From £42,8979
It has less power than the Cayman S, but this standard 718 is very nearly as good

Our Verdict

Porsche 718 Cayman

Can the best sports coupé of the decade absorb a contentious new engine?

15 July 2016

What is it?

Porsche’s new entry-level sports car. With the 718 Cayman now priced and positioned beneath its Boxster sister, the standard Cayman is the cheapest way into a new Porsche. Indeed, it’s currently the only Porsche with an un-optioned price of less than £40,000, although you'll tip over that by ticking a single option box. This pricing makes the 718 Cayman dangerously attractive when you consider the performance on offer.

As in the 718 Boxster, power comes from the smaller 2.0-litre version of Porsche’s new turbocharged flat-four engine. This 718 Cayman doesn’t have the Cayman S’s variable geometry turbocharger, yet it actually runs bigger boost pressures – a peak of 19psi compared with 16psi in the Cayman S.

The 718 Cayman gets 296bhp, which is 20bhp more than the old 2.7-litre engined Cayman. The biggest difference is torque, though: the 718 Cayman's turbocharged engine delivers a peak 280lb ft all the way from 1950rpm to 4500rpm.

The basic Cayman is far quicker than the car it replaces. Porsche claims a 0-62mph time of 5.1sec for the manual Cayman and a 4.7sec time for the twin-clutch PDK version, which has launch control as part of the optional Sport Chrono pack.

Video review

What's it like?

In short, a very good reason to consider whether you really need to splash the extra cash on a Cayman S. While the old 2.7-litre Cayman always felt like a significant downgrade compared with the brawnier 3.4-litre Cayman S, this new entry-level car is impressively close to its more expensive sister in terms of real world pace.

Sure, the lesser Cayman doesn’t pull quite as hard when you’re really trying, and back-to-back comparison of the two models showed that the smaller engine suffers from slightly more turbo lag if asked to deal with a large throttle opening below 2500rpm. Yet, like the 2.5-litre, this is a motor that can be driven on its bristling mid-range, and while it can’t match its predecessor’s enthusiasm for being revved hard, it pulls hard at engine speeds where the old Cayman would still be rolling out of bed.

Sadly, the turbo motor can’t deliver anything like the spine-tingling soundtrack that the old flat-six managed as it closed in on its red line. Our test car was fitted with the optional sports exhaust, which adds volume with revs but doesn’t change its gruff pitch. The Cayman’s fixed roof means it’s not possible to escape from the noise, and at cruising speeds it becomes droney, even with the exhaust switched to its quieter mode. While Porsche’s engineers have succeeded in making sure the Cayman never sounds like a Subaru - the only other modern car with a flat-four - at idle the 718 Cayman's new engine does make the tick-tick noise that anyone of a certain age will immediately associate with an air-cooled Volkswagen Beetle.

Chassis settings are slightly softer than in the Cayman S, and the standard Cayman can’t be specified with the upgraded and 20mm lower sports suspension. Despite this, it feels almost equally grippy and responsive when being driven at real world pace. The entry-level 718 Cayman has 18in wheels as standard, but can be upgraded to have the Cayman S's 19in or 20in wheels. Grip levels have been increased noticeably over the outgoing Cayman, as is necessary to prevent the increased torque output from too heavily changing the car's driving experience.

The Cayman still feels like the best balanced junior sports car on the market, but there’s no doubt that there are now bigger forces sitting on both sides of the scales. Some of the subtlety of the old car has gone; there’s less nuance to the steering feel for example, but the new Cayman is much quicker on cross-country pace and can carry huge speed into and through corners.

For most potential buyers, the more significant choice than that between Cayman and Cayman S will be whether to stick with the six-speed manual gearbox or choose the seven-speed PDK automatic. On previous evidence, the majority will opt for the latter, but it’s possible to make an excellent case for sticking with a gearchange, not least because PDK seems rather too keen to kick down when left in Drive mode. The manual gearbox is a peach to use and the engine has more than enough mid-range to pull its long gearing.

Should I buy one?

This standard 718 Cayman feels like a more significant upgrade over its predecessor than the new 718 Cayman S does, especially considering it’s only £200 more expensive than before. We should definitely mourn the passing of the six-cylinder engine, but the new turbo engine beats it on every metric apart from the subjective quality of 'soul'.

Still, many buyers will be unable to resist the appeal of the 718 Cayman S’s bigger and brawnier engine. Choosing that more powerful car also gets you fractionally bigger brakes, leather dash and seat trim, larger standard wheels and a bigger fuel tank.

Forego those and opt for this entry-level Cayman and you’ll save a useful £9000 – enough for a moderate options spree – while still enjoying a car that’s very nearly as fast on the road, and one that certainly doesn’t feel like a poor relation.

