Saab's flagship saloon gets replaced after 13 years. Was it worth the wait?

What is it?

This is the long-awaited, all-new Saab 9-5, a car which almost scrapped as Saab came within days of being wound up in December last year. It replaces the 13-year-old first-generation 9-5 which, in automotive terms, was at least two generations old.

It would also be tremendously unfair to call this car a Vauxhall. The parts that make up the 9-5 were either conceived and created in Sweden itself or under under the direct guidance of Swedish engineering chiefs working under General Motors umbrella in Germany.

Indeed, in this range-topping form, the 9-5 is arguably the most purely-conceived Saab since the 9000 was launched back in 1985, with 70 percent of its part numbers unique to Saab.

What’s it like?

This is an unusual car. On paper, it is aimed directly at the Audi A6 (Audi and Saab buyers are apparently closely related) but at nearly 5.1m long, the 9-5 is the same length as the BMW 7-series. Compared to the related Insignia, the 9-5 gets an extra 10cm in the wheelbase.

The result is extraordinary legroom both front and rear as well as a very substantial boot. It’s a very wide car, too. The upshot is that the 9-5 range probably offers more space than any other car retailing for under £50,000.

There’s no mistaking the cabin, either. It remains gloriously Saabish, individual and cleverly thought-out. The usual great seats are complimented by some desirable options, including an excellent head-up display and blistering Harman Kardon hi-fi.

Saab says that new 9-5 was ‘engineered with the driver in focus’ for a ‘segment leading sporty driving experience’. Combining this aim with a front-drive car as large as the 9-5 could not have been straightforward.

The 2.8-litre V6 engine - which uses a twin-scroll turbocharger and gets variable valve timing on both camshafts - is a huge advance over the first-generation unit fitted to the 9-3. The induction, exhaust and installation system have all been greatly refined. It drives a conventional six-speed autobox.

First off, there’s a satisfying sophistication to the drivetrain of this new Saab. The engine is very smooth and extremely refined under cruising conditions and the autobox swift to respond. The fact that it can get to 62mph in 6.9 seconds, despite weighing 1945kg gives some idea of its potency. The 9-5 can kick down and sprint past slower cars with ease.

However, even with the chassis in ‘Sport’ mode, there’s a certain imperiousness and refinement about this 9-5 which is not the most ‘sporty driving experience in the segment’. It’s not inclined to claw its way aggressively around bends and the steering becomes a little indirect when cornering hard. It is not that the 9-5 cannot pick up its skirts and go hard.

It can, with a turn of speed that belies its size. But it does it with an underlying sense of calm that’s partly thanks to the suspension’s ability to hold the body neatly and smoothly in check.

This is probably explained by the combination of the ‘Skyhook’ principle of the active damping (where the dampers attempt to mimic the body being held steadily in space) and the effects of the HiPer strut front suspension (which damps out at lot the ‘noise’ and interference from the road surface) combine to isolate the driver from the road surface, while allowing the car to progress very quickly. It might be argued that buyers in this particular segment want a little more edge to the driver experience.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Find an Autocar review

Back to top

Should I buy one?

This range-topping version offers the best Saab can currently offer and features some highly impressive technology. It is fast, smooth, refined and has an impressively sophisticated edge. But it’s bigger than rivals and less aggressively sporting than other high performance sports saloons, a mix that will split opinion.

Later this year Saab will launch an intriguing 188bhp twin-turbo-diesel 9-5 (the £28,495 2.0 TTiD) with the same upgraded suspension as this 2.8T, but without four wheel drive. This model might be the be best compromise for those who want a sporting 9-5 for more mainstream money.

See all the latest Saab reviews, news and video

Join the debate

Comments
57
Add a comment…
Dan McNeil v2 2 June 2010

Re: Saab 9-5 2.8T XWD Aero

Paul123 wrote:

Chips wrote:
Would you really want this Saab instead of a Passat CC?

Yes.

One of VW's stylists must be an elephant, because the Passat CC looks like a Passat that an elephant has sat on. For that matter, the Scirocco has the look of having been sat on by an elephant as well.

beachland2 2 June 2010

Re: Saab 9-5 2.8T XWD Aero

Peanus wrote:
I would say that a 'Diesel' version of this car with a 3.0D or equivalent would give equally the same power with twice the MPG & probably torque.

The list price would be many thousands more, making it uneconomic to consider.

And of course its a diesel, which makes it illegal in my mind. Toxic emissions.

Paul123 2 June 2010

Re: Saab 9-5 2.8T XWD Aero

Chips wrote:
Would you really want this Saab instead of a Passat CC?

Yes.

Find an Autocar car review