What will replace the ‘Buckingham Palace on wheels’ approach to building luxury cars in an era of electrification and environmental awareness? We investigate

The recent spat at the Geneva motor show between Aston Martin and Rolls-Royce was a most un-English outburst.

Aston’s unexpected reveal of the electric Lagonda super-luxury concept was accompanied by a direct denunciation of Rolls-Royce’s future as the ‘pinnacle of luxury’ by the brand’s chief creative officer, Marek Reichman.

Reichman described Rolls-Royce as “the most luxurious car in the world” but then qualified that by suggesting its time was running out. “Given its roots, its reason for being, it’s essentially still an internal combustion engine to replace a horse, a carriage and a trunk. It’s an imperfect package for luxury,” he said.

“Rolls-Royce and Bentley are Ancient Greece today. I worked on the original Phantom. The brief was ‘Buckingham Palace on wheels’. It was important to do that to establish it. But the world has changed, and the royals have changed.”

Our Verdict

Rolls Royce Phantom 2018 review hero front

The eighth-gen Rolls Royce Phantom is the second of the company's modern era. Is it still a world-beater?

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

Reichman also predicted that “the [automotive] world will be more extreme, and customers expect it. You can’t see Apple or Google executives in a Phantom. You can see them in this [a Lagonda].”

It’s exceptionally rare for one car maker to so directly attack another, especially in a way that suggests Rolls-Royce – as currently configured – does not have bright future ahead of it. Reichman’s punchiness might have hit even harder at Rolls-Royce because he was on the original Phantom design team, which was billeted in a disused bank overlooking Hyde Park Corner.

At the same Geneva show, Rolls-Royce boss Torsten Müller- Ötvös told the Financial Times that Aston “really don’t understand our segment, they really don’t understand the customers... they are in a complete different league on pricing, they have zero clue what’s going on in the upper, upper segment – zero.”

On the face of it, Aston’s decision to declare its intention to enter the ultra-luxury segment with a new brand while taking a big swing at the established market leader seems to be a storm in a very small teacup. In 2017, Rolls-Royce sold just 3362 cars (down on 4011 in 2016, as some customers waited for the all-new Phantom). Last year, Aston sold 5117, up 58% on the year before, off the back of strong demand for the DB11.

So why, when the ultra-luxury market is so small, should there be such a row? The short answer is that Aston hopes – and Rolls-Royce is well aware – that a once-in-a- generation shift in taste could be on the horizon. For the world’s multimillionaires and billionaires, the established ideas of what constitutes ultra-luxury might be about to change.

To be fair to Rolls-Royce, it has already shown its vision of the future. The 2016 103EX was the brand’s first ‘visionary’ concept car. While it was more extreme than the Lagonda concept, the 103EX very much played a similar tune: all-electric drive, full autonomy and an interior made from unusual materials and described as ‘grand sanctuary’.

What Aston is doing with the Lagonda concept, according to researchers and analysts working in the global luxury sector, is known as ‘luxury hacking’. According to a Future of Luxury report by the Economist Intelligence Unit, hacking is “about understanding what a product really is and providing a new and different, more convenient and exciting approach”.

It continues: “Luxury brands have an extraordinary growth potential if they disrupt their own business model and come up with services that create unexpected experiences for their guests. The opportunities are almost limitless. And if the incumbents don’t reinvent their business models, outsiders will do so instead.”

Take electrification. Rolls-Royce built an EV version of the Phantom in 2012 and sent it on a world tour. The project was dropped, according to industry rumours, because the company did not receive any serious orders, even from super-luxury hotel fleets. The company may build an EV version of the new Phantom, but it appears to be reluctant to push the market into something that is not being demanded. The Lagonda project, on the other hand, is a bespoke EV platform, which obviously opens up the opportunity to build a car with a very different interior package.

According to the analysts, there are plenty of other trends that could play towards Aston’s bet on an ultra-luxury EV. Eighteen months ago, consultancy Trendwatching released a report on what it thought would steer consumer luxury in 2017 and beyond. It claimed that status “used to be physical and is now intangible”, adding: “Status has become less about ‘what I have’ and much more about ‘who I am’ – namely, moreethical, creative, connected, tasteful.”

‘Self-actualisation’ is the theory behind a huge shift in luxury consumption patterns, where experiences and products ‘supercharge’ a person’s ability to improve themselves and their overall well-being.

