Still, let’s have a go, eh? The Peugeot deserves that much at least, because it is, let’s face it, pretty. It’s pleasing enough inside, too, with decent, supportive seats and a wide range of steering column adjustment, compensating to an extent for some slightly awkward pedal and gearshift actions.
Where it’s better than most other Peugeots in general, and RCZs in particular, is in the way that it drives. Its ride is firmish but far from harsh, and it’s impressively composed. It steers pretty fluently, too. There’s some torque steer, of course, because the engine is boosty and the limited-slip diff amplifies that sort of thing. But the benefit is traction beyond that expected of a 250bhp-plus front-driver and a degree of mid-corner throttle adjustability. It’s a good car.
Slide into the Jaguar and you’re not greeted with a gulf in terms of perceived interior quality. This generation of XK went on sale in 2006, and although Boyden’s XKR is a 2011 car and does feel classier than the RCZ, the gap isn’t as vast as you might think, given the price difference when the XKR was new. This was an £80k car, don’t forget.
The Jaguar’s seats are flatter than the Peugeot’s and the wheel doesn’t reach as far, but that’s the limit of the RCZ’s ergonomic advantage. The Jaguar’s control weights are all better – there’s no clutch, of course, because this is an auto only – and the Jaguar is a more comfortable place to spend long periods of time.
And you’ll want to, because it’s rather pleasant to drive. It steers smoothly and rides in that signature way that Jaguars do, with great body control but enough compliance to breathe over bumps.
When the XK was new, we said we probably preferred the softer way that the standard, non-supercharged XK drove – it had a lighter engine in its nose, too, so it felt more agile – but it’s hard to argue with the way that Boyden’s XKR sends itself down the road or lights up its rear tyres.
We wouldn’t usually do that with an owner’s used car, but Boyden, who had a new set of rears waiting at home, made us. We liked him. The ’zorst he had fitted makes a pretty sensational sound, too. An XKR always sounds good. This one has about 35% extra Nascar.
I know what you’re thinking, though. If you buy a new car and you buy it on finance, you might not own it outright yet but you don’t own any of its problems, either. So if it goes wrong, it’s frustrating, but you hand it back and they lend you something else until it’s fixed. All true.
And a 1.6-litre car with a combined fuel economy figure of 44.8mpg – even though you’re not going to get that – will be vastly more frugal than one with a four-year-old supercharged V8 that has since been turned up by 20%. True, too.
But if you buy a four-year-old Jaguar through the firm’s approved used scheme, they’ll throw in a two-year warranty. You’ll also find that there’s a large support network for cars like the XK, including the Jaguar Enthusiasts’ Club, through which we found Boyden. Not that they should need support too often; Jaguar was scoring highly in JD Power customer satisfaction surveys at the time and owners report XKRs are pretty trustworthy.
Check that any potential purchase has decent service history and that every single electrical system works, but the things that go wrong seem to be niggles, not biggies. Boyden’s car seems to be in good fettle; call him on 07904 028763 and he might even sell it to you.
Really, though, what we’re comparing here isn’t just two cars, but two ways of life. One’s a buy-it-new-and-forget-about-it daily driver. I can understand why people do that. But the used car represents an investment of time and interest. That’s more up my street and would be whether it came attached to a supercharged 5.0-litre V8 or not. That it does in this case is a heck of a bonus.
Read the previous test - New Mini Cooper S versus used Volkswagen Golf GTI
New versus used cars - which is better?
Peugeot RCZ R
Price today £32,250; Price when new £32,250; Engine 4 cyls, 1598cc, turbo, petrol; Power 266bhp at 6000rpm; Torque 243b ft at 1900-5500rpm; Gearbox 6-spd manual; Kerb weight 1355kg; 0-60mph 6.1sec; Top speed 155mph; Economy 44.8mpg; CO2/tax band 145g/km / 24%
Jaguar XKR (2011)
Price today £30,750; Price when new £77,845; Engine V8, 5000cc, supercharged, petrol; Power 503bhp at 6000rpm; Torque 461b ft at 2500-5500rpm; Gearbox 6-spd automatic; Kerb weight 1656kg; 0-60mph 4.6sec; Top speed 155mph; Economy 25.2mpg; CO2/tax band 292g/km 37%
Get the latest car news, reviews and galleries from Autocar direct to your inbox every week. Enter your email address below: