Feature25 July 2014

Steve Sutcliffe has the keys to two very fast versions of the BMW 3-series: the 435bhp petrol BMW M3 and the 345bhp diesel Alpina D3. Should you satisfy your high-performance saloon cravings with a petrol or a diesel engine? Let's find out.

Join the debate

Comments
27

25 July 2014
A combination of the D3 being really very good, and the M3 being sadly far of the boil. 'M' just isn't what it used to be. But at least you can get a manual gearbox...

25 July 2014
Snog or marry....with someone else's tyres.


25 July 2014
Good job Steve. you have finally exposed M-sport for what they have become- average! Good on you! No one else would ever do a test showing that a diesel BMW is a better all around car- let alone a better handling car than a "genuine" M car!! When we listen to ALL the HYPE from BMW and fanboys like evo magazine and Top gear and Chris Harris. all we get is sterling silver reviews of this new M3 but o how wrong they are. You were the only one with the balls to show this before our eyes. Good job and yes merry christmas, for once. Try to do this more often. j

25 July 2014
@jl4069 - Have you driven both cars? Only if you have can you agree so wholeheartedly with Mr Sutcliffe and write off, Chris Harris, Top Gear, EVO etc as fanboys. PS. I suspect I too would prefer the Alpina, but I wouldn't feel that would give me the right to insult people who choose the M3.

 

 

26 July 2014
...@jl4069 could not have said it better myself..:-) This M will be remembered as the worst of its kind.

25 July 2014
Really interesting to watch and of course the best thing about the Alpina is you can have it as a Touring.

25 July 2014
spot on about the M3 noise/sound Steve. reminds me of the 350Z, not really a great pleaseure to wring the engine out. Alpina looks more tasteful too.

25 July 2014
Who ever bought an M3 because it majored on comfort?

25 July 2014
Do genuine M still exist?

26 July 2014
Sorry I think this complete rubbish, and had to make an account to say so. You're comparing to completely different cars for the sake of bashing the M3. First off the drag race. Not sure if anyone's noticed, but the Alpinas in Sport+ with launch control.. The M3s in comfort with no launch control! Then there's the fact that the Alpinas on empty and the M3s got half a tank of fuel. Not exactly a fair test. Secondly, the speed run. It was done once. Wouldn't a fair test to be doing it 3 times and averaging? I don't think this is a fair review at all, and that Steve is just bashing the M3 to differentiate himself from the other reviewers...

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • First Drive
    3 July 2015
    Charming four-door city car gets Smart's new six-speed dual-clutch automatic gearbox, in a bid to make the Forfour more versatile
  • First Drive
    2 July 2015
    First UK drive in the latest-generation MX-5 reveals an iconic roadster that's back to its best
  • First Drive
    2 July 2015
    Extra firepower and pared-down kerb weight conjure even greater brilliance from the Boxster's chassis. Pricey – but superb to drive
  • First Drive
    1 July 2015
    There's another BMW 2 Series variant on the horizon; we drive a late-stage prototype plug-in hybrid Active Tourer
  • BMW's prototype fuel cell concept is based on the 5GT
    First Drive
    1 July 2015
    Fuel cell-powered 5 Series GT concept previews a revolutionary storage and refuelling system which could pave the way for hydrogen to become the alternative fuel of choice

Latest videos