Nic Cackett
10 March 2012

What is it?

We could hardly be more besotted with the new Porsche Boxster S, a car we’ve already described as one of the world’s most exciting - now it’s time to find out if the smaller-engined, entry-level version deserves the same high regard.

The original Boxster was criticised by some for only producing 204bhp when its water-cooled 2.5-litre flat-six was revealed nestling behind the seats in 1996. Cut to sixteen years later, and Porsche has extracted 261bhp from a downsized 2.7-litre lump directly derived from the 3.4-litre engine found in the S model.

Detailed improvements, including revised pistons, adjusted variable valve timing and a flow-optimised air intake system, combine to produce 10bhp more than the previous 2.9-litre Boxster at slightly higher revs (6700rpm compared to 6400rpm).

Peak torque is also delivered over a broader range - appearing marginally later but staying on song until 6500rpm - even if at 206ft lb it has suffered a negligible 8lb ft decrease over its predecessor.

In return for that modest penalty, Porsche’s return customers can expect to see a marked improvement in efficiency. Thanks to better cooling, automatic stop-start across the range and intelligent battery charging, the standard Boxster’s combined economy improves to 34.5mpg (from 30mpg) with the standard six-speed manual and 36.7mpg with the optional seven-speed PDK driven here.

More impressive is the 29g/km drop in CO2 emissons (34g/km with the auto) which sees the Boxster fall below the 200g/km threshold, and in the PDK’s case, tumble two VED bands in a single stroke.

What’s it like?

It’s not unusual for the less powerful derivatives of performance cars to edge their brawnier counterparts in the satisfaction stakes, if only because more of their potential pace can be wrung out on the road (rather than left frustratingly unused in the box).

There is an element of that sentiment in the standard Boxster. The car is barely any lighter than the S, but it feels a little leaner and revs with almost the same howling enthusiasm. However, Porsche’s immaculate fettling underneath has produced a car of such masterful ability that the 2.7-litre’s lower output barely seems to scratch the dynamic surface.

On the sun-bleached smooth roads of the south of France, the Boxster’s chokehold lateral grip and grasping traction (complimented by the optional mechanical rear differential) mean the roadster feels like it could cope with more power than even the S sends to the back wheels.

Which isn’t to suggest that the cheaper car is by any means a disappointment. It isn’t. Even without the endearing final punch of the 3.4-litre engine’s higher yield, the Boxster bristles with flat-six brio. An absence of torque beneath 4500rpm is palpable in the PDK’s willingness to kick down three gears even in its gentlest mode, but keep the 2.7-litre motor spinning near its 6700rpm peak and it answers the throttle with an assertive yowl.

Opt to include the Sport Chrono Package and the Boxster gets a Sport Plus button that activates a ‘racing track’ shift strategy on the PDK, yielding 5.5 second to 62mph performance. At the opposite end of the scale, the ability to remap the engine (and gearbox’s) responses via the push of a button is part of what makes the Boxster’s improved economy possible - and while the default setup lacks the whip-crack riposte of the thirstier alternatives, its easy-to-live-with congeniality underlines the roadster’s continuing appeal as a use-everyday machine.

Should I buy one?

Of course you should. But if electrifying performance is your main criteria for buying a Boxster it would probably be wise to invest the extra money in the S model. Porsche’s uncanny ability to engineer quantifiable gaps between its variants means the more expensive car retains a tangible edge over its sibling.

However, if flat out pace is less of a concern than, say, running costs or any of the other fine features that make the new Boxster a superb ownership prospect, the standard car is a more than worthy entry to the range. Like the S, it’s ride, refinement, enhanced appearance and dazzling chassis make it easily the finest roadster within the reach of modest money.

Porsche Boxster 2.7

Price: £37,589; Top speed: 163mph; 0-62mph: 5.5 secs; Economy: 36.7mpg; CO2: 180g/km; Kerb weight: 1340kg; Engine: Horizontally-opposed six-cylinder, 2706cc petrol; Power: 261bhp; Torque: 206lb ft; Gearbox: 7-speed dual-clutch

Join the debate

Comments
36

Re: Porsche Boxster 2.7

2 years 18 weeks ago

Excellent another Porsche review

 

Hydrogen cars just went POP

Re: Porsche Boxster 2.7

2 years 18 weeks ago

Still the best roadster available for an acceptable price, best looking too, outdone, though not outclassed, by the cheaper to own Mazda MX5.

