Currently reading: Tata Nano vs Hyundai i10
The world's cheapest car goes head to head with Britain's best city car on UK roads
Autocar
News
3 mins read
30 May 2010

The Tata Nano has given new meaning to the word affordable, but how will it cope with the day-to-day demands of running in Britain?

Will a car with just 33bhp – and one that takes in excess of 30 seconds to hit 60mph and runs out of puff entirely not far north of 65mph – seem entirely unsuitable for our roads?

See the Hyundai i10 versus Tata Nano test pics

Will the compromises that its £2250 price places on refinement, handling, quality and performance perhaps seem too great for our Western palettes to bear?

And will the world’s cheapest car look too cheap next to the best-value city car offered to British buyers in recent years: Hyundai’s i10?

Delivery mileage only

The Nano has been supplied by Richard Cruttenden, who bought it in India and drove it over 6000 miles back to the UK. Yet inside and out, it shows little evidence of the adventures it has been through.

The driver’s door feels very light, but once you are settled in you soon get comfy. The steering wheel sits a little low and doesn’t adjust, but that’s it.

You get a lot of space for your money. At less than 3.1 metres it’s barely 10cm longer than a Toyota iQ, yet it’s a proper four-seat family car with bags of head and shoulder room.

The engine is a two-cylinder 624cc petrol two-valver with a single overhead cam, and it’s buried under the boot floor. Although it’s noiser than most superminis, it has multi-point fuel injection, a balancer shaft and special Bosch ECU.

Across quiet rural routes the Nano feels unexpectedly comfortable. Up to 50mph you can keep up with most traffic if you know how hard to work the engine and when to change gear – there’s no rev counter or shift lights to help. Corners do induce bodyroll, but grip at the front wheels is decent enough.

Life on a multi-laner is unenjoyable, though. The rev limiter intervenes at 65mph, but even at 60mph this car lacks the basic directional stability, chassis control and stopping power to give confidence.

Oddly, where you’d expect the Nano to impress – in the city – it’s only okay. Visibility is excellent and there’s – just – enough power to nip into gaps, but the unpowered steering can get cumbersome and there’s not enough compliance in the Nano’s chassis to soak up broken surfaces.

The i10

How does a Hyundai i10 feel after this? Sublime. Like a new Mercedes C-class after a tired, ten-year-old Vectra.

It’s gloriously easy and precise around town; it feels like a rocketship away from a standstill; it rides bumps so quietly and handles its body movements so well for a car so small. It’s just a peach.

Back to top

That isn’t to say there’s no future in Europe for the Nano – far from it. Already work has begun on making the car comply with stricter Euro 5 emissions standards as well as fitting it with better, disc-based anti-lock brakes and a more sophisticated ECU.

Other changes need to be made to: in our book , the Nano needs power steering, a better chassis and a slightly higher top speed to really cut it with European customers.

You can read the full story, plus see more pictures, in this week's Autocar magazine, which is on sale now.

See all the latest Hyundai i10 reviews, news and videoSee all the latest Tata Nano reviews, news and video

Join the debate

Comments
15
Add a comment…
VirginPower 31 May 2010

Re: Tata Nano vs Hyundai i10

Autocar wrote:
Will the compromises that its £2250 price places on refinement, handling, quality and performance perhaps seem too great for our Western palettes to bear?

This really upsets me.

Western palettes have been some of the finest ones since they first appeared on the scene, and, indeed, far from not being exported across Europe, they were exported across Europe, and used by people like Goyter, Giovanni Bellini (not the rally driver, the other one), Hans Membling (Hans Mumbling in English), Hugo van der Goes (Huge van that Goes), Jan van Eyck (Johnny van Eyck), Jeanie Fouquet (not the rally driver, the other one), Enguerrand Quartunes (there's no such rally driver) and Tony Hart.

I could name many, many more, I'm sure, but I don't believe there are any.

moe360 30 May 2010

Re: Tata Nano vs Hyundai i10

I just bought a brand new A3 Sportback 1.4TFSI Sport in that fancy white and the interior is amazing I cant stop playing with all the switch gear IoI, the S line was to exspensive to insure the sport is a good compromise.

tannedbaldhead 30 May 2010

Re: Tata Nano vs Hyundai i10

moe360 wrote:
Audi A1

Not that keen. Sat in an A3 S Line. Really nice interior. Didn't bother with a test drive though. If I buy anything it wont be till September. Fancied the Polo 1.2 TSI but a few options take the price to almost £19K. Have had a look at the Pug RCZ and find it a damn sight better looking in real life than in pictures. Its interior is also a hellova lot better than I expected. Only problem is that it's so bloody heavy and front drive. May well be a bit stodgier a drive than I'd be happy with. Might even keep the MX5 for a bit longer and stack the payments into the bank. Now may be a time for saving rather than spending.