Tue
Jul 14 2009

Why GM wants to sell to RHJ, not Magna

Julian Rendell
Interesting that the ‘serious’ newspapers — the FT and Sunday Times — have run a version of our Vauxhall/Opel sell-off story from last week’s mag.

For those that didn’t see it, Vauxhall/Opel’s buyer is now most likely to be a company called RHJ International, a Belgian holding company with very strong links to US buyout firm Ripplewood.



These reports are significant, because this week is meant to mark the final, final deadline for the Vauxhall/Opel sell-off. Although my experience of reporting similar stories in recent years suggests we treat the word ‘final’ with some scepticism.

The Canadian/Russian bid from Magna/Sberbank has fallen out of favour for various reason, not the least of which is that GM fancies buying back Vauxhall/Opel in a few years time.

I’m told that a buy-back clause for GM to take back control of Vauxhall/Opel is a key part of the sell-off documentation and the Russians/Magna aren’t too keen on it.

Apparently GM’s high-ups in Detroit have also found it much easier to negotiate with RHJ than the Russians, largely because RHJ is run by Americans, namely the financier Tim Collins, who also founded the Ripplewood buyout fund.
The German Unions are said to favour RHJ, too.

A couple of years ago, Ripplewood was one of the bidders for Jaguar Land Rover and enlisted former Ford CEO Nick Scheele to guide its ultimately unsuccessful bid. Former Chrysler exec Tom Stallkamp is also an advisor to Ripplewood, so there’s potentially heavyweight automotive advice on hand.

RHJ also has an automotive bias to its investment holdings. It has a 37 per cent share of Japanese casting company Asahi Tec, which also incorporates US metal-basher Metaldyne. Asahi Tec actually derives the bulk of its revenue from US car-makers (43 per cent).

Plus it owns Japanese widget maker U-shin, a supplier of automotive door locks, and Belgian aluminium and magnesium castings company HIT.

Not so automotive related are a Japanese holiday company Phoenix Resport, which used to own the world’s biggest swimming pool, and Columbia Music Entertainment. Columbia was a Ripplewood Investment, but transferred to RHJ.

What we don’t know exactly is what plans RHJ has for Vauxhall/Opel, although my guess is that it will go along with whatever GM, now rumoured to be eyeing a 45 per cent in its spun-off European business, wants.

Think of RHJ as temporary investors in Vauxhall/Opel. Ferrari did something similar a few years ago.

RHJ’s investment gives GM a handy capital boost and when times get better in a couple of years, GM invokes the buy-back clause. Then RHJ walks away with a handsome profit and GM gets its European businesses back. Nice deal.

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About Julian Rendell

The man with the legendary contacts book. Once went 'under the wire' to scoop a secret Honda; also navigated a Fiat 127 in a road rally. Says the latter was only marginally more risky.

Comments

ordinary bloke July 14, 2009 10:21 AM

So, instead of Vauxhall/Opel geting the chance become an independant and innovative company free to play in a wider field, it will just be held in limbo until the dead hand of GM takes over again and sucks the profit out of its only truly innovative and viable brand. At least SAAB has got away.

obamabeach July 14, 2009 10:57 AM

"The German Unions are said to favour RHJ, too."

- what's your source(s) for that?

does IG Metall count as a German union? (2.4m members, largest industrial union in Germany en.wikipedia.org/.../IG_Metall)

'Magna International Inc.’s bid for General Motors Corp.’s Opel and Vauxhall brands provides the only “long-term industrial concept” for the European operations, Armin Schild, a labor representative on Opel’s board, said.

Magna offered “detailed planning” for the GM Europe division, while bringing proposals by Beijing Automotive Industry Holding Co. and RHJ International SA under discussion now “can be nothing more than a distraction,” Schild said in an e-mailed reply to questions. ' 13/7/2009

www.bloomberg.com/.../news

that's Armin Schild, head of IG Metall for the region that includes Opel's HQ in Ruesselsheim and Board member of Opel.

or:

'Opel workers want Magna'

'Union representatives at the automaker say the Economics Ministry is undermining Magna's position in the take-over battle by providing information to its challengers.'

www.dw-world.de/.../0,,4485151,00.html

Why no mention by Autocar that RHJ reported a huge loss of £1 billion for the year? Where is the money actually coming from for this acquisition of Opel? US govt. money? RHJ/Ripplewood are private equity or Locusts as the Germans refer to such outfits.

