From £56,605
Lexus's new M3-chaser feels quick, but isn't quite as entertaining or as horny-looking as its rivals

Our Verdict

Lexus IS-F 2008-2012

The Lexus IS-F is the marque's first attempt at a genuine performance car - and it's a competent M3 rival

  • First Drive

    Lexus IS-F

    The Lexus IS F moves closer to the BMW M3 thanks to a proper limited slip diff
  • First Drive

    Lexus IS-F

    Lexus's new M3-chaser feels quick, but isn't quite as entertaining or as horny-looking as its rivals
27 November 2007

What is it?

Meet Lexus's answer to the BMW M3. Like its German rival, the IS-F has had a V8 engine shoe-horned under its bonnet, although in this case one with 5.0-litres of displacement and with drive dispatched to the rear wheels via an extremely clever eight-speed gearbox.

Despite the extra capacity, the F's 417bhp is almost identical to that of the M3's higher-revving 4.0-litre motor, but it has far more torque to call on - 372lbft against the BMW's slightly anaemic 295lbft.

What's it like?

Pretty impressive. Indeed, if you were about to sign an order form for the new M3 it might be worth waiting three months to have a go in the IS-F.

The engine is a work of art, lacking much urgency at lower revs but waking up at around 2500rpm, and then pulling with increasing vigour to the 6600rpm at which peak power arrives.

Despite sharing an identical 4.8 second official 0-62 mph time with the M3, the IS-F feels subjectively quicker off the line, thanks in large part to an amazingly vocal V8 soundtrack.

The eight-speed transmission is a development of the system already fitted to the LS460, but with the ability to take direct control of gear selection via paddles behind the steering wheel, and with a lock-up clutch that can operate from second to eighth gears and dramatically reduce both shift time and the normal autobox feel of a slushy change between ratios. It's not perfect, sometimes getting confused when left in "Drive" and, even at its quickest, still not capable of matching the seamless shifting of a twin-clutch system. But it's vastly superior to the lunge-prone SMG system that BMW still foists on M5 and M6 buyers.

The rest of the driving experience sticks close to the M3 benchmark, too. The IS-F is undoubtedly the most dynamically focussed Lexus yet, with well sorted suspension and steering. At 90 percent commitment it's very impressive: agile, point-able and very grippy. Beyond that the front end washes out in anything except slow-speed corners, even with the stability control fully isolated. With the electronic nanny kennelled the IS-F can be persuaded into smoking its rear Michelins like a good 'un, but it's not as much of a hooligan as the eminently driftable M3.

The biggest disappointment is with the tame styling, though. Buyers get a new front bumper, some vents inset into the trailing edge of the front wheel arches and quad exhaust pipes as the rear, but it doesn't feel different enough from the lesser models in the range, especially when you consider its very serious £51,000 pricetag.

Should I buy one?

With near-identical performance and pricetag to the M3, the Lexus looks set to give the BMW a serious run. It's more practical than the (currently) coupe-only M3 and the transmission is better suited to everyday use. Now all we need is the UK arrival of the Mercedes C63 AMG and things will get really interesting.

Mike Duff

Join the debate

Comments
6

4 November 2007

I like Lexus, unassuming, quality, reliability, technologically advanced, dealer backup/service second to none, slightly left field to German offerings.

The IS-F seems slightly out of place with my view of Lexus, but I hope it succeeds. To gain credibility, they should enter a works backed team in the DTM series. With Toyota's backing they could bloody a few noses.

5 November 2007

[quote Vicky Parrott]But I can't bring myself to believe that Lexus will ever produce a car as focused as an M3 or RS4. It just seems to go against what I consider Lexus to be. Which is impeccably reliable, comfortable, and just a tiny bit dull (sorry Lexus). [/quote]

Agreed. I also think the rear exhaust configuration looks a bit daft. :-(

13 December 2007

[quote Vicky Parrott]But I can't bring myself to believe that Lexus will ever produce a car as focused as an M3 or RS4. It just seems to go against what I consider Lexus to be. Which is impeccably reliable, comfortable, and just a tiny bit dull (sorry Lexus). [/quote]

Images aren't everything, it seems. Some tests in the USA have proved the IS-F is capable of beating the competition. Car and Driver for example drove the IS-F with 71.6 mph through their '700-slalom', while the new M3 did 65.9 mph there.

The brakes seem to be a bit more supportive as well.

18 December 2007

Having owned a new Lexus IS, one can only be impressed by what Toyota has achieved with this car. But you're absolutely right that, despite excellent dealer service, superb build quality, and unimpeachable reliability, somehow Lexus still fails to hold a candle to Mercedes-Benz, BMW and Audi. The dynamics are flawed and the brand has no soul.

All that said, there was one aspect of Lexus that was extremely compelling: value. Compared to the Germans, most Lexus models are much cheaper. They come loaded with standard kit. I was rather hoping that the IS-F would offer the same advantage. If it were to be priced around the £42-£45K mark, it would make an extremely convincing case for itself. Selling the IS-F for the same money as a new M3 or C63 just doesn't make sense. It smacks of arrogance bordering on stupidity.

What I'm really saying is that while Lexus knows how to make decent cars, it knows nothing about marketing.

2 January 2008

errr last time l checked the DTM series is solely for German marques.

2 January 2008

That 51,000 price-tag is for the car 'ás tested'.

Does this mean it was a car fully packed with expensive extra's or is that a base-price?

It could make a big difference. Test cars are often full specced.

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Citroën C3 Aircross
    First Drive
    17 October 2017
    The Citroen C3 Aircross has got funky looks and a charming interior, but it's another small SUV, and another dynamic miss. Numb steering is just one thing keeping it from class best
  • Skoda-Karoq 2.0 TDI 4x4
    First Drive
    16 October 2017
    Diesel version of Skoda’s junior SUV is unobtrusive and undemanding, but we’d still go for the silkier petrol version of the Karoq
  • Audi Q7 e-tron
    First Drive
    16 October 2017
    Expensive and flawed but this understated diesel-electric Audi Q7 has a lot to offer
  • Citroën C3
    First Drive
    16 October 2017
    Is the third gen Citroën C3 ‘fresh and different’ enough to take on its supermini rivals? We spend six months with one to find out
  • BMW X3
    First Drive
    15 October 2017
    A satisfying rework of the X3 that usefully improves its handling, cabin finish, space and connectivity to make this BMW a class front-runner again