Trendwatching says this move is reflected in everything from new types of exercise to ever more exotic types of drink.

Another big shift – and one especially relevant to the automotive industry – is that the future of ultra-luxury has to be guilt-free, say Trendwatching analysts “Millions of affluent consumers feel trapped in a guilt spiral when it comes to the negative impacts – on the environment, society and their health – of their consumption. The real luxury for these consumers? Indulgence without the guilt.”

‘On-demand extravagance’ is another significant shift, something that can be seen even in the rise and rise of Uber taxis and food delivery. The final, perhaps most significant claim, is that traditional demographic theory is over, opening the way for ‘old luxury’ to be swept away.

“The old demographic model – which sought to predict consumer behaviours based on age, gender, location, income bracket and more – is losing its power,” says Trendwatching. “Instead, consumers are freer than ever to construct lifestyles and attitudes of their own choosing. That’s thanks to unlimited access to information, the erosion of old social conventions, endless choice and more.”

For example, a social media backlash against farmed leather could make traditional interiors a difficult sell in the near future. It’s just such a risk that pushed Land Rover into developing a premium fabric interior for the Range Rover Velar. Clearly, there’s enough trend theory in that one report to support Aston’s bet on launching a futuristic Lagonda EV. But there’s another intriguing shift that could affect the ultra-luxury market.

Marie-Cécile Cervellon, a marketing professor at the French EDHEC Business School, told consultancy Canvas8 that “vintage and second-hand luxury is still a huge trend” in the fashion world.

This is well-established in the automotive industry with the classic car boom and the move for car manufacturers to offer factory restoration services for their own historic vehicles.

But what if more mainstream luxury EVs were deemed refined enough to provide transport for ultra- luxury consumers and more smart money starts to flow into prestige classics and even classics that are re-engineered for modern life, such as the Mercedes SLs built by Brabus and Hemmels?

As Bentley’s chief designer Stefan Sielaff told Autocar, the new sociological trend is of people being – and acting – ‘forever young’. Such people would rather have a bespoke classic plaything, perhaps, than invest £250,000 or more in a traditional super-luxury new vehicle.

Clearly, the Lagonda concept proposal fits all of these potential trends like a glove. Reichman even claimed at the Geneva show that “Lagonda has always been a disruptor. It has a massive heritage of going toe to toe with Rolls-Royce and Bentley. It has always offered a different shape and form.”

Aston, however, remains a minnow, and it has plenty on its plate. But the noisy arrival of the Lagonda is a bet on disruption in the ultra-luxury market, taking the Tesla formula and moving it forward significantly.The list of disruptive possibilities is long. A new generation of ultra- high-net-worth people who are younger in outlook and influenced by their millennial children and grandchildren, a shift against leather and petrol-chemical-based plastics allied to a greater interest in sustainable natural materials and a much-reduced energy footprint in the construction of the vehicle.

Ultra-luxury with a much lighter environmental impact and even a desire for a more radical interior architecture is a distinct possibility. But it’s a hell of bet for a company the size of Aston Martin.

Rolls-Royce: the future is custom, not disruption: 

“After some years in this business, and after talking to many, many customers, I know how fundamentally important it is today to have something very different from the ordinary,” says Rolls-Royce CEO Torsten Müller-Ötvös.

“It’s not about bling, or price positioning. It’s about our cars being very special, including under the skin. There is no other way for us than to take a different route from the rest.

“One huge advantage of our new, highly flexible production system is that bespoke cars can be completed on the line. We don’t have to build a car to take it apart again. This helps quality enormously, and makes the process far more efficient.

“We have 100 people working only on bespoke and 90% of our cars have special equipment.

Owners participate in the bespoke process: it’s like creating a piece of art – and they can be part of it.

“Bespoke is now so big and valuable to our business, I’d almost say Rolls-Royce could not survive without it.”

How the disruptive ultra-luxury car of tomorrow might look: 

  • All-aluminium construction from 100% recycled material
  • Massively reduced component miles, as much of the car constructed within 250 miles of final assembly as possible and component deliveries made by biomethane-powered trucks
  • Recycled copper HT cables, ethically sourced cobalt and other minerals
  • Leather interior replaced by wool, cashmere, silk, Alcantara and cotton
  • Low-CO2 lithium battery packs made with renewable or nuclear energy
  • Manufacturer has a secure server for storing digital information uploaded by the car and the owner
  • Near total removal of plastic mouldings. Dashboard, console and door trims made from high- craft wood, ceramics and stone
  • Individual occupant low-power halogen heating
  • Rolls imagines a ‘Grand Sanctuary’ for car occupants
  • Low-CO2 manufacture, offset by tree-planting in the UK’s National Forest
  • Electric motors that don’t use rare-earth materials
  • Significantly lighter and less bulky seat designs, moving away from traditional automotive seats
  • Compressed natural gas- powered range extender option for countries with high-CO2 grid generation. (CNG ICE engines are categorised as ‘near-zero emission’ in California.)

