount of road noise the car generates. There’s a surprising number of rumbles and thumps, especially on the motorway, which could detract from the Cayman’s cruising ability.
Should I buy one?
Although the 2.9 Cayman won’t blow your socks off with its performance, it is now well enough endowed to make you question whether there’s any need to spend an extra £8k on a Cayman S. And unlike the previous 2.7 with its five-speed ’box, there’s nothing obvious to suggest that it’s a lesser model than the S, so you’re unlikely to ever feel short-changed if you can’t stretch to the 3.4-litre model.
In the end the S is probably a slightly more complete car, but it’s hard to imagine anyone being disappointed with such a rewarding driver’s car as the 2.9 Cayman.