Wed
Apr 01 2009

Is Britain Treasure Island?

Mike Duff
Remember ‘Rip-Off Britain?’ It’s not many years since the tabloids were filled with rabid headlines accusing British retailers – and especially car manufacturers – of profiteering on the back of prices that were substantially higher than elsewhere in Europe. The newspapers even coined a phrase for the way these profit-hungry multinationals saw the UK - ‘Treasure Island.’

In car prices, the differences were big enough to create a substantial market in ‘parallel imports’, right-hand drive cars sourced from abroad and imported for substantial savings. The number of middle-aged Vauxhalls you see wearing Opel badges is testament to how widespread the practice was.
But now the pound/euro exchange rate has slid to the other end of the scale, and we’ve suddenly got the cheapest cars in Europe.
 
Last week I blogged about Ford’s imminent price rises and I got contacted by an expat friend who lives in Germany and who – despite the price increase – is now seriously contemplating trying to source a left-hook Focus RS from Blighty.



His logic is simple enough. In Germany the Focus RS costs €33,900. Which, at current exchange rates, is about £31,300. Even after the £750 price increase takes effect today, a UK-sourced RS could be his for just £26,490. Even with the costs of getting it back to Germany and, in the worst case scenario, getting a right-hooker converted to full ‘TUV’ compliance, he’s looking at a four-grand saving.

The obvious point is that British prices are likely to rise further. But in the meantime maybe it’s time for some canny British dealers to cash-in and start ‘parallel importing’ back into the euro zone. It wouldn’t be too hard – send a few staff on language courses, put some adverts in the French, German and Italian press and entice some bargain-seeking continental punters to make the trip over here.

Technorati Tags: , ,

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About Mike Duff

Used to edit this website, but now back to reporting from the road - and contemplating which sub-£1000 1990s German executive to buy next

Comments

roadtester April 1, 2009 3:25 PM

Ford will just lose even more money if a significant reimport channel for its cars opens up between the UK and Germany.

If Ford wants to try charging 31 grand for a Focus in the UK, they can try. But they won't have many takers.

And the idea of importing an RHD into Germany to save four grand is completely nuts. The only significant pool of modern RHD cars in Germany is that owned by members of HM forces intending to return to the UK - and they can already buy RHDs locally or from the UK via dedicated channels tax-free.

I'd never buy an RHD outside that set-up with German TÜV, German insurance and so on because Germany is far less hospitable to RHDs than the UK is to LHDs - of which we have a surprisingly large number.

You could be looking at, for example, new right-dipping headlamps, a new instrument pack and rewiring the rear fog lamp from right to left (i.e. RHD offside to LHD offside) just for the TÜV.

Timberwolf April 1, 2009 3:34 PM

And yet, you try getting this through the mainstream press (and by association, much of the public) who are *still* running those exact same sentiments from nearly a decade ago without even bothering to do the slightest bit of research - such as five minutes with online configurators building a few cars of identical spec with the latest exchange rates to hand.

The Fop April 1, 2009 3:37 PM

No need for that worst case scenario - any UK dealer (of any brand) should be able to supply a LHD car ( I think legally they have to).  Cars here have never been cheaper - and like all good things, sooner or later it will come to an end...

horseandcart April 1, 2009 4:39 PM

the RHD thing will kill this. No one will facilitate this. The big story in Germany -  Roadtester back me up on this - is importing by dealers from weaker currency countries like Denmark undercutting markedly the German euro price.

Not to forget also that until next year there is a 4% difference in UK/Germany VAT rates. Once the election is over in UK, 2010 probably, it's suspected VAT will be raised to 21%, to start paying off some of the public sector wage bills.

Car prices in UK have only one way to go regardless of recession-level demand, up. The pound lost 30% against the euro but car prices have risen by only 5% or so. Compare that to say bicycle equipment. High-end stuff from Italy like Sidi shoes, or groupsets from Shimano Japan or wheelsets from Mavic France have gone up by a minimum half in the last 12 months. Terrifying. With the BoE printing money and inflation at 3% compared to eurozone 0.5% British pound is destined to be monopoly money in short order.

GaryW April 1, 2009 4:58 PM

horseandcart - you're right to say that the pound has fallen 30% and prices have only risen 5%...  However, when the pound rose to its peak, I don't remember car prices in this country falling!  So we're probably back where we started, if you get my drift.

