Jim Holder
25 October 2012

What is it?

This is the Tesla Model S, the first bespoke creation from PayPal creator Elon Musk’s stable, which we tested in Germany, the first time we have driven the car in Europe. The car was production ready save for a couple of parts, such as rear headlights, which are still being prototyped for European homologation.

The 2106kg Tesla S’s body structure is aluminium, with steel used only to add strength in key areas. Tesla says the resultant stiffness has allowed it to bestow the car with good dynamics despite its size and weight (over two tonnes) and even on 21-inch wheels.

The car sits on double wishbone front and multi-link rear suspension. Our test car – as with all Tesla S models except the entry-level version – sat on air suspension.

Tesla also makes the case for aluminium’s increased strength in the event of an accident, a claim it backs up with eight standard air bags and a frontal crash structure it says has far more effective crumple zones than in a ‘standard’ car, simply because there is no engine to consider.

The company says it has wilfully made the Tesla S look like a conventional car, to the extent of fitting a dummy radiator grille, so as not to scare off customers wary of buying an electric vehicle.

The batteries – developed by Pioneer and also used by Toyota and Mercedes - sit under the floor of the car, running the length of the space between the axles in a 10cm deep stack, keeping the centre of gravity low, while the electric motor sits on the rear axle. Weight distribution is claimed to be 48%/52% front/rear.

Tesla has already taken 13,000 deposits for the S and is planning to sell 20,000 cars a year from 2013. It will go on sale in the UK next autumn.

What is it like?

Approach the Model S and the first thing you get is a touch of theatre: pop the key blipper and the door handles pop from their flush housings. Inside, the cabin is dominated by a giant, iPad-like touchscreen, which stretches 43cm down the centre console and dominates the cabin, controlling everything from the air conditioning to the Google Earth powered sat-nav. It’s a futuristic high spot of an otherwise conventional premium cabin, which unashamedly uses switchgear straight from Tesla partner Mercedes and its parts bin. 

On the move you quickly feel that the Tesla Model S is a big car. At 4978mm long, 1964mm wide and 1435 in height, it is longer, wider and lower than all of its most obvious opposition, such as the BMW 5-series, Mercedes E-class and Audi A7. For instance, that’s 79mm longer than a 5-series, 164mm wider and 29mm lower.

This has its benefits – the car is a true five-seater, and can be extended out to be a seven-seater with the addition of rear jump seats, and there is generous front and rear boot storage, totalling 895 litres. That compares to the 5-series’ 520 litres.

But there is also a downside. The width, in particular, takes some getting used to. While open roads present few problems, it does make town driving a nervy experience, at least while you adapt to the dimensions. 

Acceleration in this Signature Performance trim level is as shocking as you’d expect from a car that produces 443lb ft of torque from a standstill, and peak power of 416bhp. Sure, the car’s two tonne plus weight holds it back off the line, but there’s no arguing with the sensations of a 4.4sec sprint to 62mph, or the pace with which it reaches its limited top speed of 130mph. All the way, there’s just a slight bustle of tyre and wind noise.

It is also more supple and agile than its stats suggest, the 21-inch wheels and low profile tyres proving a surprisingly decent ride on the mixture of roads we tested on. Down a twisty road you can always feel the weight, but the low down battery pack does noticeably help the centre of gravity. The steering can be switched between three settings – comfort, normal and sport, predictably – at the switch of a button, changing input weights but never really delivering much feel.

 

Should I buy one?

It’s hard to say for sure, as Tesla won’t give any clues to European or UK pricing, but the Tesla S certainly delivers a highly credible steer, a large, hushed premium cabin and massive load space with a nicely futuristic touch. It has the makings of a decent alternative for the class, then.

As ever, though, for many the stumbling block will be charge times and range. Tesla will eventually sell the S with three battery pack capacities: 85kWh, 65kWh and 40kWh, but at present only the largest is available. Range is rated at an impressive 300 miles, with each hour of charge from a standard socket delivering 65 miles of range. That gives the Tesla S the longest range of any pure electric car we’ve tested.

Enough to convince buyers? Maybe, maybe not, but the Tesla S certainly stands as perhaps the most credible electric car we’ve tested so far.

Tesla Model S Signature Performance

Price £50,000-£90,000 (est); 0-62mph 4.4sec; Top speed 130mph (limited); Economy 300-mile range claimed; CO2 0 (at tailpipe); Kerbweight 2106kg; Engine three phase, four pole AC induction motor; Instillation rear, transverse; Power 416bhp at 5000-8600rpm; Torque 443lb ft at 0-5100rpm; Gearbox 1-speed auto

Join the debate

Comments
35

Vs Fisker Karma?

