It is not enough for a car to be the best in its class to earn a five star verdict. Five stars are reserved for cars that don’t so much head their class as transcend them.

This is what the Porsche Boxster does. For anyone who cares at all about driving, it is so far ahead of any accepted rival that to choose another over it on these grounds alone would be little less than perverse.

Nic Cackett

Road tester
Everything a classy sports roadster ought to be, albeit at a price

Yes it’s quite expensive to buy and can rapidly become far more expensive still if you’re trigger happy with the options but given the experience it provides, the build quality, the likely residual value and the way your heart leaps every time you see it, it’s hard not to see the value in the thing.

So the only difficult decision is whether to go for the standard car or spend the extra on the Boxster S. Normally we incline towards a less is more approach, but here we feel the S has just enough of an edge to justify its price.

But that particular question is one where there’s no such thing as a wrong answer.

Indeed, deliberating over which new Porsche Boxster to park outside your house is about as nice a problem as it is possible to have.

Top 5 Sports roadsters

  • The Boxster is the cheapest Porsche you can buy

    Porsche Boxster

    1
  • The BMW Z4 has more comfort and added practicality, but has it gone soft?

    BMW Z4

    2
  • Evolutionary looks shroud new underpinnings. Is it a good mix?

    Mercedes-Benz SLK

    3
  • Mazda MX-5
    Mazda's MX-5 has been established for decades as an affordable and enjoyable rear-drive convertible

    Mazda MX-5

    4
  • The 370Z has the pace, looks, kit, value and charm, so what’s the catch?

    Nissan 370Z

    5

Find an Autocar car review

Explore the Porsche range

Driven this week

  • Car review
    26 February 2015
    Flagship performance C-Class is more than ever a true rival for BMW's M3, and impresses with both its breadth of ability and its practicality
  • First Drive
    26 February 2015
    The new Renault Megane GT 220 is essentially a toned-down version of the hallowed Renaultsport 275, but does it have the required DNA?
  • First Drive
    20 February 2015
    Remember Mercedes' 6x6 monster off-roader? Well, this is the 4x4 version, and we've driven it.
  • First Drive
    20 February 2015
    Insignia gets new 'Whisper' 2.0-litre diesel, which promises better refinement and company car-friendly figures
  • First Drive
    20 February 2015
    Honda's quirky hatchback gets styling and equipment tweaks for 2015, as well as this new Sport trim