It's already seen off its Mercedes-Benz and BMW rivals during a comparison test, but this junior Land Rover now begins a tougher trial: a year in our hands
Allan Muir
17 April 2016

Jaguar Land Rover’s decision to introduce the Discovery Sport last year with the old, Ford-sourced 2.2-litre diesel engine under its bonnet may have seemed a little strange at the time, given that the firm had already opened a new facility in Wolverhampton to build its own powerplants, but we always knew we wouldn’t have to wait too long for the existing unit to be replaced.

Besides, it has hardly held the car back in its first year on sale.

The Freelander-replacing compact SUV has gone on to become Land Rover’s second best-selling model after the Range Rover Evoque, shifting about 10,000 units a month on average, and it’s a car that, with some reservations, we’ve regarded as the best of its breed from the outset, ageing engine or not.

The arrival of the 2016 Discovery Sport, now fitted with the more efficient 2.0-litre diesel Ingenium engine, has served only to reinforce that view.

The very car you see here - which we’re running for a year - beat the Mercedes-Benz GLC 250d and BMW X3 xDrive20d in a £40k 4x4s comparison in the 27 January issue, cementing its ranking as the top choice in the class.

It’s a very well-rounded package now, with much more competitive fuel economy and CO2 emissions figures than the earlier model, although it still comes with a few reservations in areas such as engine refinement and the quality of some of its cabin materials.

Rather than picking up our car from a dealer, we were able to collect it from JLR’s Halewood plant in Liverpool, where the Discovery Sport and Evoque are built, and have a quick tour of the trim and final assembly sections of the production line.

Before handing over the keys, Halewood operations director Richard Else gave us an insight into the former Ford facility, which was on the brink of closing in the late 1990s but has been rejuvenated in the intervening period and now churns out around 180,000 cars a year, with 4200 staff making Evoques, Discovery Sports and now Evoque Convertibles 24 hours a day over three shifts.

It may be relatively quiet inside, but the place is booming.

The model we’ve gone for is a mid-range HSE with an automatic gearbox and its list price is £39,400. Opting for that transmission over the £1805-cheaper six-speed manual means you have only one engine choice: the more powerful, 178bhp version of the Ingenium TD4, which is backed up by 317lb ft of torque at just 1750rpm.

Perhaps unfairly, I can’t help but wish that I had more powertrain options from which to choose. I’d almost certainly have a plug-in petrol-electric hybrid version if I could.

Still, you can’t expect everything at once. Standard features at HSE level include front and rear parking sensors, a reversing camera, panoramic roof, 19in wheels, powered tailgate, heated front seats, keyless entry, xenon headlights with automatic high beam assist and the same 8.0in touchscreen multimedia system with navigation as you get in the Jaguar XE.

To that list we’ve added a heated steering wheel, spacesaver spare wheel, metallic paint, a black contrast roof, privacy glass, traffic sign recognition and upgraded connectivity in the form of InControl Connect, lifting the price as tested by a relatively modest amount to £42,222.

The combination of Scotia Grey (actually a soft metallic green) body colour, black roof and black leather interior may seem relatively conservative, but the effect is really very classy, and I suspect it reflects the way the majority of buyers actually specify their cars when practicality is a consideration, as it usually is with a car like this.

First impressions of the cabin are that it’s quite plain but the driving position and seats are supremely comfortable, there’s a generous amount of space in the second row thanks to the standard sliding/reclining function and the +2 seats that fold out of the boot floor might actually be usable, even for adults if necessary.

Given that it’s a sensible 4.6 metres long and relatively wieldy, the Discovery Sport strikes me as a clever piece of packaging. After we’d ended our tour of Halewood and were driving back to London in the box-fresh Discovery Sport, the first thing I noticed was how superbly the car deals with gnarly British roads.

It’s so smooth, controlled and quiet in its suspension movements when tackling the likes of potholes and speed bumps that you’ll be gobsmacked if you’re used to ‘foreign’ cars - and even most other SUVs. I suspect I’ve already discovered one of the main benefits of driving a car developed and built in the UK…

‘Comfort’ is a word that is probably going to crop up a lot in future updates on our Discovery Sport, and I reckon it’s one of the things I’m going to enjoy most about our time with this car. But not the only thing, I’m sure.

