The only button on the climate control panel pictured below from which the coating has worn away tells a much larger story than its small size would suggest.
It's merely a single fan-speed-down button, but to me it represents ground zero in a much wider conflict.
There is a reason for the overwhelming number of pushes it has received over the past 23 years and, as you might imagine, it's an annoying one.
The car is an Audi A2 (my own 2004 diesel), a small car with automatic climate control. Swish. If you set the temperature you desire and push the 'auto' button, the fan speed looks after itself until the interior temperature matches the one requested.

For some drivers, that setting will be fine, but not everybody wants it that way. In summer, there are those who want chilled air lightly breezed into a cabin otherwise basking in warmth.
Then there are drivers and I'm one of them who in winter like very hot air drawn into the cabin, but only softly. Then there are people who just don't like a lot of fan noise. I'm one of those too.
And for drivers who want hot or cold temperatures matched with low fan speeds, there are manual override controls.
The system has buttons for temperature, fan speed and air distribution. Those for the temperature and distribution do as they're told. Alas, those for the fan speed do not, with the insistence of a badly trained dog continually pulling at a lead.
If a driver sets the fan speed low (to, say, one or two bars on the scale), after a few moments the fan will increase speed of its own accord, setting itself to three, then four or the exact point that the noise starts to become irritating.
So, as evidenced by the wear on the button, the driver pushes the down fan switch until the fan is back at the desired speed.
And another minute or two after it has been reined back in, off it wanders again, searching for something to sniff at, continually having to be dragged back to heel. So it goes on and on, driver infuriated, button worn.


Join the debate
Add your comment
Matt is so right. Every time I hire a car (3-5 times a year), I have to spend more time switching off more functionality than ever before. Some manufacturers are learning this and have created a memory function, so at the press of a button you can get back to the settings last memorised. Sadly this is usually half hidden to avoid people knowing about it. I now always look for this. First time I came upon lane assist was in a Fiat 500 and it convinced me that it had a serious steering problem or maybe a flat front tyre, as it was continually fighting with me on a country road. Turns out the road was too narrow for it to function properly, so it decided to put my life in danger by fighting me for control of the car. Ford and VW at least do this better, as it doesn't fight you as hard for control, more a gentle nudge. Can we please have a button that switches all this shit off. Call it the "I can drive, I don't need a nanny" button. Some have even gone so far as to set off an alarm telling you, you are asleep if you look at the dash to see what damn alarm has gone off again. I think that was a Ford Puma issue with that feature. Shut up and let me concentrate on the road!
To be honest what's the big deal, in the colder months if the temperature goes below four degrees the car heats the seats till the car cabin is warm, no noise no fuss no noisy fans,and if you must there's a touch screen so you can choose where the hot/cold air comes from,simple, no ummimg and aaahing it just dies it instantly,the car brand? it's a BMW.
The fundamental problem is with the idea of intent.
I want a car where I can regulate the temperature of the air coming out of the vents. Car designers seem to want to remove that choice from me, instead aiming to meet a target temperature.
In my wife's Peugeot 5008, the cabin temp sensors are next to each other (left/right) and in a roof console that gets hot in the sun. If you set different target temps for driver and passenger, the system inevitably settles on the lowest - how could it not do so, when the sensors are separate be mere inches? And if the sun comes out? We all freeze!
It is madness. Just give me my old classic Saab 900s or Mercedes W124s with bulletproof, manual temperature controls!