Read more 

Rolls-Royce Wraith review 

Rolls-Royce Phantom review 

Rolls-Royce Ghost review 

Join the debate


14 April 2018

 I hope I’m off the Road by the time these Jerry Anderson Luxo barges get on the Road.

Peter Cavellini.

14 April 2018
This is interesting. I believe we're in the process of huge cultural shift, particularly with the mega rich. There thousands of new customers entering markets who know nothing of the heritage of these types of companies, neither do they care for it. I've been working in Italy on and off for the past few months for a luxury motor yacht builder, they're seeing the same thing and rapidly changing their designs to meet the changing tastes.

14 April 2018
Marc wrote:

This is interesting. I believe we're in the process of huge cultural shift, particularly with the mega rich. There thousands of new customers entering markets who know nothing of the heritage of these types of companies, neither do they care for it. I've been working in Italy on and off for the past few months for a luxury motor yacht builder, they're seeing the same thing and rapidly changing their designs to meet the changing tastes.

There is a big difference between a luxury yacht and a super-luxury car. A car is also intended for the multitude of on-lookers on the road and sidewalk. This why RR and Bentley keep their super-luxury car tradition, and that is why Maybach and Lagonda Failed (certainly reliability of the latter took its toll). Luxury achts are manufactured in a much lower numbers per model and a very limited number of on-lookers can watch them. Therefore the emphasis is more on internal luxury and facilities than on external recognizable design.


15 April 2018

...from the reveal of the car and the statements that followed, it just seems that the folks at Aston Martin/Lagonda blindsided/sucker punched those over at Rolls Royce. As if they were calling them out and serving them with a letter of intent, demanding their attention and respect! Following the original analogy, I don't think Rolls Royce would ever get into a fist fight, or back and forth between them and Aston Martin/Lagonda, yet the products would have to speak for themselves. I must say though, not that I would ever be in a position to afford either of them, Lagonda's concept looks a lot more promising then Rolls Royce's 103XE. While the concepts dashboard and instrumentation, to my eye, looks as good as the exterior, the rest of the interior appointments are not exactly what one would come to expect for a vehicle that competes against Rolls Royce, Bentley and Bugatti. Outside of that, IMHO, Aston Martin/Lagonda is headed in the right direction, but execution is what will make all the difference and garner them the Respect that they are looking for.   


15 April 2018

....I still believe that when the time is right, Mercedes will step in and taking a controlling interest an Aston Martin and its Lagonda brand.

15 April 2018

This is one of the most insightful articles I have read for a while. It is really good. One thing, I don't think the material options quite match the intentions. Wool (mentioned twice as cashmere is wool) won't go down well with vegans on the same grounds as leather that was mentioned as not welcome. Cotton has a high environmental impact and has better alternatives such a bamboo and tencel (made from eucalyptus trees). And finally, lightweight materials and stone don't usually go together.

15 April 2018

It would look good in Metroplis but in the real world the driver would scratch and bend the wheel fairing each time he pulled up to the kerb.


16 April 2018

I wonder if these trend-spotters spend too much time doing research amongst the highly educated with internet-derived wealth or others in industries that encourage socially responsible attitudes?  It seems to me that there will always be plenty of very wealthy but vulgar people who don’t live in areas like Silicon Valley, who don’t give a rat’s arse about sea levels and who just want to flash it.  Even the former will continue to lead lives that consume very large amounts of energy eg living in mansions, keeping other houses available for occupation a few weeks a year, flying private etc.  It’s changing the way the 99% live that will make a difference.  But, I like the way Lagonda seems to be heading, although "It has a massive heritage of going toe to toe with Rolls-Royce and Bentley" is bollocks.

16 April 2018
As long as we consume hamburgers, leather will be available. It's what livestock is covered in. The whole world going vegan is a lot further off in the future, than the world's vehicles going 100% electric.

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week