The i3’s upright body profile, its relatively high centre of gravity and the profile of its tyres (designed as they are to minimise rolling resistance and maximise battery range) continue to present the car with significant dynamic hurdles to overcome. Even so, the i3s succeeds in two key dimensions: by being at once a more grippy, settled, balanced and compelling proposition than a standard i3, and a much more engaging and charismatic car to drive than any of its all-electric rivals. 

That it still doesn’t feel as stable, purposeful or rewarding as any of the piston-engined hot hatches you could spend its asking price on may be true, but it’d be a very uncharitable basis by which to deny it due credit here.

Matt Saunders Autocar

Matt Saunders

Chief tester
When it comes to outright grip, the i3s can't quite match a true hot hatch

It’s the i3s’s steering that provides the first hint of its ambition to offer a more athletic drive than the average battery car. There’s a noticeable amount of heft here, particularly at low speeds, and its quick gearing lends the i3s plenty of easy agility. 

Then there’s the way it rides. The i3s is firm-riding – not to the point of being in any way uncomfortable, but just a little short on suppleness over rougher surfaces. A compromise is being struck here, of course, between day-to-day comfort, outright grip, handling response and terrierish motive temperament; and for a performance-oriented car, it’s probably the right one.

Its uprated sports suspension contains body roll well, although the i3s still pitches fore and aft more than the average hot supermini might. Those standard-fit 20in alloys (the base i3 makes do with smaller 19s) make for a bit of secondary fuss and fidget over small lumps and bumps but not enough to make you question the wisdom of fitting them. In terms of outright grip level, the i3s isn’t quite at a true hot hatch’s adhesiveness.

If you drive it hard on slippery roads, it doesn’t take that much to trigger the dynamic stability control as the car begins to squat on its hindquarters under power and understeer around bends a little. But that stability control is very good and always keeps the car true to its course. There’s also more than enough purchase and balance here to enjoy a spirited flit across A-roads and B-roads.

Removing the i3s from its natural city centre environment won’t induce a great deal of stress. Motorway driving is a mostly relaxing experience, but it pays to bear the speed of the steering in mind when performing quicker lane changes.

Save money on your car insurance

Compare quotesCompare insurance quotes

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Hyundai Nexo 2019 first drive review hero front
    First Drive
    13 July 2018
    Designed from the outset to use a hydrogen fuel cell powertrain, this front-driven crossover provides a taste of the future today
  • Mercedes-Benz A-Class 2018 road test review hero front
    Car review
    13 July 2018
    This new version is the most luxurious A-Class yet, but has Mercedes made it a class leader?
  • Honda CR-V 2018 first drive review hero front
    First Drive
    13 July 2018
    For its fourth-generation, the Honda CR-V grows in size and now offers a choice of five or seven seats, but slims down in terms of engine choices
  • Volkswagen Arteon 1.5 EVO 2018 UK review hero front
    First Drive
    13 July 2018
    Entry-level fastback doesn’t do enough to make the Arteon any more competitive in an already-tough class
  • BMW i8 Coupe 2018 UK first drive review hero front
    First Drive
    13 July 2018
    BMW's flagship i car has received a facelift for 2018. How does it compare to offerings from Porsche?