30 weeks 1 day ago

Wow, it sounds pretty amazing.  Roll on the twin test against the Fisker Karma.  Both are too big externally but this thing seems to have far more room inside.  I'd like to see the two jump seats in the boot in action.  Is there really space for humans??

While fully aware of all the limitations of electric cars (& why have they installed a vast power-consumptive LCD screen in the dashboard?), I can't help but get excited about something as Buck Rogers as this.

looks like an updated XJ?

30 weeks 1 day ago

This Tesla has clearly had a huge amount of money invested in it.

This is a high quality car with an updated Jaguar XJ look about it's body shape.

The interior is stunning and that huge screen on the dash will be copied by other makes in due course.

The rear bench seat looks a bit flat but the storage space is amazing.

I look forward to a full Autocar test as I am always dubious about the range that electric car manufacturers make. 

But how much will this car cost as I see a huge amount of tech here and the bills that have already been run up need to be paid, I'll go in at £95.000 as my guess?

A very interesting automobile in the current market place and so other manufacturers will no doubt be watching this very closely. 

 

 

It sounds all very promising.

30 weeks 1 day ago

It sounds all very promising. I suspect it won't redefine the class best when reviewed in GB, but hope this will add to the ground swell of interesting stuff that will over time allow us to keep enjoying cars in light of future legislation. A good thing.

I agree with @Tom Chet though, that dimensions sound a little intimidating for urban driving.

Surely there is something

30 weeks 1 day ago

Surely there is something amiss from this test ..... how far did you drive before it conked out?  With the amount of driving done in even a first drive review you would flatten the battery of a Leaf or other standard EV.  With this Tesla having the 300 mile range (hmmmm) where was the comment about say .... we drove it 100 miles and the range meter read 3 miles when we were expecting 200 ... for example.

I know it matters how it

30 weeks 1 day ago

I know it matters how it drive, how it looks, how well built it is, but its an electric car, so above all the one thing that matters most is its range. I dont mean the claimed range, but the actual range.

If the claim is 300, will it do 200? Is that enough? I know its far more likely to be usable compared to the Leaf which cant manage 100 miles.

Then of course there is battery life, not something that can be tested in a roadtest, but a real worry with all electric cars.

Finally width. A car over 6 inches wider than the 5 series is too wide. certainly too wide for the UK

A Car For The BIG Country ...

30 weeks 1 day ago

It looks good, but it's size alone makes it a complete non-starter for UK roads ... It may well have "BMW M5 troubling pace", but I can't see BMW being remotely troubled elsewhere ...

What this country needs are more reasonably priced and sized electric cars or hybrids like the Toyota Yaris ...

Something doesn't quite add up!

30 weeks 1 day ago

The Tesla model S is about 200kg heavier than a BMW M5 and it's down about 140bhp and 70lf ft down on the M5 too, but curiously it claims the exact same 0-60 time as the M5!

How does the Tesla manage to be this quick? Is it due to the electric motor and the 1-speed transmission or is this just a dubious claim?

 

@ Overdrive

30 weeks 1 day ago

That's one of the quoted positives of an electic motor it's peak torque is instant and you don't need gears.  I suppose to really understand you would need to compare torque and power curvers.  I don't think comparing maximums helps here.

What a cabin. Simple as that.

30 weeks 1 day ago

What a cabin. Simple as that. The whole car looks how maserati's quattroporte should look. And it throws the glove for luxury space and efficiency to every other car maker. Now that is a game changer. What Peter Griffin said in the yatsse game naked when he won? IN YOUR FACE!

Impressive

30 weeks 1 day ago

effort from a none mainstream car company!

Please register or login to post a comment.

Our Verdict

Is the Tesla Roadster a short-lived novelty or the future of performance motoring?

Driven this week

  • Citroën C1 Connexion first drive review

    Citroën C1 Connexion first drive review

    First drive
    24 May 2013

    Facebook makes a car that won't appeal to all tastes in the way it looks or drives

  • Lexus IS

    Lexus IS

    Car review
    23 May 2013

    Do Mercedes and BMW need to be worried by the third-generation Lexus IS luxury saloon?

  • Kia Carens 1.6 GDi 1 first drive review

    Kia Carens 1.6 GDi 1 first drive review

    First drive
    23 May 2013

    We test Kia's latest MPV contender, equipped with a petrol engine and in entry-level trim

  • Ford Fiesta ST

    Ford Fiesta ST

    Car review
    22 May 2013

    The popular hatchback gets the hot ‘ST’ treatment

  • Lexus IS300h first drive review

    Lexus IS300h F Sport first drive review

    First drive
    21 May 2013

    Hybrid version of third-gen Lexus IS has predictable strengths, but it’s too devoted to calmness and efficiency to really enjoy driving