Our latest ride in Porsche's new SUV shows a snappy, agile car with plenty of comfort and refinement
11 December 2013

In recent times it’s not been unusual for Porsche to use a platform shared with the greater VW Group. The hugely successful Cayenne (which now accounts for around half of all Porsche sales) is based on the same architecture as the Volkswagen Touareg.

That architecture, however, is natively rear-wheel drive, with all the inherent dynamic and weight distribution advantages of having most of the engine’s torque sent rearwards and having the engine being mounted far back in the nose.

With the arrival of the Macan SUV, Porsche has adopted an Audi platform, which means a longitudinally mounted engine sitting ahead of the front axle line. Despite a couple of decades of massaging this unique layout, it is not an ideal starting point for a vehicle that Porsche insists on calling a ‘sports car’.

The Macan may be the sister car to the Audi Q5, but that does not mean it is a clone: Porsche says some ‘two thirds’ of the car’s components have been ‘replaced or modified’. Autocar understands that the Macan shares a floor and crash structure with the Q5, as well as the lower half of the door structures.

The front and rear suspension set-ups are also basically the same, though Porsche has re-tuned the springs, dampers, anti-roll bars and added quicker steering and its own six-pot monobloc brakes at the front. In terms of the running gear – aside from the option of air suspension, which the Q5 doesn’t get – the biggest change is the addition of Porsche’s own 7-speed PDK transmission.

This is natively a rear-wheel drive set-up and sends 80 per cent of the engine’s torque rearwards in normal driving conditions. This re-biasing of the drivetrain has necessitated a new, stronger, final drive unit on the rear axle.

What Porsche calls the ‘hang on’ four-wheel drive system – a propshaft which takes power from the rear end of the transmission and sends it forwards to the front wheels – can send 100 per cent of torque to the front wheels if the rear wheels have no traction.

The Macan is also marked out by a lower driving position than the Audi. The seat mounting has been modified, as have the mounts for the steering column, to allow the wheel to be mounted in a, flatter, ‘more 911-like’ position.

Porsche’s now-familiar interior design has also been plumbed into the car along with rather shapely sports seats. The upshot, for the driver, is that when sitting in the Macan you will never guess that there are the bare bones of an Audi Q5 under the carpet.

Porsche’s engineers say that the aim with the Macan was to provide the sharpest steering, snappiest acceleration and shift action and deliver the best all-round responsiveness of any SUV of this size.

Despite being the smaller sister to the Cayenne, the Macan is not as capacious as you might expect. The cockpit is satisfyingly snug (mainly thanks to the vast centre console) and beautifully made, but the rear package is tighter, with knee and headroom only just adequate for a six-footer. The boot is also on the smaller side because of a high floor and the steeply sloping tailgate.

A few laps of a test track and a short burst of off-roading in the front seat of the £43,300 Macan Diesel S (which has a 254bhp 3.0-litre V6 diesel engine good for 46.3mpg and 0-62mph in 6.3sec) was enough to test Porsche’s central claim of class-leading responsiveness.

This ex-Panamera and Cayenne engine is impressively refined in the Macan and has substantial low to mid-range punch, enough to make the two, rather thirstier, petrol engines redundant. As Porsche’s test driver pushed the car hard around the circuit, it appears to be much less understeery (hardly washing out when driven hard into a tight bend) than the Q5 as well less obviously nose heavy (the Macan has a weight spilt of 53/47 front-rear).

On air suspension, this Macan also has quite decent capability on off-road tracks (the ride height rises by 40mm) as well as having hill descent control.

The Macan is obviously especially snappy and agile. It doesn’t look like a Q5 (the low nose has necessitated a clamshell bonnet and an engine air intake routing that snakes between the bonnet’s upper and lower skins on the way to the air filters), and the driver gets a properly Porsche cockpit. It also looks like it will be priced very competitively against the higher-end Audi Q5 models.

With Macan production initially capped at 50,000 per year, expect long waiting lists and impressive residual values.

Our Verdict

Porsche Macan

New 'junior Cayenne' promises to be the most sporting SUV yet

Join the debate

Comments
15

11 December 2013
Consistent with the 911 in placing the engine outside of the car's wheelbase?

11 December 2013
The tester commented on the diesel engine being refined which sounds a bit of a conflicting story as the same engine in the Cayenne was reported as being gruff so is it gruff or is it class leading ie refined.

11 December 2013
It is a diesel it will never be smooth or refined. It can be quiet with enough sound-proofing. It is consistent with the usual VW smoke and mirrors trick to get automotively ignorant buyers to buy yet another deeply average tarted up VW product at a hugely inflated price on the basis of a badge.

11 December 2013
As a petrol head that has loved his many cars over a 52 year period, I have been driving both Petrol & Diesel powered vehicles since I was 12. Currently sitting behind a 6 cylinder Petrol engined BMW and a 2.2ltr Honda Diesel & love the power delivery of both for varying journey types. Today I was driven for 600kms in a V10 Tdi Touareg cruising at 2,450 rpm at an effortless 94mph in Romania covering that distance in less than 5 hours. A whisper quiet journey in a vehicle with massive torque (750nm). Another recent journey across 3 countries in a Diesel Audi A5 was similarly unfussed at cruising speeds around 200kph. A true petrol head would not be dismissive of a variety of power trains - Horses for courses.

Malo Mori Quam Foedari

12 December 2013
If it were a choice between this and a q5, it'd be the Porsche every time. Tidy looking motor, love the rear

12 December 2013
An affordable little Porsche or an overpriced Volkswagen Tiguan? It just badge engineering,which makes a Porsche as charming as a Volkswagen.So I'd rather have a Volvo XC60.

12 December 2013
[quote=SJ19MB] An affordable little Porsche or an overpriced Volkswagen Tiguan? [/quote] Audi Q5 architecture has nothing to do with the Tiguan, completely different platform.


12 December 2013
I still don't think its something Porsche should be proud of.

12 December 2013
Interestingly the Honda 2.2 diesel was designed to be as like a petrol engine as possible but it still isn't smooth like a petrol engine because the combustion cycle of a diesel makes that impossible. Of course a V10 TDI engine will be quiet as there is a huge amount of sound proofing in a Touareg. Having owned a CLS 350CDI V6 diesel I am now back to a BMW straight six petrol because no matter how the CLS was driven it was noisy compared to a petrol six and the fuel economy was nowhere near the claimed figures. In a semi-agricultural vehicle such as an SUV diesel makes sense but it isn't smooth.

12 December 2013
Not a bad car although it may share some components with Skoda not to mention Audi. Overall not bad for showboating although it will have to contend with BMW's upcoming X4.

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week