Despite being a two seat, mid-engined Porsche, not even the Boxster S, let alone the standard Boxster, sets its stall out based on flat out performance. Even the fastest accelerating of the lot – an S with PDK and launch control – won’t crack 5sec to 62mph. There’s an Audi TT RS Roadster that’ll do it in 4.2sec.

But unless you’re one of those types with an unusual penchant for bar room banter, this should not affect your feelings towards the car. For Boxster drivers, the thrill comes in the way that performance is delivered.

Mark Tisshaw

Deputy editor
The S is notably more flexible than the standard model

Both the Boxster and Boxster S engines are among the smoothest of any kind in any car in the world and your enjoyment can begin in any gear at any speed.

But where the standard engine is sweet throughout the rev range, it’s only really strong past its 4000rpm torque peak, whereafter it’ll run for its red line like a starving man after a meat pie.

By contrast the S does that almost regardless of revs, so you notice the additional flexibility in performance even more than the performance itself. That old adage about there being no replacement for displacement is alive, well and living under the Boxster’s engine cover.

Your choice of transmission is easy. We like and admire the PDK auto, enough for it to be the gearbox au choix were this a test of the 911. But the manual option in the 911 is a seven speed manual which is actually too much of a good thing.

The six speed manual Boxster gearbox, is by contrast a complete peach with perfectly judged ratios and the best change quality in the business. It also happens to suit the roadster’s more recreational character.

Top 5 Sports roadsters

  • The Boxster is the cheapest Porsche you can buy

    Porsche Boxster

    1
  • The BMW Z4 has more comfort and added practicality, but has it gone soft?

    BMW Z4

    2
  • Evolutionary looks shroud new underpinnings. Is it a good mix?

    Mercedes-Benz SLK

    3
  • Mazda MX-5
    Mazda's MX-5 has been established for decades as an affordable and enjoyable rear-drive convertible

    Mazda MX-5

    4
  • The 370Z has the pace, looks, kit, value and charm, so what’s the catch?

    Nissan 370Z

    5

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • First Drive
    24 April 2015
    Space and practicality has never been an issue for the Seat Leon ST, and thanks to a Cupra 280 engine it's now fast, too - but does it gel as a package?
  • First Drive
    24 April 2015
    Ariel's third model is the best yet - in fact, it's one of the best driving experiences we've ever had
  • Car review
    23 April 2015
    Mazda's Skyactiv tech revolution transforms its cheapest model
  • The new Espace is a seven seater and described by the company as a 'crossover'.
    First Drive
    23 April 2015
    Renault replaces its classic flagship MPV with a new take on the seven-seat utility vehicle, but it's not for sale in the UK
  • First Drive
    23 April 2015
    You won't find another premium, all-wheel-drive, seven-seat compact MPV like BMW's xDrive 2 Series Gran Tourer, but is there a reason for that?