Video: Jaguar F-type coupé versus Porsche Cayman GTS

18 September 2014
Feature

We pit the sensational new 336bhp Porsche Cayman GTS against one of our favourite sports cars - the 375bhp Jaguar F-type V6 S coupé. Which will come out on top? Steve Sutcliffe decides.

Used cars for sale

 Jaguar F-type 5.0 Supercharged V8 R 2dr Auto
2017
£27,490
54,588miles
Petrol
Automatic
2
View details
Jaguar F-type 3.0 Supercharged V6 S 2dr Auto
2014
£29,900
45,386miles
Petrol
Automatic
2
View details
Jaguar F-type 3.0 Supercharged V6 2dr Auto
2015
£29,995
21,000miles
Petrol
Automatic
2
View details
Jaguar F-type 2.0 R-dynamic 2dr Auto
2017
£29,995
58,874miles
Petrol
Automatic
2
View details
Jaguar F-type 3.0 Supercharged V6 2dr Auto
2016
£31,495
23,697miles
Petrol
Automatic
2
View details
Jaguar F-type 3.0 Supercharged V6 S 2dr Auto
2016
£32,000
33,390miles
Petrol
Automatic
2
View details
Jaguar F-type 3.0 Supercharged V6 2dr Auto
2016
£32,500
23,300miles
Petrol
Automatic
2
View details
Jaguar F-type 2.0 R-dynamic 2dr Auto
2018
£34,444
16,122miles
Petrol
Automatic
2
View details
Jaguar F-type 2.0 2dr Auto
2018
£34,490
16,500miles
Petrol
Automatic
2
View details
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Join the debate

Comments
23
Add a comment…
Citytiger 20 September 2014

Further proof

Pierre, I actually think it proves the Jaguar is the better all-round car, but the Porsche is the better track car, as I have said in an earlier post, we dont spend our lives on a track, and if you drove anywhere near the limits of these vehicles on public roads you deserve to be locked up, the Jaguar has bare far the nicer interior and thats where you spend most of your time, does it really matter if the steering is not quite as nice when you are on the limit, for 99% of the target audience, I would say probably not.
Peter Cavellini 20 September 2014

YEP!!!!

Citytiger@

So,it's Horses for courses,you choose what you like,these two cars are close in many ways,but, in the end,you buy what you like,right?

Pierre 19 September 2014

Further proof?

Roadster, I think you're really saying that if Jaguar made a better car, it would be better.

It's hard to argue with that, but until they do, they have to be judged on what they do actually make, just as Porsche do, and it appears that Porsche make the better car.

Roadster 19 September 2014

Further proof that the F Type is the best car in its class.

The Cayman, in GTS guise, is regarded as Porsche's finest sports car. That the F-Type in a standard set-up has ran it so close and only just missed out here is testament to Jaguar's excellence and further proof of how brilliant the F-Type is. It also highlights the fact that the F-Type is by far the best car in its class on the basis that it has got closer to the Cayman than any 911 can ever hope to manage. Imagine if Jaguar produced an even more driver-orientated F-Type. It'd kick the likes of a 911 GT3 in to the middle of next week.