230SL April 1, 2009 5:29 PM

The pound may have gone down but so have our wages and therefore our spending power, sorry to state the obvious.

horseandcart April 1, 2009 5:57 PM

@GaryW,

Gary, I see what you're saying but ultimately it's a case of ifs, buts and maybes. The current, plain fact is that Ford of Europe sets the Focus RS price, majority German designed, developed and built, at 34,000 euros, which means that with the pound more likely than less to approach parity with the euro Ford of Great Britain will be making next to nothing on each one sold at around £26K. If the car is such a hit they could simply divert more sales to Germany and other eurozone countries.

@230SL

- official stats show wages still growing healthily in UK, in relation to official cost of living  - www.statistics.gov.uk. In fact wage levels need to come down sharply. Latest productivity figures show unit wage costs in UK manufacturing rose 6% in the last three months. UK should - and will have to, unless the IMF is called in first - cut all public sector wages, especially the senior levels, to share the burden that the manufacturing sector is suffering.

roadtester April 1, 2009 6:23 PM

Yes, horse is right about Denmark. Grey imports into Germany come from a variety of countries depending on currency fluctuations but Denmark is tends to be a favourite because the exceptionally high VAT on cars there means that the car companies tend to pitch the Danish pre-tax price - which is the relevant one for reimports - at a lower level than most other places.

The Fop April 2, 2009 10:17 AM

"the RHD thing will kill this"....

It won't.  I'm sure they HAVE to supply LHD to anyone who asks.  As someone said previously, look at the the rhd Opels diriving around Blighty from a few years back.

Casanova April 2, 2009 10:56 AM

Just a word on wage statistics (although somewhat OT), I think that 6% is inflated by companies making redundancy payments.  Private sector wages are not rising in real terms - many companies have a pay freeze and quite a few have cut wages in deals to keep jobs.  Always got to be careful with statistics, especially government ones!

horseandcart April 2, 2009 11:34 AM

@Casanova

6% rise in unit wage costs, i.e. output divided by wage bill. Wages in manufacturing are stagnant or falling but output is falling faster.

'Overall manufacturing unit wage costs in the fourth quarter of 2008 grew by 6.8 per cent compared with the same quarter a year earlier' - www.statistics.gov.uk/.../nugget.asp

paulb77 April 2, 2009 12:07 PM

TheFop

I'd guess your RHD opels are from Ireland.

There is a large (relatively speaking...) import of british cars into ireland just now, privately, by small dealers and now by main dealers - BMW dealers importing nearly new from UK.

Not that too many are buying cars here

JKFR33 April 2, 2009 12:51 PM

I contacted a load of brokers in the UK to see if they could supply me a LHD car in the UK (I live on the Continent), but none were interested. Given the price differences involved, this amazed me. I'd be happy to pay UK list, even a little more, which would still represent a substantial saving for me - I assume at that price the brokers could make quite a tidy profit sourcing direct from the manufacturer. Mr. Duff is quite right, there is a lot of money to be made by doing this.

horseandcart April 2, 2009 1:26 PM

'I contacted a load of brokers in the UK to see if they could supply me a LHD car in the UK (I live on the Continent), but none were interested.'

- just what I thought. Let's not be naive here - instructions from manufacturers' national sales operations.

Peter Cavellini April 2, 2009 2:04 PM

Tell me Mike, do we really need "niche" cars?and if we do then please explain to me and countless others why?.Are car companys running out of ideas?,there hardly goes by a day when a new model is born and usually its a sports car or a supercar,premium cars are just that beyond most average families budget right now.Yes i think we still get a raw deal and pay over the odds for our pride and joy, anything thats imported costs about double it price in its home country,Corvettes in te states $50,000dollars here add about 25%.Get rid of "niche" cars and give us good,well priced cars, i bet the G20 don't suggest price parity across the union, what do you think?

The Fop April 3, 2009 9:43 AM

'I contacted a load of brokers in the UK to see if they could supply me a LHD car in the UK (I live on the Continent), but none were interested.'

Brokers are under no obligation and can't be bothered - manufacturers HAVE to do this.  I know of a dealer that got an approoach a few weeks ago from an expat for LHD.  Contacted the mfr. and was told normal delivery timescale, with a option price for LHD (I think it was about £500).  They sold the car...

hueymcp April 7, 2009 4:05 PM

Please come to Ireland and examine how over priced the cars are there, example:

BMW - Conv' Diesel 3.0 86,812 euros (ireland)

BMW - Conv' Diesel 3.0 £37,300 (United Kingdom)

Even with currency conversion this doesnt make sense as we are so over taxed. So RIP off Britain I think not - more like RIP off Irish Government....

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - cover 8.2.12

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>