When it comes to the used car market, I don’t pay much attention to the ‘official’ industry line on anything. Instead, I listen to you. And the burning question in the emails I’ve been getting lately is: “Should I buy diesel or petrol?”
This is an ongoing issue and won’t go away until there is an official answer via the fuel tax system. In the meantime, please let me make it clear that if you are buying a used car and don’t do that many miles - say, around 10,000 a year - then you might as well buy petrol.
Before I replied to a reader, I looked out of the window and noted that the four cars on my drive were all petrol, while the quite old one in the garage was also petrol-powered. I really don’t need diesel in my life and, depending on the circumstances, neither do you.
Now, I know that 85mpg is all very impressive, but you will have to spend a substantial amount of money to enjoy that level of fuel economy. Used cars don’t have to be dirt cheap, but the most singular appeal is that they dial out the most expensive motoring cost of all: depreciation.
The second biggest cost is fuel, unless you have a major engine breakdown, which will take you back to square one. So although you can get lucky with a high-mileage diesel, I get rather frightened by the associated particulate filters, turbos and dual-mass flywheel clutches, never mind all those injectors that have to be replaced.
Our reader wasn’t looking for anything complicated, either; he just wanted a sensible family car to do a solid few thousand miles each year without breaking down. His budget meant he was in the market for relatively recent 100,000-mile motors. So petrol it was.
The shortlist included a Vauxhall Insignia or a Honda Accord, and I unadventurously suggested a Ford Mondeo or Toyota Avensis. So with £5000 to spend - my projected average for a decent used buy - the options are a 40,000-mile 2009 Insignia 1.8 16V SE, a 2008 Accord 2.0i EX with 69,000 miles, a 60,000-mile 2008 Mondeo 2.0 Zetec or a 2009 Avensis 1.8 V-Matic TR with 74,000 miles.
The Avensis was interesting because it was the latest shape. And you can never rule out the Mondeo, which is consistently a lot of car for the money. However, the Insignia seemed to me like the pick of the bunch on sheer value.
Our reader, though, is poised to dive into an Accord - the most sensible thing to do. It’s not only classy but also shouldn’t give the owner any sleepless nights. In fact, none of those models should, and 99% of the reason for that is because they are run-in petrols. So buy them.