Re: Porsche Boxster 2.7

2 years 18 weeks ago

I'd have the 2.7 over the 3.4, but I'd want a manual 'box. The Boxster is a precision tool, so excessive power is unnecessary. In fact, an engine with about 200bhp would be fine. Whilst it is a very good car, my money would go elsewhere.

Re: Porsche Boxster 2.7

2 years 18 weeks ago

Fidji wrote:
my money would go elsewhere.
How can you say that, Fidji? Queen Vicky told you this was the best car available, just so long as you weren't senile. In a strange way I do miss her. However I reserve the right to change my mind, if it turns out it was a bloke all along.

Re: Porsche Boxster 2.7

2 years 18 weeks ago

newdevonian wrote:
How can you say that, Fidji? Queen Vicky told you this was the best car available, just so long as you weren't senile.

I bet he (I mean 'she') is reading this and is desperate to stick his ore in. I like reading opinions different to my own, but not when they resort to insults and accusations. That's why I like the majority of posters on these forums.

newdevonian wrote:
In a strange way I do miss her.

I don't.

Re: Porsche Boxster 2.7

2 years 18 weeks ago

I'd love to own a lot of things in life, my own house for instance,and possibly a chimpanzee, but I'd really love to own and keep one of these for a long time.

Re: Porsche Boxster 2.7

2 years 18 weeks ago

Los Angeles wrote:
outdone, though not outclassed, by the cheaper to own Mazda MX5
Yes I think that's a fair statement L.A. The mazda is 17k before discounts here, the Boxster 33.5k. Couple of older guys in my Community own MX5's and use them as 'beach cars'. Difficult to make a logical case for spending twice as much for the Porsche, but luckily we don't worry about that do we.

Re: Porsche Boxster 2.7

2 years 18 weeks ago

Err ... why have you used pictures of a Boxster S?

Re: Porsche Boxster 2.7

2 years 18 weeks ago

xxxx wrote:
Excellent another Porsche review
er, i think your syntax is all wrong, surely it should be 'another excellent porsche review' shouldn't it??!!

Re: Porsche Boxster 2.7

2 years 18 weeks ago

Could be also "Excellent, another Porsche review" :)

Please register or login to post a comment.

Our Verdict

Does bigger mean better for Porsche’s third-generation Boxster?

  • First Drive

    Porsche Boxster S

    The Porsche Boxster S is an astonishing car. Faster than ever but just as capable on the handling front.
  • First Drive

    Porsche Boxster E

    Remarkably complete and compelling to drive. The future for Porsche begins here

Driven this week

  • Audi A7 Ultra first drive review

    Audi A7 Ultra first drive review

    First drive
    23 July 2014 12:02am

    The appeal of the A7, which offers smart looks, refinement and luxury, has now been bolstered by the improved economy of a new Ultra version

  • Lexus NX

    Lexus NX

    Car review
    22 July 2014 7:57am

    An over-firm ride and a lack of driver engagement detract from the appeal of Lexus's rival to the BMW X3, Range Rover Evoque and Audi Q5

  • Infiniti Q50 Eau Rouge prototype first drive review

    Infiniti Q50 Eau Rouge prototype first drive review

    First drive
    21 July 2014

    The high-performance Q50 Eau Rouge is more than just a concept and previews what could be an incredible sports saloon

  • Lexus NX300h F Sport first drive review

    Lexus NX300h F Sport first drive review

    First drive
    21 July 2014

    The petrol-electric hybrid Lexus NX300h is a superior ownership proposition to the NX200t, but no better to drive

  • Fiat Panda Cross Twinair Turbo first drive review

    Fiat Panda Cross Twinair Turbo first drive review

    First drive
    21 July 2014

    New Panda Cross gets a range of off-road upgrades, resulting in an appealing proposition – but it comes at a price