The STI’s powertrain will feel immediately familiar to anyone who’s driven a highly strung Impreza: big on traction and robust and substantial through the gearlever and clutch pedal but not exactly straightforward to interact with.

Given the work put in to overhaul it, the new gear linkage should be slicker. As it is, it feels notchy and ponderous. But it’s only one constituent part of an engine and transmission combination that’s a bit of a monster: potent, sure – but demanding to use and generally unwilling to yield to your efforts to bring it to heel.

Matt Saunders

Deputy road test editor
Subaru's engine gets a new ECU and bigger intercooler in the STI

Subaru’s turbocharged flat four might as well be a 1980s turbocharged F1 engine, given how peaky it feels compared with an equivalent modern turbocharged in-line engine.

Bury the pedal with less than 3000rpm showing and embarrassingly little happens; there’s a fair bit of turbo lag to push through, followed by a separate wait for the crankshaft to spin fast enough for the turbo boost to peak.

At 3500rpm the car begins to pick up; at 4000rpm it’s finally hauling. But that only gives you a 2500rpm sweet spot in which to aim to keep the crankshaft spinning in order to keep the car surging on.

Doing that means concentrating and timing your shifts with careful precision. And there will be lots of shifts, so short are the STI’s intermediate gear ratios.

That’s certainly an engrossing process, and we wouldn’t argue that the STI isn’t an involving drive. It’s characterful, too; seldom do you find modern performance cars in which you can feel the turbo boost building so vividly.

But if all of that sounds like we’re making excuses for the car, it’s because we are. Frankly, in this era of direct fuel injection and variable-geometry turbos, a £30,000 performance saloon should be more flexible, more responsive and just plain easier to drive quickly.

If the STI were all of those things, it would probably have broken the 5.0sec-to-60mph barrier – which is all it needed to do in order to be competitive with its current rivals. Instead, it languishes at least half a second off the required pace.

Top 5 Hot hatches

  • The Trophy-R is a track-focused 271bhp front-drive hot hatchback

    Renault Mégane RS 275 Trophy-R

    1
  • Volkswagen Golf R
    The new Golf R is faster than any production Volkswagen before it

    Volkswagen Golf R

    2
  • This four-cylinder Focus feels lighter at the front than its five-pot predecessor

    Ford Focus ST

    3
  • Seat Leon Cupra
    The new Leon Cupra is offered with a choice of 261bhp or 276bhp 2.0-litre turbocharged petrol engines

    Seat Leon Cupra

    4
  • Mercedes-Benz A45 AMG
    The Mercedes-Benz A45 AMG features a 355bhp turbocharged engine

    Mercedes-Benz A45 AMG

    5

Find an Autocar car review

Explore the Subaru range

Driven this week

  • Car review
    6 July 2015
    Ariel's third model takes the all-terrain car to another level. It's one of the best driving experiences we've ever had
  • First Drive
    3 July 2015
    Charming four-door city car gets Smart's new six-speed dual-clutch automatic gearbox, in a bid to make the Forfour more versatile
  • First Drive
    2 July 2015
    First UK drive in the latest-generation MX-5 reveals an iconic roadster that's back to its best
  • First Drive
    2 July 2015
    Extra firepower and pared-down kerb weight conjure even greater brilliance from the Boxster's chassis. Pricey – but superb to drive
  • BMW's prototype fuel cell concept is based on the 5GT
    First Drive
    1 July 2015
    Fuel cell-powered 5 Series GT concept previews a revolutionary storage and refuelling system which could pave the way for hydrogen to become the alternative fuel of choice