The only thing better than a new Golf GTI or R is a nearly new one
28 March 2019

If the seventh-generation Volkswagen Golf GTI isn’t the best everyday hot hatch in recent memory, it can only be because the faster, fitter, four-wheel-drive Golf R is even better still.

For track days and B-road thrills, you’ll want a Honda Civic Type R, but no other hot hatch gets close to the union of performance, athleticism, comfort and refinement that characterises both the GTI and the R. As they near their sixth and fifth birthdays respectively, VW dealers are overflowing with approved used stock at half the price of a new one. 

The GTI emerged in early 2013, only a handful of months after the sixth-generation Golf was superseded by the much-improved and substantially lighter Mk7. With 217bhp from a turbocharged four-pot, the GTI was brisk without being rampantly accelerative. For those buyers who wanted quicker acceleration and had more than £25,845 to spend, the GTI was also available to order in Performance specification. With 227bhp, the GTI Performance was only a little faster but, fitted as well with bigger front brakes and a limited-slip differential, it was also appreciably sharper to drive. Costing only £980 more than the regular GTI, it was a no-brainer for the keenest drivers. 

Our Verdict

Volkswagen Golf GTI

Can the hottest Volkswagen Golf GTI ignite the passion and reclaim its crown now lost to the Ford Focus ST?

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Ford Focus RS 2019 road test review - hero front
    23 September 2019
    Car review
    Is Ford’s AWD mega-hatch as special as we first thought? And can the Focus RS...
  • Honda Civic Type R 2019 road test review - hero front
    23 September 2019
    Car review
    Honda’s hottest hatch yet is quick on a track - but just how well rounded is...
  • Audi Q5 55 TFSIe quattro front three quarters on the road
    20 September 2019
    First Drive
    Plug-in SUV is compellingly fast and well rounded. Take advantage of the...

The earliest Mk7 GTIs start now at £13,000, although £15,000 will stretch to a newer car with fewer than 20,000 miles beneath it. Included in VW’s approved used scheme, called Das WeltAuto, is a 12-month unlimited-mileage warranty and roadside assistance over the same term. Every approved used VW undergoes a 142-point check by trained technicians, too. 

Both versions of the GTI could be specified with a manual or DSG dual-clutch transmission – both very good in their own way – and with three or five doors. The GTI Performance isn’t quite so common so you’ll have to be less picky when it comes to paint colour and spec options, and their prices start at £16,000. 

Perhaps the best argument for not spending that sum on a GTI Performance is the Golf R, which can be found for much the same money (albeit with higher mileage). When the Golf R arrived in 2014, prices started at a whisker under £30,000. With two extra driven wheels, 296bhp and superbly tuned suspension, the R was worth the extra outlay over the GTI back then, and with the price differential much slimmer now, the R looks even more attractive. Like the GTI, the R comes in both three and five-door configurations and you can choose between manual and DSG transmissions although, in this case, the DSG is preferable. 

If you put down £2000 and sign up to a 36-month finance agreement, a £16,000, four-year-old Golf R will cost you £296 each month (with a £7470 optional final payment). However you pay for your Golf hot hatch, though, bagging a warrantied car at half the price of a brand-new one would be a winning move by anybody’s judgement. 

Need to know

Wrapped in very low-profile rubber, the Golf R’s optional 19in wheels can be susceptible to pothole damage and are £800 a corner. Expect to pay £120 for each Bridgestone tyre, too. 

The Golf R’s Haldex four-wheel-drive system will need oil changes every three years, as will the GTI Performance’s limited-slip differential. In many cases, the differential fluid and transmission fluid are one and the same, but not here. 

Golf GTI owners have reported issues with rear dampers, which can begin weeping fluid after a number of years. A replacement VW part is an inexpensive fix, although some owners choose to upgrade to aftermarket Bilstein dampers all round. 

Our pick: VW Golf R

It may be a little more expensive than the GTI, but the Golf R is substantially faster, even better to drive and no less usable every day. Given its lofty reputation, the R is likely to hold more of its value over the coming years as well. 

Wild card: VW Golf GTD

Search VW’s approved used stock for a GTI or R and you’ll be trawling through a sea of GTDs. The 2.0-litre diesel engine made the GTD slower and more nose-heavy than the petrol models, but 67mpg combined is hard to argue with. 

Ones we found

  • 2014 Golf GTD, 55,000 miles, £12,790 
  • 2014 Golf GTI, 68,000 miles, £12,980 
  • 2014 Golf GTI Performance, 45,000 miles, £15,990 
  • 2015 Golf R, 67,000 miles, £16,645

Read more

Volkswagen ditches hybrid plans to play to Golf GTI’s strengths​

Hot hatchback twin test: Mercedes-AMG A35 vs. Volkswagen Golf R​

Price match promise: Volkswagen Golf R vs. first-gen Audi R8​

Join the debate

Comments
14

28 March 2019

of the braking DSG transmissions?

28 March 2019

It depends on which DSG transmission you are talking about according to Honest John it's one specific unit that caused problems with the other units being on a par with other autos (I think there's about 4 or 5 different units). From memory the MK 7 GTI and R have the more reliable transmission but if it is fitted with the less reliable unit it's pretty remiss not to mention it.

28 March 2019
NoPasaran wrote:

of the braking DSG transmissions?

The brakes do the braking not DSG.

XXXX just went POP.

28 March 2019

I always thought the gti was the keener more feelsome driver, going by reviews, this really does read like a vw advert with very little what to look out for advice. I'd choose a manual gti personally.

28 March 2019

Honest John is mentioning dampers and MMI intermittent faults as being the most common problems to look out for. Some DSG related issues.

28 March 2019

 Not sure about this, but, is there an estate Gti and R’...?, because I followed one which had a quad exhaust like the R’ has...?

Peter Cavellini.

28 March 2019

There's a GTD estate, and an R estate, but no GTI estate.

28 March 2019
Peter Cavellini wrote:

 Not sure about this, but, is there an estate Gti and R’...?, because I followed one which had a quad exhaust like the R’ has...?

 

Why not look it up for yourself?

28 March 2019

Yet again Autocar confused at the difference between nearly new and used.

28 March 2019

Yes, after 5 years, I'd say that nearly old was a better term! And paying around half the new price for a five year old potentially hard driven car isn't exactly a giveaway.

Still, the original owner probably got a decent part exchange price, so buying a new one looks tempting for those who can afford it...

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Ford Focus RS 2019 road test review - hero front
    23 September 2019
    Car review
    Is Ford’s AWD mega-hatch as special as we first thought? And can the Focus RS...
  • Honda Civic Type R 2019 road test review - hero front
    23 September 2019
    Car review
    Honda’s hottest hatch yet is quick on a track - but just how well rounded is...
  • Audi Q5 55 TFSIe quattro front three quarters on the road
    20 September 2019
    First Drive
    Plug-in SUV is compellingly fast and well rounded. Take advantage of the...