A year in a diesel SUV is going to be something of a change of pace for me, the Discovery Sport replacing a Volkswagen Golf R on my driveway, but with the world seemingly going crazy for this type of vehicle, I’m more than happy to be jumping on the bandwagon.

Car: Land Rover Discovery Sport HSE TD4 190 auto

Needs to: Be as comfortable off-road as it is on it, and usable every day

Run by Autocar since: March 2016

List price £39,400; Price as tested £42,222; Options InControl Connect £650; Scotia Grey metallic paint £600; Santorini Black contrast roof £500; privacy glass £350; reduced-setion spare wheel £287; traffic sign recognition £250; heated steering wheel £185; Economy 31.7mpg; Faults None; Expenses None

Our Verdict

The Land Rover Discovery Sport
The new Land Rover Discovery Sport is the successor to the Freelander

The Freelander's replacement goes big on prettiness and packaging, and as a result becomes the class leader

Join the debate

Comments
7

17 April 2016
You may as well have gone a model up to HSE Black. Much better than adding bits and bobs to the HSE.

17 April 2016
So the ride has improved since Autocar wrote "For those switching from the smallest Range Rover, it’s worth mentioning that the edges are more apparent here – especially in the quality of the secondary ride, which occasionally stumbles from crisply rugged to downright bony, a vice not helped by the Sport’s wider failure to isolate you from the audible machinations of the suspension.

This chivvying at the comfort levels does the car a disservice if for no other reason than that the primary ride – its capacity to soak up the low-frequency hillocks of UK roads at a cruise – is generally stellar." ?

17 April 2016
Yes, considerably.

18 April 2016
"It may be relatively quiet inside, but the place is booming."
I thought JLR were slightly in the doodoo after the latest twitch from the Chinese market?

"you’ll be gobsmacked if you’re used to ‘foreign’ cars " i don't get this. Do you mean cars made by non-UK manufacturers? Or cars not developed on UK roads.

18 April 2016
What 'sport' is it exactly that is being referred to in the name? If it's driving I would rather have a GTI or MX5.

18 April 2016
Interesting to hear you'd rather take a more powerful version or a Petrol Electric Hybrid instead of the engine you have.

An off the cuff comment such as this is very telling and I wonder how many other customers / potential customers feel this way? I'd wager quite a few.

 

 

It's all about the twisties........

18 April 2016
TegTypeR wrote:

Interesting to hear you'd rather take a more powerful version or a Petrol Electric Hybrid instead of the engine you have.

An off the cuff comment such as this is very telling and I wonder how many other customers / potential customers feel this way? I'd wager quite a few.

Valid observation and comment Teg type R. I was all set to have a Discovery Sport, but delayed my decision for 6 months in order to wait for the new engine, but also to see if they were going to bring out a Diesel / Electric hybrid version . I would not consider petrol / electric hybrid as the real life economy is so poor –based on example of Mitsubishi PHev. As the latter looked to be some time off and also because I still had reservation about the amount of BIK tax on the Discovery Sport, I subsequently had a change of mind and ordered an F-Pace as this appealed more, sufficient to justify the amount tax payable in order to have as a company vehicle

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Lexus LC500
    Car review
    20 October 2017
    Futuristic Lexus LC coupé mixes the latest technology with an old-school atmospheric V8
  • Maserati Levante S GranSport
    First Drive
    20 October 2017
    Get ready to trade in your diesels: Maserati’s luxury SUV finally gets the engine it’s always needed
  • Jaguar XF Sportbrake TDV6
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    The handsome Jaguar XF Sportbrake exhibits all the hallmarks that makes the saloon great, and with the silky smooth diesel V6 makes it a compelling choice
  • Volkswagen T-Roc TDI
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    Volkswagen's new compact crossover has the looks, the engineering and the build quality to be a resounding success, but not with this diesel engine
  • BMW M550i
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    The all-paw M550i is a fast, effortless mile-muncher, but there's a reason why it won't be sold in the UK