Since it is simple to debunk your efforts to betray Ripplewood's bid as having broad support including the unions the question begs itself why is Autocar so transparently shilling for this bid? Could you please explain. Is it a simple pro-American/anti-Russian cultural bias as is usual in UK or have you been co-opted by GM/their proxy Ripplewood to 'sell' the case? I think you should divulge your position.

obamabeach July 14, 2009 10:59 AM

correction, RHJ's loss was €1bn not £1bn.

roadtester July 14, 2009 11:37 AM

Actually, although it pains me to say it, testicle is right on the narrow point about the attitudes of the German unions - like him they are irrational but incorrigible anglophobes and italophobes, so aren't keen on private equity bids or Fiat.

That said, the German unions - and testicle - are, of course, wrong; RHJ or Fiat are far better partners for Opel/Vauxhall in the long run, and present fewer complications from GM's perspective.

Interesting to see GM being more assertive/engaged again after appearing more or less to give up on its European ops a few months ago.

obamabeach July 14, 2009 12:43 PM

oh dear, the gonad man is back again. you'd think someone who bangs on obsessively about 'balls' would have some spunk or even a backbone.

look you creepy tw*t stalking me don't make up for your personality-bypass. now go away you tiresome individual.

In your own time Mr. Rendell with those answers:

where does a €1bn loss outfit get a likewise some at short notice? is RHJ/Ripplewood acting as proxy for GM/US Govt.(majority owners of GM)? is RHJ using some of the $70bn-odd funds passed to 'New GM' by US Govt. for this bid? and why have you distorted the truth on publicly available facts of the support or lack of for RHJ's bid? does this indicate you have some undisclosed tie in with GM/RHJ/Ripplewood?

roadtester July 14, 2009 12:50 PM

@ testicle

The analysis is becoing ever more complicated I suppose we now need to add paranoia and a persecution complex - 'Verfolgungswahn' I think it is in in your mother tongue - to your anglophobia, italophobia, homophobia, misogyny and all the rest.

By the way, we never did establish precisely what great car you, the man who turns his nose up at the stunning XJ, drives himself. What is it exactly?

jackjflash July 14, 2009 2:41 PM

When I saw the blog title I knew it would be like a moth to the flame. Does it really matter who buys Vauxhall/Opel, apart from the Chinese who would probably move manufacturing, the other interested parties look to be interested in building cars at the current factories.

rtwingo July 14, 2009 4:20 PM

Considering Reuters and the Automotive News reported about the RHJ bid long before Autocar, I really can't see the point of the first paragraph.

Dave52 July 14, 2009 7:02 PM

Much as everybody is right about the people who work around me being a bunch of xenophobes and the attitude of the Betriebsrat (effectively the IGMetal) being more than a little stupid, even I don't much like this idea. It's just a way for GM to get their hands on somebody else's money. We'll be hung out to dry until they get round to taking us back and be forced to use some pretty crap platform's along the way. I kept telling 'em, stop telling them you think they're a bunch of useless, dumb, f***** idiots until they're really gone, but nobody in Germany ever listens - too convinced of their own brilliance. I'm not sure the various Länder will cough up their part for this plan though. Zu Guttenberg fancies himself as the next Kanzler, hence the sh*t stirring.

North July 15, 2009 7:39 AM

I think it makes total sense for GM to do this; in fact I did reference they may buy it back.  At the end of the day GM paid for Opel/Vauxhall....the capital company come in, run the business whilst GM build Chevy in the EU.

Then in about four years/five years GM buy Opel/Vauxhall back and end with more of the market than they had before!

God bless GM!......they are without doubt superb; most excellent; Luton should be producing some sort of electric unit by then also i.e. the Volt and or the Volt van version.......the RHJ would work well.

I am still a big fan of Fiat getting it......but the RHJ looks an even stronger bid and it makes more sense for GM.....go RHJ.....bottom line....I do not want Magna getting it and RHJ provides a really neat solution.

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - cover 15.2.12

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>