From £10,4905
In an urban environment, the Smart Forfour Brabus has some appeal. However, on the open road, you soon learn that it's no hot hatchback

Our Verdict

Smart Forfour

Smart aims to stamp some Mercedes-Benz hallmarks on the city car class

  • First Drive

    Smart Forfour Brabus Xclusive 2017 review

    In an urban environment, the Smart Forfour Brabus has some appeal. However, on the open road, you soon learn that it's no hot hatchback
  • First Drive

    Smart Forfour Electric Drive 2017 review

    First electric five-door Smart has a limited range and a high price, but it’s the best EV offering from the brand and could be a great green city car option for

What is it?

Do you remember the first generation Smart Forfour Brabus? It was launched back in 2005 and was the fastest ever production Smart thanks to a 1.5-litre four pot that ran sufficient boost to generate 174bhp – enough for some rampant torque steer.

After a long hiatus, the Fourfour Brabus is back. Unlike its front-drive predecessor, this is rear engine and rear drive like every other Smart. Its 898cc three-pot kicks out 108bhp and drives exclusively through a six-speed dual clutch automatic ‘box.

If that sounds familiar, that’s because it’s the same mechanical makeup that underpins the Renault Twingo GT. No surprise as the cars were developed together and are built in the same factory in Slovenia. Can the Brabus impress more than the underwhelming Renault?

What's it like?

The Fourfor Brabus may be a tiny car - it’s shorter than a VW Up - but it tips the scales at nearly 1100kg, a good chunk more than the Fortwo. That means performance that’s fairly tepid. The 0-62mph dash takes 10.5sec which is more than half a second longer than the turbocharged Up. That said, it’s enough for it to feel nippy around town, and it does make a fruity rasp from its twin tailpipes. Indeed, it’s well suited to city life thanks to the narrow body and hilariously small turning circle that allows you to pull u-turns in all but the tightest of streets.

That may sound great, but the chunky alloy wheels don’t do the ride any favours at all. Go down a typical potholed UK road and you’ll find yourself jostled this way and that, a sensation that’s amplified by the lofty driving position. The ride does calm down at higher speeds, but you then face another issue – crosswinds. With a gust, you’ll find yourself having to make plenty of minor corrections even with the ESC nipping brakes to try and keep you on the straight and narrow on the motorway. This becomes tiresome very quickly.

So what about cornering? There’s certainly a lot of mechanical grip, enough to surprise plenty of lower-slung machinery. It also feels a lot more stable than the Forfour while still diving into turns thanks to quick steering. You don’t have to push too hard to find the ESC cutting in aggressively to stop it getting too out of shape, though.

Throw in plenty of body lean and steering that isn’t particularly communicative, and you’ve got a car that isn’t really that enjoyable to drive quickly. The gearbox doesn’t help, either: it may be a huge step on from the old automated manual, but shifts still feel ponderous and it’s easy to confuse it. 

As this is an Xclusive model, you get leather seats, a leather-look dashboard topper, a 7.0in infotainment system with sat nav and a DAB radio, a reversing camera plus auto lights and wipers. That sounds generous until you realise that this is £15 shy of £20,000. I’ll repeat that. Twenty thousand pounds.

That brings us to the Smart’s biggest issue. For that money you could get a proper hot hatch such as a Ford Fiesta ST. If you want something a bit more premium, a Mini Cooper 5-door is cheaper and still loads faster than the Smart. It’s not like it feels that plush inside, either. There may be the aforementioned leathery bits, but there’s also lots of hard plastic and an infotainment system that looks like it’s been lifted straight out of a Renault. Probably because it has.

Should I buy one?

As you may have guessed by now, we can think of much better ways to spend the asking price of the Smart Forfour Brabus. Even if you avoid the luxuries of Xclusive trim, you’re still spending around £17,000.

At the end of the day, if you’re after a hot hatch, there are much better alternatives out there. If you really do want the Smart, then save yourself several thousand pounds and buy the Renault Twingo GT instead. True, it's also a distinctly average driver's car, but at least you’re not wasting quite so much money.

2017 Smart Forfour Brabus Xclusive

Location West Sussex; On sale Now; Price £19,985; Engine 3cyl, 898cc, turbocharged, petrol; Power 108bhp at 5750rpm Torque 125lb ft at 2000rpm; Gearbox Six-speed dual-clutch automatic; Kerb weight 1095kg; 0-62mph 10.5secs; Top speed 96mph (limited); Economy 61.4mpg CO2/tax band 104g/km, 17%; Rivals Renault Twingo GT, Mini Cooper 5-Door 1.5T

Join the debate

Comments
4

24 February 2017
Stupidly overpriced does nothing more than,a Twingo GT does for £6K less,the Smart and Brabus badge isn't worth that. At best a cynical marketing exercise,why any keen driver would buy one is beyond belief

24 February 2017
Couldn't agree more. What a way to blow £20K! As the reviewer says, MINI Cooper or Fiesta ST would be an infinitely better bet at this budget. It's sometimes said that there aren't any truly bad cars made anymore, but this comes close, nor least for the sheer cynicism of its manufacturer in bringing such an inept car to market.

25 February 2017
What does Brabus think it can offer that Mercedes and Mercedes-AMG cannot?

25 February 2017
An exclusively silly car, but exclusivity sells, exclusively.

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Lexus LC500
    Car review
    20 October 2017
    Futuristic Lexus LC coupé mixes the latest technology with an old-school atmospheric V8
  • Maserati Levante S GranSport
    First Drive
    20 October 2017
    Get ready to trade in your diesels: Maserati’s luxury SUV finally gets the engine it’s always needed
  • Jaguar XF Sportbrake TDV6
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    The handsome Jaguar XF Sportbrake exhibits all the hallmarks that makes the saloon great, and with the silky smooth diesel V6 makes it a compelling choice
  • Volkswagen T-Roc TDI
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    Volkswagen's new compact crossover has the looks, the engineering and the build quality to be a resounding success, but not with this diesel engine
  • BMW M550i
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    The all-paw M550i is a fast, effortless mile-muncher, but there's a reason why it won't be sold in the UK