Porsche 718 Cayman

LocationMalmö, Sweden; On sale: now; Price: £39,878; Engine: 4cyl, 1988cc, turbocharged, petrol; Power: 297hp at 6500rpm; Torque: 280lb ft at 1950–4500rpm; Gearbox: Six speed manual or seven-speed twin-clutch; Kerb weight: 1335 kg; 0-62mph: 5.1sec (manual); Top speed: 171mph; Economy: 38.2mpg (combined); CO2/BIK tax band: 168g/km/30%

Join the debate

Comments
15

15 July 2016
... in the sports car department. At less than £40,000 it's not a huge amount more than the most expensive Seat Leon, or a Golf R. Best of all it makes the 911 look like a piece of over priced, over sized relic! 458,R10 are huge dinosaurs in comparison, too powerful, big and designed for people with ego problems.

 

Hydrogen cars just went POP

15 July 2016
Does anyone know what these are like for reliability, as a friend of mine has one in an Audi A3 auto and had loads of problems requiring a new auto box.keep reading and appears the zf boxes used by BMW and JLR are more reliable,wouls manuals be a better bet if options for auto are these pdk and dsg auto double clutch systems,I hear that the clutches wear quickly.

15 July 2016
Asking a question like that in these forums, @Ski Kid is like lighting the blue touch paper! But I will get in first with a positive. My experience of VW DSG has been excellent, and that is over 4 different cars in family since 2007. I have had both the "dry" clutch 7-speed and the "wet" clutch 6-speed. My preference is for the 6-speeder, but be warned, the wet clutch will mean poorer fuel economy (could be around 10% worse), whereas the dry clutch is likely to be a bit more economical than a manual. No idea about pdk.

15 July 2016
Ski Kid wrote:

Does anyone know what these are like for reliability, as a friend of mine has one in an Audi A3 auto and had loads of problems requiring a new auto box.keep reading and appears the zf boxes used by BMW and JLR are more reliable,wouls manuals be a better bet if options for auto are these pdk and dsg auto double clutch systems,I hear that the clutches wear quickly.

Yeah it put me off buying a dsg Golf. The 7 speed dry clutch DSG's have reams and reams of info on the web regarding failures of various sorts. Not a peep about the wet clutch 6 speed though. I presume they are more reliable.

15 July 2016
How long did you keep those cars?

15 July 2016
winniethewoo wrote:

How long did you keep those cars?

One was over 7 years/45k, another over 5 years/65k (the 7-speed box). Other two are recent, oldest at 2 years/30k. All have had just schedule service. My only criticism of the 7-speed was change up points were a touch early for my taste, but it was great for economy - 820 miles on one tank for that Golf on one occasion. Reality is, I would be reluctant to go back to manual for an everyday car, but then DSG reliability has been fine for me.

15 July 2016
thank you for the info my wife has a 1.6diesel golf cab and it is pathetic on fuel 42mpg up to 44mpg in the summer only done 24k and well looked after if we thrashed it I am sure it would be even worse ,people tell me the 2 litre is way better ,bit disillusioned with vw /Audi at the mo seen the car mag saying 24.5 mpg with the q7 official 47.9mpg makes you think they are being mighty untruthful to say THE LEAST .I am thinking about a petrol auto to replace it.

16 July 2016
That is good to hear. My Golf is an early Mk6 and getting long in the tooth. I wanted to replace it with a 1.0 triple with DSG (perfect for my pathetic average speed of 9mph around town) but am scared enough about DSG reliability to wait for the new Honda Civic in 2017. If that car turns out to be pants then I'll be going down the VWAG route again reluctantly.

16 July 2016
Like it, @winniethewoo, low average speed 9mph and we are on a Porsche article! Anyway, in those circumstances CVT would be ideal in my view. I like CVT for town use, and if that was all I did would probably seek one out again.

16 July 2016
I bet your bottom dollar all the Porsches I see in London have a similar average speed!

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Lexus LC500
    Car review
    20 October 2017
    Futuristic Lexus LC coupé mixes the latest technology with an old-school atmospheric V8
  • Maserati Levante S GranSport
    First Drive
    20 October 2017
    Get ready to trade in your diesels: Maserati’s luxury SUV finally gets the engine it’s always needed
  • Jaguar XF Sportbrake TDV6
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    The handsome Jaguar XF Sportbrake exhibits all the hallmarks that makes the saloon great, and with the silky smooth diesel V6 makes it a compelling choice
  • Volkswagen T-Roc TDI
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    Volkswagen's new compact crossover has the looks, the engineering and the build quality to be a resounding success, but not with this diesel engine
  • BMW M550i
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    The all-paw M550i is a fast, effortless mile-muncher, but there's a reason why it won't be sold in the UK